Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I assume he’s a junior. He should ED to his favorite SLAC. It is really hard to find comparable schools to the more selective SLACs.

I would add Grinnell.

The kid is not getting into Grinnell. Not with limited extras. And definitely not if the kid doesn’t apply ED. The admit rate is in the single digits.

Agreed. So, could someone please suggest some Midwest safeties.

Midwest safety - maybe Beloit?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Check out Colleges that Change Lives.

They are known for being supportive communities.

Oh please. They are known only for banning together for marketing purposes.

Here. We. Go. Again.

It’s a valid opinion.

Except for the random Juniata parent, I’m finding this thread incredibly helpful! The A student’s safety is the B student’s target or reach, so it’s useful info all around.

Anonymous wrote:OP here: Thanks for all the thoughts here!

Mellow vibe = Collaborative vs competitive feel

I am surprised that people aren't more bullish on kid's chances at F&M, Lafayette, Kenyon, etc.

Also, we are full pay - does that make a difference here?

I think kid’s chances are very good but I still think you need a sure thing! Several “seems pretty likely” schools is not the same as a safety!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I would keep F&M, Union, Lafayette, and UMD, Kenyon. Add Dickinson. I think Bucknell and Lehigh are the WRONG fit, and I can't really comment on the others.

F&M and Lafeyette are very similar to Bucknell and Lehigh.

Lafayette has D1 sports, which makes it a little different than a D3 school.

I also think Sewanee is a good suggestion.

Haverford is a HIGH reach with those stats, at least for our school last year (in Naviance). We visited but my kid did not apply after seeing how unlikely it was. It’s a much harder admit than most of your list.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I assume he’s a junior. He should ED to his favorite SLAC. It is really hard to find comparable schools to the more selective SLACs.

I would add Grinnell.

The kid is not getting into Grinnell. Not with limited extras. And definitely not if the kid doesn’t apply ED. The admit rate is in the single digits.

Agreed. So, could someone please suggest some Midwest safeties.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Check out Colleges that Change Lives.

They are known for being supportive communities.

Oh please. They are known only for banning together for marketing purposes.

Here. We. Go. Again.

Anonymous wrote:Check out Colleges that Change Lives.

They are known for being supportive communities.

Oh please. They are known only for banning together for marketing purposes.

Anonymous wrote:Why do people keep suggesting Juniata? Have you read student reviews? It sounds terrible and difficult to transfer out of.

A frequent poster has a kid who goes there and has convinced herself that it’s Harvard.

Anonymous wrote:I assume he’s a junior. He should ED to his favorite SLAC. It is really hard to find comparable schools to the more selective SLACs.

I would add Grinnell.

The kid is not getting into Grinnell. Not with limited extras. And definitely not if the kid doesn’t apply ED. The admit rate is in the single digits.

Anonymous wrote:I would consider Skidmore.

Agreed. Skidmore isn't a safety but a potentially good match, and it seems to pride itself with having a collaborative, supportive vibe.

But regarding admissions, it does pay attention to if an applicant has shown some interest – so if you can't visit in peson, at least do a virtual tour or something.

Grinnell is a great suggestion, though not a safety. Any other Midwest safeties to recommend?

I assume he’s a junior. He should ED to his favorite SLAC. It is really hard to find comparable schools to the more selective SLACs.

I would add Grinnell.