Anonymous
Post 06/10/2025 08:36     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Anonymous wrote:I'm a Parisian and this post is horrifying.
Have you looked at the ingredients? It's 1/2 car tire. No wonder you all look the way you look.


You sure sound Parisian...
Anonymous
Post 06/09/2025 20:14     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Anonymous wrote:I love the Whole Foods Berry Chantilly cake. My family and I have gotten it for all my promotions and significant events.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/02/dining/whole-foods-berry-chantilly-cake.html


Got this for my mother’s birthday last month. Incredible. But for a kids party or work celebration sheet sheet cakes from Costco or Wegmans is the way to go.
Anonymous
Post 06/09/2025 19:45     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Anonymous wrote:I love the Whole Foods Berry Chantilly cake. My family and I have gotten it for all my promotions and significant events.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/02/dining/whole-foods-berry-chantilly-cake.html


this one is fantastic. I haven’t had a great experience with many of their other cakes though.
Anonymous
Post 06/09/2025 01:11     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
I love Whole Foods cake also , depends on which flavor; Wegmans chocolate and all other flavors, Whole Foods.
Anonymous
Post 06/09/2025 01:05     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
I love the Whole Foods Berry Chantilly cake. My family and I have gotten it for all my promotions and significant events.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/02/dining/whole-foods-berry-chantilly-cake.html
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 23:01     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Anonymous wrote:Hmm. I really don't think you know what a good cake is. The fancy ones may just have had better decor. That's OK, it's not your fault, they're really hard to find in the US. One day you'll try a really good French, Korean or Japanese cake (because they built their own recipes on the original French) and you'll know the difference. They have way less sugar, and they put all their efforts into the crumb/texture of the cake and the taste. Not with artificial ingredients.



I am one of the pro wegmans poster. I definitely do not think wegmans is the best cake possible or am trying to compare them to high end cakes. I honestly think that most of the PPs like me are saying that it is tastier and more comforting than many other options. I paid $50 for a 6” cake from a small bakery and it was absolutely delicious. Obviously I’m not comparing to that. But that price is not very accessible and I do think wegmans is exceptional for the price and doesn’t taste super processed.
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 21:53     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
I'm a Parisian and this post is horrifying.
Have you looked at the ingredients? It's 1/2 car tire. No wonder you all look the way you look.
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 21:43     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
I like the Wegmans specialty cakes, but once I got the regular birthday cake (2 layer) and the frosting got too soft when it wasn’t refrigerated and the cake just fell apart.
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 21:31     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Ugh, store bought cakes are so bad and it's so easy to make one yourself from scratch. You can do it in the time it takes to pick one up from the store. Try it--you won't go back.


Agree. I made my DH a chocolate cake from scratch for his birthday. It was so much better than anything from a mix and so much better than anything from a grocery store. It was better than cakes from bakeries as well.



Homemade cakes are great for close family. If it’s someone I don’t know very well and they made a homemade cake-i’m simply not eating it. When you are supplying a cake for an event it makes everyone more comfortable to have a store made/bakery made cake. Also not particularly convenient to make a homemade cake for 30 or more people.


If you are scared to eat cake, your comfort is low on my list of priorities

Three words: Cats on countertops


Three words: you are human.
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 17:24     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
COSTCO. Everything they make is awesome.
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 17:02     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
I don’t like Wegmans sheet cakes but their occasion cakes are amazing. The tiny round vanilla one with buttercream frosting is one of the best I’ve ever had but I’m going to try the others mentioned here now!
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 12:27     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Ugh, store bought cakes are so bad and it's so easy to make one yourself from scratch. You can do it in the time it takes to pick one up from the store. Try it--you won't go back.


Agree. I made my DH a chocolate cake from scratch for his birthday. It was so much better than anything from a mix and so much better than anything from a grocery store. It was better than cakes from bakeries as well.



Homemade cakes are great for close family. If it’s someone I don’t know very well and they made a homemade cake-i’m simply not eating it. When you are supplying a cake for an event it makes everyone more comfortable to have a store made/bakery made cake. Also not particularly convenient to make a homemade cake for 30 or more people.


If you are scared to eat cake, your comfort is low on my list of priorities

Three words: Cats on countertops
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 09:43     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Wegmans sheet cake with fresh fruit filling and buttercream icing is my favorite. I bought one once to a party at work and now it is requested for every work event we have!
Anonymous
Post 06/08/2025 09:20     Subject: I have had so many fancy cakes...wegmans is still my favorite.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You need to go to Austria and try their tortes. And countries around that make the same. There is a cake and then there are Viennese tortes. Heaven in the mouth.


The taste is very different. I lived in Germany and disliked the desserts. Black Forest cake is gross. They have no flavor. They look incredible and you think it’s going to be great. I only eat one bite, because it’s so disappointing. I feel the same about Korean dessert. Just too bland.

If you like American crème brûlée, cookies, brownies, or pies, the level of sweetness is much more intense than European and Asian desserts.

I do enjoy wegmans and balduccis desserts. Wegmans cakes, fruit tarts, and macaroons are delish. Balduccis chocolate cake is really good. Whole Foods used to have a yellow and choclo layer cake that was amazing. I also like their chocolate mousse.


I travel to Germany and other Northern European countries enough and there's no shortage of that awful sugary fondant / glaze on so many of their baked sweets that adds a pointless layer of sugar on an already sweet item. Will concur on the whole Americans win by a landslide for sugary sweetness but it's also pretty easy to avoid excess sugar in the US. Just don't go to the Cheesecake factory!