Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 15:42     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:Good lord it is because of changing demographics. PERIOD. I’m a 5’4” Jewish woman and I clearly remember being by far the shortest girl in my Midwestern high school filled with mostly ethnic German, Slavic and Scandinavian descent kids. My friends all toward over me at 5’7” at a minimum. As soon as I moved to the East Coast for college, where my classmates were also Jewish, Asian, Italian and Irish, boom I was average height. Yes there are tall Jews and Italians and quite a few Irish and even Asians, but on a whole they are shorter than Norwegians and Serbians. Add in indigenous people from El Salvador and the average American height it going to get shorter.

This isn’t rocket science and there is no need for conspiracy theories on this one.


People, it’s just this.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 14:29     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:No, that's not it, OP. Whites of Scandinavian descent are tall. Hispanic whites are short.

Changing heights are due to changing demographics.


Hello, perhaps you missed this in OP's post:

Around 1980, even native-born White men and women started getting shorter. (We’re looking specifically at Whites because they have the most robust data.)


The definition of "white" in this country has always been a moving target.


So wapo now defines Central americans and Asians as white?


Some of them are.



Grasping at any logic to blame POC


Lots of people from Central and South America are Caucasian.


White South Americans loathe to come to the us as immigrants

White Central Americans are rare and while they aren’t as reticent to come to the us as South Americans, the numbers are minuscule


I’m from Central American and white. White is a race not an ethnicity.


If you really are white Central American you know how limited your numbers are in general and especially in the us

Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 14:01     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Hormones in food. Kids' metabolisms are all messed up, unless parents knew what to avoid in the food chain and cold afford to do so.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 13:56     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Agree it's obviously due to changing demographics. People from difference backgrounds are different heights.


Read the article! They addressed it.


I'm still skeptical. We've had massive demographic changes in the US since 1980 and plenty of white people are white Latinos or have some mixed race heritage but still look very white. Very hard to separate the demographic changes from everything else.

I suspect there's fiddling with data or ignoring unwanted data to make the narrative fit. WaPo does this all the time.


+1 WaPo is a very biased news source. Demographics have changed. That said, it's not clear whether there are other issues such as food additives and pesticides, vaccine side effects, etc. also affecting height.


microplastics. Everywhere. Even found in newborn's poop. It's crazy and recent study there are way more (very alarming numbers of microplastics) in two well-known bottled water companies. They definitely cause harm in the body and interfere with hormones. Packaged food and fast food also have a very high number.


This is scary. DD got the covid vaccines and it changed her period. We had no idea that was even a possible side effect. I've had other permanent side effects from medications. It's alarming how little we know about long-term side effects from things we put into our bodies. The FDA is under a lot of pressure to approve medications. It's a big business with lawyers pushing hard so they can make their billions.

I decided on holding on covid vaxx for my 12 yr old DD who had not started her period at the time because there was not enough study done on prepubescent girls and how the vax would impact them. After hearing about how women's periods were being impacted, we (DH and I both) decided to hold off. DD was eventually fully vaxxed.

DD is now 5.5" at 15, and still growing.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 13:54     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:No, that's not it, OP. Whites of Scandinavian descent are tall. Hispanic whites are short.

Changing heights are due to changing demographics.


Hello, perhaps you missed this in OP's post:

Around 1980, even native-born White men and women started getting shorter. (We’re looking specifically at Whites because they have the most robust data.)


The definition of "white" in this country has always been a moving target.


So wapo now defines Central americans and Asians as white?


Some of them are.



Grasping at any logic to blame POC


Lots of people from Central and South America are Caucasian.


White South Americans loathe to come to the us as immigrants

White Central Americans are rare and while they aren’t as reticent to come to the us as South Americans, the numbers are minuscule


I’m from Central American and white. White is a race not an ethnicity.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 11:39     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Agree it's obviously due to changing demographics. People from difference backgrounds are different heights.


Read the article! They addressed it.


I'm still skeptical. We've had massive demographic changes in the US since 1980 and plenty of white people are white Latinos or have some mixed race heritage but still look very white. Very hard to separate the demographic changes from everything else.

I suspect there's fiddling with data or ignoring unwanted data to make the narrative fit. WaPo does this all the time.


+1 WaPo is a very biased news source. Demographics have changed. That said, it's not clear whether there are other issues such as food additives and pesticides, vaccine side effects, etc. also affecting height.


microplastics. Everywhere. Even found in newborn's poop. It's crazy and recent study there are way more (very alarming numbers of microplastics) in two well-known bottled water companies. They definitely cause harm in the body and interfere with hormones. Packaged food and fast food also have a very high number.


