Anonymous wrote:I am slowly making my way through this show but there are so many consistency flaws. Cady is reading Caste in 2016, but it didn’t come out until 2020. Ed makes a reference to Ice Spice when he asks Johnny about marrying his mom, but Ice Spice was only 16 years old in 2016. It’s just sloppy.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:In the book, it is rather obvious that the two brown people are not really a welcome presence. Tolerated more like it and they know it.
So I don't understand why they keep showing up year after year. The uncle brings his nephew. Uncle is merely one of the Sinclair women's boyfriend and she will never marry him because they all openly know it would jeopardize her inheritance.
Th nephew - doesn't his mother have any summer activities for that child ever? Why is so always packing him off to a place he knows isn't welcoming of him? As an Indian son, she would have been much more involved and protective of her child.
The immigrants in his story lack personal dignity and as an immigrant, their eager submissiveness to being an unwanted presence is just embarrassing. I guess white folks expect to see us groveling to be at their mighty summer island.
The most unbelievable part is that this guy who has no personal stake in the family would participate in the arson. I mean, what guest does that?

In the show they made Gat’s mom really young and crude. She curses up a storm constantly in a way that was shocking as and acts like his buddy more than like a mom. And yes, it made zero sense Gat would participate. It’s pure insanity to most people to set fire to a house!!!

The writers know nothing about being an Indian immigrant. The have painted him as a lower class child of a single mother American style although he is presented like an Indian Brahmin caste.
I am not even Indian and I know about their caste system.

What? How on earth did you get that? I am Indian Brahmin and didnt think that at all. I haven’t read the book so I figured they were not Indian in the book, given their names (I know there are Indian Christians so could have been that as well).

I personally appreciated that the mom was not a stereotypical Indian mom. And it’s totally possible that the mom wasn’t well off, given that her husband died. And she clearly grew up in the US. I know plenty of Indian American women and men who curse plenty. It’s true that they might not in this atmosphere, but as I recall, she was talking to her son not the Sinclairs.

You need to read the book. He is much more self aware of his circumstances and the socioeconomic disparity which brings to question his continuing visits.

Ok, but this discussion is about the tv series on Netflix, where that is not clear at all.

It's clear in the series that the grandfather brushes aside serious discussion of the uncle wanting to marry the grandfather's daughter. And other little things like that which the brown skinned characters can't NOT notice.
The Sinclairs, like most of American society, are polite. They are not in your face about their superiority complex but ignorance and lack of ANY interest in the lives of these brown characters speaks to the invisible divide.

Well, duh. No one was disagreeing with that. You randomly brought caste into it, and that was not included or implied in the show.

Sorry but the Gat guy does not look like an Untouchable. Patel surname is middle Brahmin apparently.

Anonymous wrote:I haven’t finished yet so I’ve not read the full thread, but I had to post. Did anyone else recognize salty Dan?! It’s Mutt from schitts creek!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I haven’t finished yet so I’ve not read the full thread, but I had to post. Did anyone else recognize salty Dan?! It’s Mutt from schitts creek!

Damn it, I didn't. Now I need to go look at him again.

Anonymous wrote:I haven’t finished yet so I’ve not read the full thread, but I had to post. Did anyone else recognize salty Dan?! It’s Mutt from schitts creek!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:In the book, it is rather obvious that the two brown people are not really a welcome presence. Tolerated more like it and they know it.
So I don't understand why they keep showing up year after year. The uncle brings his nephew. Uncle is merely one of the Sinclair women's boyfriend and she will never marry him because they all openly know it would jeopardize her inheritance.
Th nephew - doesn't his mother have any summer activities for that child ever? Why is so always packing him off to a place he knows isn't welcoming of him? As an Indian son, she would have been much more involved and protective of her child.
The immigrants in his story lack personal dignity and as an immigrant, their eager submissiveness to being an unwanted presence is just embarrassing. I guess white folks expect to see us groveling to be at their mighty summer island.
The most unbelievable part is that this guy who has no personal stake in the family would participate in the arson. I mean, what guest does that?

In the show they made Gat’s mom really young and crude. She curses up a storm constantly in a way that was shocking as and acts like his buddy more than like a mom. And yes, it made zero sense Gat would participate. It’s pure insanity to most people to set fire to a house!!!

The writers know nothing about being an Indian immigrant. The have painted him as a lower class child of a single mother American style although he is presented like an Indian Brahmin caste.
I am not even Indian and I know about their caste system.

What? How on earth did you get that? I am Indian Brahmin and didnt think that at all. I haven’t read the book so I figured they were not Indian in the book, given their names (I know there are Indian Christians so could have been that as well).

I personally appreciated that the mom was not a stereotypical Indian mom. And it’s totally possible that the mom wasn’t well off, given that her husband died. And she clearly grew up in the US. I know plenty of Indian American women and men who curse plenty. It’s true that they might not in this atmosphere, but as I recall, she was talking to her son not the Sinclairs.

You need to read the book. He is much more self aware of his circumstances and the socioeconomic disparity which brings to question his continuing visits.

Ok, but this discussion is about the tv series on Netflix, where that is not clear at all.

It's clear in the series that the grandfather brushes aside serious discussion of the uncle wanting to marry the grandfather's daughter. And other little things like that which the brown skinned characters can't NOT notice.
The Sinclairs, like most of American society, are polite. They are not in your face about their superiority complex but ignorance and lack of ANY interest in the lives of these brown characters speaks to the invisible divide.

Well, duh. No one was disagreeing with that. You randomly brought caste into it, and that was not included or implied in the show.

Anonymous wrote:I love Marren. I love her art, her pixie face, her new hair cut, her summer fling and her whole vibe.