Anonymous wrote:Melt and learning loss are much worse the longer summers are, it’s not really a question. If you don’t supplement or maintain at all- and let’s be honest here most dc families do not, for various reasons- kids who are on average pretty far behind only fall further behind. Shorter summers are just much better for kids unless you think you- the parent- add more educational value than a school.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:DCPS is not going to eliminate summer, so this is a moot argument.
They are also not going to lengthen summer because despite the myopia of people on this board, the majority of students in DCPS come from poor, working class, and middle class families who are not spending summer traveling internationally and crafting bespoke experiences for their children. Most families in DCPS are struggling to cover childcare so they can continue going to their full time jobs that also don't take a break in the summer.
If you want more control over your family's schedule, homeschooling is a viable option for families with a lot of resources who want to be able to take longer breaks and travel more. There are homeschool collectives in DC that even provide group class experiences, field trips, and other programming so that your child still gets a communal education.
DCPS is not a bespoke, custom-for-you educational opportunity. It's a public school district. If you are sitting around on DCUM at 10:30am on a Tuesday lamenting 8-9 weeks is simply not enough time to fit in all your leisure activity during the summer, you are not the average DCPS family and are going to have to work that problem out for yourself.
I know self-awareness is hard, but it's not THIS hard, folks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DC used to have 1 more week of summer so it is doable. They require way too many PD days. https://dcps.dc.gov/sites/default/files/dc/sites/dcps/publication/attachments/DCPS%20School%20Calendar%202007-2008.pdf
Anonymous wrote:DCPS is not going to eliminate summer, so this is a moot argument.
They are also not going to lengthen summer because despite the myopia of people on this board, the majority of students in DCPS come from poor, working class, and middle class families who are not spending summer traveling internationally and crafting bespoke experiences for their children. Most families in DCPS are struggling to cover childcare so they can continue going to their full time jobs that also don't take a break in the summer.
If you want more control over your family's schedule, homeschooling is a viable option for families with a lot of resources who want to be able to take longer breaks and travel more. There are homeschool collectives in DC that even provide group class experiences, field trips, and other programming so that your child still gets a communal education.
DCPS is not a bespoke, custom-for-you educational opportunity. It's a public school district. If you are sitting around on DCUM at 10:30am on a Tuesday lamenting 8-9 weeks is simply not enough time to fit in all your leisure activity during the summer, you are not the average DCPS family and are going to have to work that problem out for yourself.
I know self-awareness is hard, but it's not THIS hard, folks.
Anonymous wrote:How utterly depressing to take away summer for kids and force them to be in school.
I guess you could make a case for the kids who need it and are so, so far below grade level.
But the rest, no way. We would pivot to private if that was the case. Oh and the parents in the popular charters would have a huge uproar over this and it won’t be happening in the popular charters.
DCPS could do this and the SES divide would be even greater between DCPS and charters as charters bleed higher income families.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:You know how this would work in high school? First, you will have a sports/modelUN/robotics/etc commitment on everyone of those Fall, Winter, or Spring breaks that no one else has.
Your child won't be able to have a summer job or internship. Just misc dats during the year to play video games.
Forget summer school.
Do any of you visit relatives with kids outside of DC during the summer?
Forget seeing cousins.
Love this take. Too many families don’t expect their kids to work anymore. Having a longer break in the summer is so important for kids to find other ways to engage outside of school and for parents to have a consistent and predictable schedule for finding consistent alternative care.
Seriously, there is more to a kids life then school esp if that kid is doing fine.
Summer is for travel, seeing families, fun camps, pools days, etc…
Take away summer and you will see so many UMC families leave DCPS…….. It’s bad enough the shirt summer now and short holiday breaks. The private schools schedules are so much better.
You would all have a FIT if there were LESS school days and summer break was 9-10 weeks.
Nope. I wish my kid had 10-12 weeks off like I did as a kid. I can’t fit everything in that he wants to do in the summer and travel because it’s so short!
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:You know how this would work in high school? First, you will have a sports/modelUN/robotics/etc commitment on everyone of those Fall, Winter, or Spring breaks that no one else has.
Your child won't be able to have a summer job or internship. Just misc dats during the year to play video games.
Forget summer school.
Do any of you visit relatives with kids outside of DC during the summer?
Forget seeing cousins.