This is scary. DD got the covid vaccines and it changed her period. We had no idea that was even a possible side effect. I've had other permanent side effects from medications. It's alarming how little we know about long-term side effects from things we put into our bodies. The FDA is under a lot of pressure to approve medications. It's a big business with lawyers pushing hard so they can make their billions.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 11:33     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:My DS towers over both of us. He sleeps 10+ hours a night, sometimes more. In early elementary he slept about 12 hours a night and was late to give up naps.

He’s been a solid sleeper since early infancy.

I think so many young people are sleep deprived, screens, activities, studying etc., so they aren’t getting enough sleep and because they are spending so much time indoors they aren’t getting enough exercise. Little sleep and little exercise in childhood makes for smaller adults.

+1 add in the early puberty, and you get shorter kids.

My kids also slept a lot, way more than their peers, and they are late bloomers. I am super short; DH is tall, and my kids are above average height, and still growing at 15 and 18.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 11:32     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:No, that's not it, OP. Whites of Scandinavian descent are tall. Hispanic whites are short.

Changing heights are due to changing demographics.


Yup.

- former Scandinavian Texan


What are you now?

LOL-- a native American Virginian. or an AA Bostonian?
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 11:31     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Agree it's obviously due to changing demographics. People from difference backgrounds are different heights.


Read the article! They addressed it.


I'm still skeptical. We've had massive demographic changes in the US since 1980 and plenty of white people are white Latinos or have some mixed race heritage but still look very white. Very hard to separate the demographic changes from everything else.

I suspect there's fiddling with data or ignoring unwanted data to make the narrative fit. WaPo does this all the time.


+1 WaPo is a very biased news source. Demographics have changed. That said, it's not clear whether there are other issues such as food additives and pesticides, vaccine side effects, etc. also affecting height.


microplastics. Everywhere. Even found in newborn's poop. It's crazy and recent study there are way more (very alarming numbers of microplastics) in two well-known bottled water companies. They definitely cause harm in the body and interfere with hormones. Packaged food and fast food also have a very high number.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 11:29     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:No, that's not it, OP. Whites of Scandinavian descent are tall. Hispanic whites are short.

Changing heights are due to changing demographics.


This is what was always explained to me.

Our National population demographics have changed a LOT. Height is related to that new racial mix.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 08:50     Subject: Re:Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

The Federal government's definition of race:
https://wonder.cdc.gov/wonder/help/populations/bridged-race/directive15.html

Note that Hispanic is not a race, so the vast majority of them end up in the White category, along with people from the Middle East and North Africa.

You have to keep this in mind when talking about the White population over time. The White population of 1980 is drastically different from the White population today.
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 08:32     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:It's hard to believe there could really have been a huge change in the quality of food around 1980. I'm more inclined to believe an environmental chemical factor we haven't identified yet.


This.

Or an unintended hormonal effect from a vaccine?

Or genetic impact of interracial relationships given the growing Latino population in the US (noting their well documented shorter stature).
Anonymous
Post 01/09/2024 00:43     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Good lord it is because of changing demographics. PERIOD. I’m a 5’4” Jewish woman and I clearly remember being by far the shortest girl in my Midwestern high school filled with mostly ethnic German, Slavic and Scandinavian descent kids. My friends all toward over me at 5’7” at a minimum. As soon as I moved to the East Coast for college, where my classmates were also Jewish, Asian, Italian and Irish, boom I was average height. Yes there are tall Jews and Italians and quite a few Irish and even Asians, but on a whole they are shorter than Norwegians and Serbians. Add in indigenous people from El Salvador and the average American height it going to get shorter.

This isn’t rocket science and there is no need for conspiracy theories on this one.
Anonymous
Post 01/08/2024 23:32     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

Anonymous wrote:All latino kids I know are a lot taller than their parents. They are off of the corn diet which gives them nothing but full stomach. Their kids may end up being shorter or the same height they are because of the empty calories yet again.
US already may have hit their max height and it's downhill from there.
Europe is going downhill soon too because fast food is overtaken cooking at home. Not at schools yet luckily.


I'm 5 ft and Latina born raised in dc age 42. Nephew/godson is 6ft 3. My brother's are both 6ft parents are both 5ft
Anonymous
Post 01/08/2024 22:27     Subject: Wapo - Why are Americans getting shorter?

We have turned a blind eye to the biggest chemical change in the last 30 plus years, the increase in childhood vaccinations. Of course no one wants to examine the impact of vaccinations because the good outweighs the bad, but increasingly I’m not so sure. The body changes in teens and young adults over the last twenty years are significant.