Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I wouldn't say she's overthinking it so much as she is pushing back on and gathering as much information (information is power!) about a course of action her doctor is pushing, as if her getting pre-E diagnosis is fait accompli and not a relatively unlikely scenario given her general health and the fact that her BP has been only MILDLY elevated at most, and it has stayed at consistent levels rather than climbing towards the end, thoughout her pregnancy (If I'm reading correctly). She seems to be reacting to a legitimate ham-handed diagnosis and suggested plan of attack from her doctors by gathering all of her information, which I personally think is prudent. The magnesium worries may be getting ahead of herself but I can see my head going there, too. ONce your doctor who you've been seeing says something like "well, you're probably going to get prme-E, and if you do, we'll induce" who can blame you for researching and vetting your concerns about induction?
As far as not getting an epi unless it is required, I don't read setting up for failure in that. I just think giving birth without drugs generally appeals to determined people, and OP is determined to do it that way if she can, recognizing her circumstances might dictate a change from the plan. This is how I felt about my own first birth, and although I would not have ruled out an epidural under circumstances, I also believed in my body and my ability to cope without drugs. Had drugs been necessary (to bring down my BP, to give me rest after a long labor, and if were prevented from using other pain management techniques for genuine safety reasons, like moving around, etc) then yep, I would have gotten an epidural without a single regret. So there's no real need to counsel women out of feeling determined about what they want in childbirth. We all know that life throws curveballs, we all adapt. there's a difference between being rigid and being determined, IMHO.
Yeah right, those of us who get epidurals are just not determined enough?
There was a mom on DCUM who posted a while back about how she believes her "determination" to avoid induction at all costs lead to her child's brain damage. She may or may not be correct about causation. But what seems clear is that some women are not so much determined about it, but have a sort of phobia or superstitious belief about interventions that really does not serve them well.
Why so defensive? You are inventing an argument here where this is not one. I never said nor would I say that women who do get epidurals are not sufficiently determined. We all have different perspectives here, and nobody's feelings or decisions are invalid.
On the other hand, some women seem to lump all of us who ARE determined to forego pharmaceutical pain relief in one lump category of "crazies" after nothing more than some sort of meta "experience," as if there can't be genuine and real reasons that a woman might choose or aim for different things than you or others did? Likening the decision to avoid pain medication if possible to voodoo or a phobia is just silly and completely simplistic / reductionist. Case in point, see your above, absolutely irrelevant story about brain damage. There is no call for comparing someone who is genuinely seeking evidence-based care and asking questions about her care (who has clearly said all along she'll HAVE the induction if it is best for baby) and is seeking to have a minimum of interventions otherwise to someone who you characterize as "determined to avoid induction at all costs." Who has described such a scenario here? Not me, and by my read, not OP.
I'm NOT going to keep hashing out the issue of "to have an epidural or not" with you here, you can start your own thread if you want that fight and I'm sure you can poke the mommy war beast into a 10 page response. But I wanted to go on record to say your comparison is unfair and highly inaccurate in terms of capturing how I and many people like me approach the issue of interventions. Seeking evidence-based care, and forgoing pain meds is NOT voodoo or crazy stuff. It's a legitimate choice, and it has NO bearing on your choice. really, it's not all about you.