Anonymous
03/17/2021 22:30
Subject: Predictions on how many TJ applicants there will be this year?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What no one wants to admit is that the kids who will be most impacted by these changes are the relatively mediocre kids who have always been able to pose as talented through artificially inflated exam scores. It’s not like the actual cream of the crop is going to be impacted by these changes in any way.
You just have a ton of parents who are afraid that their dime-a-dozen kid is gonna get exposed for what they are, when that kid would have far better college prospects at their base school anyway.
Reality check: FCPS doesn’t manage anything that requires a lot of discretion properly do the idea that they are suddenly going to be able to conduct a “holistic review” of TJ application to select a better qualified class is an exercise that goes beyond wishful thinking into pure cynicism. It will appear better to those who always wanted overt tokenism and little else on full display.
This is actually a really good point. But they were using a largely holistic review process to get from the semifinal cut to the final group anyway.
Yes, that was to keep the class from being 90% Asian. There was a lawsuit over that too (Dr. Cohen from GMU sued FCPS 20 years ago)
Anonymous
03/17/2021 21:51
Subject: Predictions on how many TJ applicants there will be this year?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What no one wants to admit is that the kids who will be most impacted by these changes are the relatively mediocre kids who have always been able to pose as talented through artificially inflated exam scores. It’s not like the actual cream of the crop is going to be impacted by these changes in any way.
You just have a ton of parents who are afraid that their dime-a-dozen kid is gonna get exposed for what they are, when that kid would have far better college prospects at their base school anyway.
Reality check: FCPS doesn’t manage anything that requires a lot of discretion properly do the idea that they are suddenly going to be able to conduct a “holistic review” of TJ application to select a better qualified class is an exercise that goes beyond wishful thinking into pure cynicism. It will appear better to those who always wanted overt tokenism and little else on full display.
This is actually a really good point. But they were using a largely holistic review process to get from the semifinal cut to the final group anyway.
Anonymous
03/17/2021 21:13
Subject: Predictions on how many TJ applicants there will be this year?
Anonymous wrote:What no one wants to admit is that the kids who will be most impacted by these changes are the relatively mediocre kids who have always been able to pose as talented through artificially inflated exam scores. It’s not like the actual cream of the crop is going to be impacted by these changes in any way.
You just have a ton of parents who are afraid that their dime-a-dozen kid is gonna get exposed for what they are, when that kid would have far better college prospects at their base school anyway.
Reality check: FCPS doesn’t manage anything that requires a lot of discretion properly do the idea that they are suddenly going to be able to conduct a “holistic review” of TJ application to select a better qualified class is an exercise that goes beyond wishful thinking into pure cynicism. It will appear better to those who always wanted overt tokenism and little else on full display.