Anonymous
Post 11/23/2019 19:31     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

What is an all star team
Anonymous
Post 11/23/2019 15:53     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:11:53 here, I'm a rec only parent. Caring about "seeding" here is silly. Every team in every bracket has a chance to win.


Lol


why is this funny? At this tournament, its 100% true.


Herndon parent here-it is not unusual at this tournament for a lower-seeded team to win the bracket. Lots of All star teams barely practice together before the short Saturday games, so they can be kind of random.
Anonymous
Post 11/23/2019 15:43     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:11:53 here, I'm a rec only parent. Caring about "seeding" here is silly. Every team in every bracket has a chance to win.


Lol


why is this funny? At this tournament, its 100% true.
Anonymous
Post 11/23/2019 13:36     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:11:53 here, I'm a rec only parent. Caring about "seeding" here is silly. Every team in every bracket has a chance to win.


Lol
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2019 10:09     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:"to no ones surprise" ??? really

If you read the posters entire post, I believe this poster means they have been a good team for awhile. Both of these current U12 teams have been 1st or 2nd the last four seasons of All Stars.


Wasn't McLean also the #1 seed going into Sunday's finals?


Ok, enough, it is a fun rec tournament. Lets stop with talking about "seeding". These are not established teams like travel and how kids are selected will vary across the clubs. Enjoy it for what it is if your kid plays rec.


Wow you travel parents certainly seem testy. No need to be dismissive.

Why so defensive?


Not defensive at all, just putting some perspective on the tournament.

1. The nature of player selection varies across the clubs. Larger rec programs may ask for each rec team to provide one or two players. How those players are selected per team may also vary but it is always safe to assume the coaches kid will be one of them. Some clubs may offer an open tryout and some clubs are small enough that essentially most of the rec team may participate.

2. No single age group is similarly represented from year to year as is the nature of rec soccer. Kids come and go and keeping a team together year after year can prove to be very difficult into the travel age years.

3. The teams general do not get to practice together and if they do it is only a couple of times before the tournament.

4. The tournament is intended to be a reward for the best players in the rec program and to offer them the opportunity to play external competition and to enjoy a tournament setting that they otherwise would not experience in rec other than the occasional end of season jubilee if the club offers one.

For all of these reason, actual "seeding" is extremely difficult and the best effort to try and ensure a competitive balance is hard. So with all that said, yes, don't give the seeding a second thought.
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2019 08:30     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

11:53 here, I'm a rec only parent. Caring about "seeding" here is silly. Every team in every bracket has a chance to win.
Anonymous
Post 11/21/2019 19:45     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:"to no ones surprise" ??? really

If you read the posters entire post, I believe this poster means they have been a good team for awhile. Both of these current U12 teams have been 1st or 2nd the last four seasons of All Stars.


Wasn't McLean also the #1 seed going into Sunday's finals?


Ok, enough, it is a fun rec tournament. Lets stop with talking about "seeding". These are not established teams like travel and how kids are selected will vary across the clubs. Enjoy it for what it is if your kid plays rec.


Wow you travel parents certainly seem testy. No need to be dismissive.

Why so defensive?
Anonymous
Post 11/21/2019 11:53     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Right, the seeding is pretty random based on mini games and the multiple brackets are also random. It doesn’t have some deeper meaning-it’s just the way they schedule the tournament games. I am sure low “seeds” won across lots of age groups.
Anonymous
Post 11/21/2019 11:04     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:"to no ones surprise" ??? really

If you read the posters entire post, I believe this poster means they have been a good team for awhile. Both of these current U12 teams have been 1st or 2nd the last four seasons of All Stars.


Wasn't McLean also the #1 seed going into Sunday's finals?


Ok, enough, it is a fun rec tournament. Lets stop with talking about "seeding". These are not established teams like travel and how kids are selected will vary across the clubs. Enjoy it for what it is if your kid plays rec.
Anonymous
Post 11/21/2019 11:01     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:"to no ones surprise" ??? really

If you read the posters entire post, I believe this poster means they have been a good team for awhile. Both of these current U12 teams have been 1st or 2nd the last four seasons of All Stars.


Wasn't McLean also the #1 seed going into Sunday's finals?
Anonymous
Post 11/21/2019 09:07     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:"to no ones surprise" ??? really

If you read the posters entire post, I believe this poster means they have been a good team for awhile. Both of these current U12 teams have been 1st or 2nd the last four seasons of All Stars.


That’s one way to spin it

It came across a different way.
Anonymous
Post 11/20/2019 19:34     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:"to no ones surprise" ??? really

If you read the posters entire post, I believe this poster means they have been a good team for awhile. Both of these current U12 teams have been 1st or 2nd the last four seasons of All Stars.
Anonymous
Post 11/20/2019 15:08     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We had a kid in this tournament and it was so fun!
Our age group was mostly great support by parents, but I did see some others get ugly.
I don’t care that these kids may or may not be as good as travel teams. It’s for the love of the game and it was really fun to watch.


Agree 100%!

McLean was seeded #1 going into Sunday's finals, to no ones surprise. Sadly, the U12 girls could not duplicate their win over GFR at the last Father's Day All-Stars tournament.

The 2020 re-match can't come soon enough.


why was the GFR team wearing eye liner on their faces on a cloudy day??


They are tough
Anonymous
Post 11/20/2019 14:26     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We had a kid in this tournament and it was so fun!
Our age group was mostly great support by parents, but I did see some others get ugly.
I don’t care that these kids may or may not be as good as travel teams. It’s for the love of the game and it was really fun to watch.


Agree 100%!

McLean was seeded #1 going into Sunday's finals, to no ones surprise. Sadly, the U12 girls could not duplicate their win over GFR at the last Father's Day All-Stars tournament.

The 2020 re-match can't come soon enough.


why was the GFR team wearing eye liner on their faces on a cloudy day??
Anonymous
Post 11/20/2019 14:21     Subject: U12 girls Herndon Youth Soccer All-Star Tournament on November 16-17th

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We had a kid in this tournament and it was so fun!
Our age group was mostly great support by parents, but I did see some others get ugly.
I don’t care that these kids may or may not be as good as travel teams. It’s for the love of the game and it was really fun to watch.


Agree 100%!

McLean was seeded #1 going into Sunday's finals, to no ones surprise. Sadly, the U12 girls could not duplicate their win over GFR at the last Father's Day All-Stars tournament.

The 2020 re-match can't come soon enough.


for the kids or the parents??