Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:27     Subject: Re:Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

I think it would be best to withhold judgment until we hear from all of the witnesses.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:23     Subject: Re:Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:Aren't there other non lethal means to restrain someone? Why a chokehold? Should realize by now that people have died, unintentionally it would appear, due to law enforcement using chokeholds to restrain.

Agree with PP that a Marine has a good chance of knowing when to stop so this guy is unconscious instead of dead. And he had two other guys to help restrain him, so not seeing the need for lethal force AT ALL with what’s been reported so far.

And yes, if someone or something is annoying you while on public transportation, you move. That’s been true since I was riding the Metrobus to school in the 80s when I was 11 and it is still true today. It’s not like the subways are full right now. None of this was necessary.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:19     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Drug addicts aren't healthy individuals. They die quicker in custody and often stop breathing when normal people would have had no issues.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:18     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:I live in NYC and take the F train most days. The myth or rumor that policing is down is just that. There are more cops in subway stations and patrolling subway cars than I’ve ever seen in my 20 years of living in New York. Obviously homelessness and mental health crisis are also up, and there are a lot of almost tragedies and true tragedies like this happening all the time.
I also believe a trained marine should know the difference between chokehold to subdue and chokehold to kill. Obviously, this guy had some sort of white savior act to “protect others bothered” going on. From
The eyewitnesses it doesn’t sound like the man murdered was doing anything dangerous.


He has a long rap sheet and has previously punched a women in the face. He should have been in prison.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:18     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:I live in NYC and take the F train most days. The myth or rumor that policing is down is just that. There are more cops in subway stations and patrolling subway cars than I’ve ever seen in my 20 years of living in New York. Obviously homelessness and mental health crisis are also up, and there are a lot of almost tragedies and true tragedies like this happening all the time.
I also believe a trained marine should know the difference between chokehold to subdue and chokehold to kill. Obviously, this guy had some sort of white savior act to “protect others bothered” going on. From
The eyewitnesses it doesn’t sound like the man murdered was doing anything dangerous.


I guess all the witnesses were wrong to be frightened and to feel threatened.

I wonder if he did anything dangerous before he hit the 67-year-old woman in the face?
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:13     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

I live in NYC and take the F train most days. The myth or rumor that policing is down is just that. There are more cops in subway stations and patrolling subway cars than I’ve ever seen in my 20 years of living in New York. Obviously homelessness and mental health crisis are also up, and there are a lot of almost tragedies and true tragedies like this happening all the time.
I also believe a trained marine should know the difference between chokehold to subdue and chokehold to kill. Obviously, this guy had some sort of white savior act to “protect others bothered” going on. From
The eyewitnesses it doesn’t sound like the man murdered was doing anything dangerous.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:11     Subject: Re:Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Aren't there other non lethal means to restrain someone? Why a chokehold? Should realize by now that people have died, unintentionally it would appear, due to law enforcement using chokeholds to restrain.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:06     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?


He didn’t do anything dangerous


How do you know? We’re you there?


There have been several statements collected by witnesses, if you have been keeping up. Yes, he was yelling and screaming.
This is not a crime. If it were, I’d be entitled to choke out your brats when they have a tantrum in public. I’m honestly shocked and sickened by the attitudes here. Do we live in Minority Report, where people can be killed for futurecrime?

Not at all surprised it was a Marine who killed him. When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.


I have read a number of articles about this and watched an interview with the man who took the video. In his interview (in Spanish with a translator), he did note that the man had not assaulted anyone (although you could argue that throwing trash at people might be assault). The witness did, however, note that he was frightened by the man. He also said, in a comment that I found very telling, that if the police had come five minutes earlier, the marine would have been hailed as a hero. I think the fact that two other men were helping the marine subdue the man speaks to the fact that they genuinely viewed his behavior as a threat.

Of course whether they went too far is the question, and it sounds like the force used was excessive.


I ride the NY subway every day, and encounter loud, erratically behaving people regularly. If I deem one of them to be an actual potential threat (and the vast majority are not), I move further down the car, or switch cars. Removing oneself from the threat is the appropriate, and usual, tactic.

dp.. you think every single person in that car should've moved?


If you don’t want to be around a loud person you live.

Some move away from crying babies.

It’s your choice… you can’t just kill them.


Yeah, crying babies are exactly the same as a mentally unstable person who is reported to have been directly threatening people. I guess there is a moral obligation to either sit quietly or risk getting up to move and agitating a person who is screaming about not caring if he lives or dies.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:01     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?


He didn’t do anything dangerous


How do you know? We’re you there?


There have been several statements collected by witnesses, if you have been keeping up. Yes, he was yelling and screaming.
This is not a crime. If it were, I’d be entitled to choke out your brats when they have a tantrum in public. I’m honestly shocked and sickened by the attitudes here. Do we live in Minority Report, where people can be killed for futurecrime?

Not at all surprised it was a Marine who killed him. When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.


I have read a number of articles about this and watched an interview with the man who took the video. In his interview (in Spanish with a translator), he did note that the man had not assaulted anyone (although you could argue that throwing trash at people might be assault). The witness did, however, note that he was frightened by the man. He also said, in a comment that I found very telling, that if the police had come five minutes earlier, the marine would have been hailed as a hero. I think the fact that two other men were helping the marine subdue the man speaks to the fact that they genuinely viewed his behavior as a threat.

Of course whether they went too far is the question, and it sounds like the force used was excessive.


I ride the NY subway every day, and encounter loud, erratically behaving people regularly. If I deem one of them to be an actual potential threat (and the vast majority are not), I move further down the car, or switch cars. Removing oneself from the threat is the appropriate, and usual, tactic.

dp.. you think every single person in that car should've moved?


