This milk is not natural and is suspicious it smelled and tasted like fish. The milk is not expired yet. There is no option on the phone to complain. If I don't get a reply in 48 hours I will complain this to BBB and other federal agencies. I don't think cows eat fish btw. :)

I am so happy to find this post! I thought I was going crazy! Then I thought maybe my espresso machine had a problem. I make mochas all the time in my home. I thought maybe the milk was spoiled. I never thought it was a particular milk. Now I find that two organic milk companies milk is awful when steamed.

Have noticed the fish taste a few times in the last month or so. Today opened a brand new half gallon of Horizon Organic w/ DHA and the taste was so strong that I poured my glass in the sink. Several other people here at work tried it and agreed that the milk had such a fish taste that they couldn't drink it.

Yeah, I noticed it was awful as an ingredient. My son seemed to like drinking it cold, though.

Got the milk from Sam's Club in Gaithersburg, MD, and it smelled and tasted like fishy

Has horizon made comment? It is rancid? Or is this how it's supposed to taste? If it's become oxidized it can actually be harmful I'm pretty sure... If it's rancid they need to pull it

I have never been so thankful that I buy el cheap Aldi milk for $1.49. Never ever had a fish taste. I can't even imagine. Yuck!

Horizon sucks. Look at the Cornucopia Institute's ratings of organic dairies. Horizon ranks pretty poorly.

The "soy milk" Silk has a terrible fish taste too.

Honestly, horizon milk just always taste nasty to me. I stick with Organic Valley followed by WF's organic milk if they are out of Organic Valley. I find that the taste of organic milk really varies by brand.

Anonymous wrote:I almost throw up. I used omega 3 milk to make my biscuits and gravy and it was the absolute worse thing I've ever cook. It tasted like fish OMG I HATE FISH...................... NEVER BAKE OR COOK with this type milk EVER

Congrats on replying to a thread from 2011.

I can definitely taste an off taste. It must be the algae xDHA. No more buying this nasty tasting stuff. Eat sardines! The regular Horizon whole milk tastes normal.

I almost throw up. I used omega 3 milk to make my biscuits and gravy and it was the absolute worse thing I've ever cook. It tasted like fish OMG I HATE FISH...................... NEVER BAKE OR COOK with this type milk EVER

I had the same issue with their organic fruit snacks. I brought them home from the grocery store and the only thing I could think of after eating them was, "This tastes like fish." Absolutely disgusting!!!

Anonymous wrote:Good lord people. Why are you drinking that stuff? Get yourselves some real milk from a local farmer that feeds his cows on grass. It will taste awesome and have plenty of DHA.

If you want extra DHA, take a vitamin or something.

+100