Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 16:18     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:The music was horrible and sounded like highschool slam poetry.


We loved it and so did many others - why get your kicks raining on others’ joyful parades?
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 15:23     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The music was horrible and sounded like highschool slam poetry.


And you've listened to lots of high school slam poetry, have you?


PP probably hasn’t listened to any music.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 15:23     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Ha yeah definitely don't see Six, or Pacific Overtures, or Les Mis...

I mean you don't have to love the show but obviously it is going to be a simplified version of history.


Add to the list, don't watch South Pacific, or Assassins, or Miss Saigon, or Newsies, or anything set any time other than today, and featuring any story line that involves history or actual historical people. And as someone earlier noted: Don't go near any Shakespeare histories, OP! Or really any Shakespeare at all, because even in comedies his geography is all wrong, and that will only inflame the ulcer you''re working on with your ire over Hamilton.

Maybe just watch modern sitcoms on TV. Not dramas, they might get police procedure wrong and that's inaccurate....Wait! It's inaccurate that on sitcoms, people live in gigantic apartments in what are actually very high-cost city centers! Stick to just news and documentaries. There you go, OP.


Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 15:21     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:Hamilton the musical blows. People won't admit theyhp hated it after they spent $$$ on tix.


I’m sorry you couldn’t afford to see it.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 15:21     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:If you're going to tell someone's life story in facts are readily available to you, why would you not try to be as accurate as possible?.


Because tweaking can focus the story and make the timing flow better.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 14:06     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:The music was horrible and sounded like highschool slam poetry.


And you've listened to lots of high school slam poetry, have you?
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 14:05     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:Ha yeah definitely don't see Six, or Pacific Overtures, or Les Mis...

I mean you don't have to love the show but obviously it is going to be a simplified version of history.


Add to the list, don't watch South Pacific, or Assassins, or Miss Saigon, or Newsies, or anything set any time other than today, and featuring any story line that involves history or actual historical people. And as someone earlier noted: Don't go near any Shakespeare histories, OP! Or really any Shakespeare at all, because even in comedies his geography is all wrong, and that will only inflame the ulcer you''re working on with your ire over Hamilton.

Maybe just watch modern sitcoms on TV. Not dramas, they might get police procedure wrong and that's inaccurate....Wait! It's inaccurate that on sitcoms, people live in gigantic apartments in what are actually very high-cost city centers! Stick to just news and documentaries. There you go, OP.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 13:13     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
The music was horrible and sounded like highschool slam poetry.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 13:12     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:Hamilton the musical blows. People won't admit theyhp hated it after they spent $$$ on tix.


Umm because we loved it and it was worth every penny.

Our then MS Dc wanted to listen to it in the car all the time as well.

We looked up the relevant history and appreciated this formerly little recognized founding father.

We loved all the diversity of actors in the show, which was important for my child to see. It was ground breaking at the time.

We truly loved this show.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 13:06     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Ha yeah definitely don't see Six, or Pacific Overtures, or Les Mis...

I mean you don't have to love the show but obviously it is going to be a simplified version of history.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 12:44     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:If you're going to tell someone's life story in facts are readily available to you, why would you not try to be as accurate as possible?.


Because they wanted to avoid a lot of these inconvenient truths. It would have made the story less crowd-pleasing and let's face it, it's ultimately about putting a$$es in the seats.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 12:01     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Hamilton the musical blows. People won't admit theyhp hated it after they spent $$$ on tix.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 11:53     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
Anonymous wrote:If you're going to tell someone's life story in facts are readily available to you, why would you not try to be as accurate as possible?.


Because it's entertainment, not a biography. If you were directing this comment at Chernow, you'd be right. But as it is, you're just annoying.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 11:51     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
If you're going to tell someone's life story in facts are readily available to you, why would you not try to be as accurate as possible?.
Anonymous
Post 03/19/2023 11:25     Subject: Hamilton historically and accurate and a letdown
OP, you should definitely not go see Six.