Love this take. Too many families don’t expect their kids to work anymore. Having a longer break in the summer is so important for kids to find other ways to engage outside of school and for parents to have a consistent and predictable schedule for finding consistent alternative care.
Seriously, there is more to a kids life then school esp if that kid is doing fine.
Summer is for travel, seeing families, fun camps, pools days, etc…
Take away summer and you will see so many UMC families leave DCPS…….. It’s bad enough the shirt summer now and short holiday breaks. The private schools schedules are so much better.
You would all have a FIT if there were LESS school days and summer break was 9-10 weeks.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:You know how this would work in high school? First, you will have a sports/modelUN/robotics/etc commitment on everyone of those Fall, Winter, or Spring breaks that no one else has.
Your child won't be able to have a summer job or internship. Just misc dats during the year to play video games.
Forget summer school.
Do any of you visit relatives with kids outside of DC during the summer?
Forget seeing cousins.
Love this take. Too many families don’t expect their kids to work anymore. Having a longer break in the summer is so important for kids to find other ways to engage outside of school and for parents to have a consistent and predictable schedule for finding consistent alternative care.
Seriously, there is more to a kids life then school esp if that kid is doing fine.
Summer is for travel, seeing families, fun camps, pools days, etc…
Take away summer and you will see so many UMC families leave DCPS…….. It’s bad enough the shirt summer now and short holiday breaks. The private schools schedules are so much better.
You would all have a FIT if there were LESS school days and summer break was 9-10 weeks.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:You know how this would work in high school? First, you will have a sports/modelUN/robotics/etc commitment on everyone of those Fall, Winter, or Spring breaks that no one else has.
Your child won't be able to have a summer job or internship. Just misc dats during the year to play video games.
Forget summer school.
Do any of you visit relatives with kids outside of DC during the summer?
Forget seeing cousins.
Love this take. Too many families don’t expect their kids to work anymore. Having a longer break in the summer is so important for kids to find other ways to engage outside of school and for parents to have a consistent and predictable schedule for finding consistent alternative care.
Seriously, there is more to a kids life then school esp if that kid is doing fine.
Summer is for travel, seeing families, fun camps, pools days, etc…
Take away summer and you will see so many UMC families leave DCPS…….. It’s bad enough the shirt summer now and short holiday breaks. The private schools schedules are so much better.
You would all have a FIT if there were LESS school days and summer break was 9-10 weeks.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:You know how this would work in high school? First, you will have a sports/modelUN/robotics/etc commitment on everyone of those Fall, Winter, or Spring breaks that no one else has.
Your child won't be able to have a summer job or internship. Just misc dats during the year to play video games.
Forget summer school.
Do any of you visit relatives with kids outside of DC during the summer?
Forget seeing cousins.
Love this take. Too many families don’t expect their kids to work anymore. Having a longer break in the summer is so important for kids to find other ways to engage outside of school and for parents to have a consistent and predictable schedule for finding consistent alternative care.
Seriously, there is more to a kids life then school esp if that kid is doing fine.
Summer is for travel, seeing families, fun camps, pools days, etc…
Take away summer and you will see so many UMC families leave DCPS…….. It’s bad enough the shirt summer now and short holiday breaks. The private schools schedules are so much better.
Anonymous wrote:You know how this would work in high school? First, you will have a sports/modelUN/robotics/etc commitment on everyone of those Fall, Winter, or Spring breaks that no one else has.
Your child won't be able to have a summer job or internship. Just misc dats during the year to play video games.
Forget summer school.
Do any of you visit relatives with kids outside of DC during the summer? Forget seeing cousins.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:You know how this would work in high school? First, you will have a sports/modelUN/robotics/etc commitment on everyone of those Fall, Winter, or Spring breaks that no one else has.
Your child won't be able to have a summer job or internship. Just misc dats during the year to play video games.
Forget summer school.
Do any of you visit relatives with kids outside of DC during the summer?
Forget seeing cousins.
Love this take. Too many families don’t expect their kids to work anymore. Having a longer break in the summer is so important for kids to find other ways to engage outside of school and for parents to have a consistent and predictable schedule for finding consistent alternative care.
Seriously, there is more to a kids life then school esp if that kid is doing fine.
Summer is for travel, seeing families, fun camps, pools days, etc…
Take away summer and you will see so many UMC families leave DCPS…….. It’s bad enough the shirt summer now and short holiday breaks. The private schools schedules are so much better.