Anonymous wrote:I'm a landlord on Capitol Hill and I would never raise a tenant's rent just because they had a baby and I expected more wear and tear. BUT, I was at one time a tenant who got dinged for what I considered absurd wear and tear offenses (I once lost $400 of a security deposit because the landlord said there were a couple of crumbs in a kitchen drawer - my naked eye did not detect them!) so perhaps I am more sympathetic and expect people to live in the house comfortably and sometimes that means scuffs on the floor.
All that said, my property taxes go up every year unfortunately and there comes a point when you're questioning how profitable it is to be a landlord. I've never raised the rent on a tenant but I've raised it between tenants to account for the increased property taxes. If I had a tenant who stayed a few years I'd probably be forced to raise the rent. Just posting this to consider the standpoint of the landlord - they often have increased expenses too so it is hard to take into account the financial circumstances of your tenants. Good luck to you and your husband as you welcome your new babies into the world!
Anonymous wrote:OP, no one here announcing that being month to month makes you more vulnerable knows anything about DC tenant law. Call the Office of the Tenant Advocate and get informed about your rights.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:sarah1513 wrote:Anonymous wrote:1) Don't tell him. Don't hide it, but there are too many unknowns. The chance that he'll think, "ooh! they have new expenses, I shouldn't raise their rent" approaches zero. It is more likely he'll think either, "kids are destructive," or "that's more than two people," and try to force you out somehow or make you sign a new lease with built-in rent increases.
2) Talk to someone at the rent board about the occupancy situation. There are a number of competing laws at play here, and it is difficult to evict in DC, but why give him the opportunity to try to get you out before you know how strong your footing is to fight it?
Likely nothing is going to happen and all will be well. Renting is always stressful for these kinds of reasons, but it is generally best to not rock the boat if there's a potential downside that's worse than doing nothing.
Thanks. I just mentioned in reply to someone else, but I have a message in at the tenant advocate office to ask about this.
I don't think he can make us sign a new lease if we're otherwise compliant and have transitioned to month to month? But maybe if there is a loophole with having children.
Since you are month to month, he can require you to sign a new lease at any time. You can choose not to by deciding to move out instead.
You’re not from around here, are you?
Anonymous wrote:I’m a twin mom sitting here laughing at OPs naïveté
sarah1513 wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is all a business transaction. Dont think you are something special and rare bc you're expecting twins.
Not saying we're special (although technically, it IS rare!) but given that we're dealing with huge financial costs for all of this, and that we're dealing with an individual landlord, not a corporate one, we're thinking of it as trying to make a human appeal and see what happens.
sarah1513 wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I'm not sure what good would come of telling him explicitly. I definitely would not expect it to effect the rent in a favorable way, especially if he's not the warm and fuzzy type. Does occupancy law override something specifically address in the lease you signed?
+1. I would be sure that the DC tenancy laws do in fact apply given that they are specifically counter to the lease you signed.
Agreed. I have a call in to the office of the Tenant Advocate to double check.
Really, I'm thinking that the language in the lease is truly just the "fill in the blank template" that the management company uses for every lease and they plug in the number of tenants on the lease and move on.
Also, our lease also specifically says we had to get permission and pay a $300 deposit to get a pet and when we went to pay the deposit for our dog (after already having gotten permission) he was like "what? you don't need to pay me, I trust you."
We're planning to tell him because it seems really weird and like we're hiding something for him not to know. And I'm hoping maybe it will make him feel guilty about giving us a significant rent increase when I know that it's not really merited by the market etc.
Anonymous wrote:sarah1513 wrote:Anonymous wrote:1) Don't tell him. Don't hide it, but there are too many unknowns. The chance that he'll think, "ooh! they have new expenses, I shouldn't raise their rent" approaches zero. It is more likely he'll think either, "kids are destructive," or "that's more than two people," and try to force you out somehow or make you sign a new lease with built-in rent increases.
2) Talk to someone at the rent board about the occupancy situation. There are a number of competing laws at play here, and it is difficult to evict in DC, but why give him the opportunity to try to get you out before you know how strong your footing is to fight it?
Likely nothing is going to happen and all will be well. Renting is always stressful for these kinds of reasons, but it is generally best to not rock the boat if there's a potential downside that's worse than doing nothing.
Thanks. I just mentioned in reply to someone else, but I have a message in at the tenant advocate office to ask about this.
I don't think he can make us sign a new lease if we're otherwise compliant and have transitioned to month to month? But maybe if there is a loophole with having children.
Since you are month to month, he can require you to sign a new lease at any time. You can choose not to by deciding to move out instead.
sarah1513 wrote:Anonymous wrote:I am a landlord and I rent/deal with my own landlord and I have twins.
NO! Don't tell and don't try to illicit pity. It is a huge financial cost but every landlord I have dealt with (mostly in Boston) have been horrible horrible money grubbing people. Having kids is a private matter.
Now, I do suggest you check for lead paint because lead poisoning sucks and it is harder to corral 2.
Thank you for the specific advice based on your experience. If we have the no lead paint confirmation in our lease do you feel like that covers that issue?
Anonymous wrote:I am a landlord and my lease (the gcaar one) says that 2 people may occupy the unit, plus any children they have on their own or adopted.