If you don’t want to be around a loud person you live.

Some move away from crying babies.

It’s your choice… you can’t just kill them.


NP. So, to you…a crying baby is the same as a mentally Ill grown man threatening people.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:00     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The man was mentally ill and had a long history of harassing subway riders and prior arrests. Our mental health system in this country sucks. He should have gotten help long before this ever happened.

The Marine wasn’t trying to kill him, he was trying to restrain him. But how stupid can you be to not realize that holding someone’s neck like that for so long can be fatal. The Marine was attempting to be a hero, and instead he is an idiot who killed someone.



Agree with all of this. I can't believe two other men, including a Black man, were assisting the Marine rather than telling him to stop.

maybe because the two other men, including the black man, also felt that this mentally ill person was behaving in such a manner that could turn violent.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 10:00     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?


He didn’t do anything dangerous


How do you know? We’re you there?


There have been several statements collected by witnesses, if you have been keeping up. Yes, he was yelling and screaming.
This is not a crime. If it were, I’d be entitled to choke out your brats when they have a tantrum in public. I’m honestly shocked and sickened by the attitudes here. Do we live in Minority Report, where people can be killed for futurecrime?

Not at all surprised it was a Marine who killed him. When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.


I have read a number of articles about this and watched an interview with the man who took the video. In his interview (in Spanish with a translator), he did note that the man had not assaulted anyone (although you could argue that throwing trash at people might be assault). The witness did, however, note that he was frightened by the man. He also said, in a comment that I found very telling, that if the police had come five minutes earlier, the marine would have been hailed as a hero. I think the fact that two other men were helping the marine subdue the man speaks to the fact that they genuinely viewed his behavior as a threat.

Of course whether they went too far is the question, and it sounds like the force used was excessive.


I ride the NY subway every day, and encounter loud, erratically behaving people regularly. If I deem one of them to be an actual potential threat (and the vast majority are not), I move further down the car, or switch cars. Removing oneself from the threat is the appropriate, and usual, tactic.


But really, isn’t it just more appropriate these ill people aren’t just roaming around on public transport? You weren’t there, btw. You have no idea what was appropriate in this situation.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 09:59     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?


He didn’t do anything dangerous


How do you know? We’re you there?


There have been several statements collected by witnesses, if you have been keeping up. Yes, he was yelling and screaming.
This is not a crime. If it were, I’d be entitled to choke out your brats when they have a tantrum in public. I’m honestly shocked and sickened by the attitudes here. Do we live in Minority Report, where people can be killed for futurecrime?

Not at all surprised it was a Marine who killed him. When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.


I have read a number of articles about this and watched an interview with the man who took the video. In his interview (in Spanish with a translator), he did note that the man had not assaulted anyone (although you could argue that throwing trash at people might be assault). The witness did, however, note that he was frightened by the man. He also said, in a comment that I found very telling, that if the police had come five minutes earlier, the marine would have been hailed as a hero. I think the fact that two other men were helping the marine subdue the man speaks to the fact that they genuinely viewed his behavior as a threat.

Of course whether they went too far is the question, and it sounds like the force used was excessive.


I ride the NY subway every day, and encounter loud, erratically behaving people regularly. If I deem one of them to be an actual potential threat (and the vast majority are not), I move further down the car, or switch cars. Removing oneself from the threat is the appropriate, and usual, tactic.

dp.. you think every single person in that car should've moved?


If you don’t want to be around a loud person you live.

Some move away from crying babies.

It’s your choice… you can’t just kill them.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 09:58     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?


He didn’t do anything dangerous


How do you know? We’re you there?


There have been several statements collected by witnesses, if you have been keeping up. Yes, he was yelling and screaming.
This is not a crime. If it were, I’d be entitled to choke out your brats when they have a tantrum in public. I’m honestly shocked and sickened by the attitudes here. Do we live in Minority Report, where people can be killed for futurecrime?

Not at all surprised it was a Marine who killed him. When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.


I have read a number of articles about this and watched an interview with the man who took the video. In his interview (in Spanish with a translator), he did note that the man had not assaulted anyone (although you could argue that throwing trash at people might be assault). The witness did, however, note that he was frightened by the man. He also said, in a comment that I found very telling, that if the police had come five minutes earlier, the marine would have been hailed as a hero. I think the fact that two other men were helping the marine subdue the man speaks to the fact that they genuinely viewed his behavior as a threat.

Of course whether they went too far is the question, and it sounds like the force used was excessive.


I ride the NY subway every day, and encounter loud, erratically behaving people regularly. If I deem one of them to be an actual potential threat (and the vast majority are not), I move further down the car, or switch cars. Removing oneself from the threat is the appropriate, and usual, tactic.

dp.. you think every single person in that car should've moved?
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 09:57     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:He’d been arrested 42 times.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12045021/Eric-Adams-starts-war-words-AOC-Jordan-Neely-death.html


42 arrests and on the street assaulting people is comical. NYC needs a control board too it seems.
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2023 09:52     Subject: Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?


He didn’t do anything dangerous


How do you know? We’re you there?


Witnesses in news reports say his behavior was erratic, saying he didn't have food, but that he wasn't threatening to assault anyone, and he didn't assault anyone.

He got into a verbal altercation with Marine, which led to physical. If the Marine had not engaged (just ignore, like everyone else), the mentally ill man would have just continued to be annoying.

Apparently another man got onto the train and told Marine to back off if he didn't want to face murder charge.

I think the Marine was being macho. No lives were in danger. He was not protecting anyone. He was probably annoyed and irritated by the erratic behavior. He wanted to stop it.



The deceased punched a 67 year old woman in the face. He was arrested 41 other times. How do you know what would have happened. He was making very threatening statements and throwing things at people.