Anonymous wrote:Good luck trying to suss out data by grades. As a teacher at one of these schools, there are so many variables to consider, especially when looking at a single grade that might only contain 50 kids. There were so many rolling quarantines at my school, and I'm sure many others, that you are comparing some schools whose children had maybe 30 instructional weeks to schools that were around 22-24. Then you can factor in SPED populations which are also markedly different at schools. I just wouldn't glean too much from these scores; I'm guessing 12 months from now DCPS is going to brag on their "improvements" which is really just another year of children actually being in school. It's all noise

I'm sorry but this is just nihilistic nonsense. The chaos of the year is indeed reflected in the scores. There are scores available for multiple grades, and these scores track with scores from prior years. You can't draw simple conclusions from any data, and indeed, people will apply statistical lens to the data to adjust for at-risk and demographics in terms of the students attending the various schools. But to just hand wave this important data away is wrong.

Does anyone have the results broken down by demographics? Especially since the overall story seems to be that the shutdown had a much bigger effect on black/AA scores and at risk scores, it seems like the above lists probably just show how many white kids a school has. No?

I'd be more interested to see if there was a big difference once you control for demographics. Did any schools actually handle the pandemic better or worse?

Good luck trying to suss out data by grades. As a teacher at one of these schools, there are so many variables to consider, especially when looking at a single grade that might only contain 50 kids. There were so many rolling quarantines at my school, and I'm sure many others, that you are comparing some schools whose children had maybe 30 instructional weeks to schools that were around 22-24. Then you can factor in SPED populations which are also markedly different at schools. I just wouldn't glean too much from these scores; I'm guessing 12 months from now DCPS is going to brag on their "improvements" which is really just another year of children actually being in school. It's all noise

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The Grade 5 ELA proficiency run-down...

79.25 Washington Yu Ying PCS
59.70 DC Bilingual PCS
58.59 BASIS DC PCS
57.14 Lee Montessori PCS
54.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
50.00 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
44.68 Washington Latin PCS
37.50 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS
37.31 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS
36.25 District of Columbia Public Schools
34.48 Creative Minds International PCS
30.85 Two Rivers PCS
30.00 Roots PCS
26.92 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
26.53 E.L. Haynes PCS
23.68 Capital City PCS
23.53 Meridian PCS
23.08 Social Justice PCS
22.73 Bridges PCS
19.69 Center City PCS
15.24 DC Prep PCS
13.51 Perry Street Preparatory PCS
13.43 Ingenuity Prep PCS
12.60 KIPP DC PCS
12.54 Friendship PCS
11.54 Mary McLeod Bethune Day Academy PCS
11.50 Rocketship Education DC PCS

And Grade 5 Math proficiency:

61.42 BASIS DC PCS
56.60 Washington Yu Ying PCS
50.75 DC Bilingual PCS
43.18 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
35.71 Lee Montessori PCS
31.91 Washington Latin PCS
31.34 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS
30.85 Two Rivers PCS
30.00 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS
29.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
26.67 Creative Minds International PCS
25.48 District of Columbia Public Schools
20.41 E.L. Haynes PCS
19.05 Bridges PCS
15.73 KIPP DC PCS
14.29 Sela PCS
13.28 Center City PCS
12.38 DC Prep PCS
11.54 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
10.53 Capital City PCS
7.96 Rocketship Education DC PCS
5.71 Friendship PCS

This comparison is a bit off since many of these schools start in 5th grade and the kids are mostly be tested at what they learned at their prior schools.

+1. I would want to look at 4th grade knowing that 5th grade has a lot of attrition and backfilling. 4th is not the first year of testing, but without all of the 5th grade shuffling.

You should actually look at all grades across the school to get a real sense as each individual grade is small enough that there's too much statistical noise... You want the sample as big as possible to actually compare.

So 3rd and 4th?

I actually think you want 3-5, because the 5th grade scores count less where the class is much smaller... but obviously do matter somewhat in assessing the overall school experience, especially since you don't know for sure that your kid won't lose the lottery.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:87.06 Murch Elementary School
85.87 Janney Elementary School
84.62 Ross Elementary School
81.82 Hearst Elementary School
81.82 Key Elementary School
79.25 Washington Yu Ying PCS
78.76 Lafayette Elementary School
73.68 Stoddert Elementary School
72.34 Mann Elementary School
69.7 Eaton Elementary School
69.57 Ludlow-Taylor Elementary School
69.23 Maury Elementary School
69.01 Oyster-Adams Bilingual School
68.75 Hyde-Addison Elementary School
67.69 Shepherd Elementary School
66.67 School-Within-School @ Goding
61.11 School Without Walls @ Francis-Stevens
59.7 DC Bilingual PCS
58.59 BASIS DC PCS
57.14 Lee Montessori PCS - Brookland
55.56 Capitol Hill Montessori School @ Logan
54.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
52.94 Langdon Elementary School
51.16 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
48.65 Bancroft Elementary School
46.67 Brent Elementary School
46.3 Marie Reed Elementary School
44.68 Washington Latin PCS - Middle School
43.24 Tyler Elementary School
41.89 Watkins Elementary School (Capitol Hill Cluster)
41.3 Van Ness Elementary School
39.39 Burrville Elementary School
37.68 Barnard Elementary School
37.5 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS - Brookland
37.31 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS - J.F. Cook
36.36 Payne Elementary School
36.36 Center City PCS - Congress Heights
36.17 Two Rivers PCS - 4th Street
35.71 Creative Minds International PCS
35.29 Raymond Elementary School
34.29 Thomson Elementary School
33.33 Burroughs Elementary School
32.56 John Lewis Elementary School
32 Powell Elementary School
31.25 Plummer Elementary School
30.77 Beers Elementary School
30.77 Seaton Elementary School
30 Roots PCS
28.57 Cleveland Elementary School
28.57 Whittier Elementary School
27.27 Thomas Elementary School
27.03 Takoma Elementary School
26.92 LaSalle-Backus Elementary School
26.92 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
26.67 Two Rivers PCS - Young Elementary School
26.53 E.L. Haynes PCS - Middle School
26.47 Tubman Elementary School
25 J.O. Wilson Elementary School
25 Friendship PCS - Woodridge International Middle
24.14 Garrison Elementary School
24 Savoy Elementary School
24 Center City PCS - Capitol Hill
23.68 Capital City PCS - Middle School
23.53 Meridian PCS
23.08 Social Justice PCS
22.73 Bridges PCS
22.73 Center City PCS - Trinidad
22.45 Kimball Elementary School
22.22 Garfield Elementary School
21.74 H.D. Cooke Elementary School
21.43 Ketcham Elementary School
20.75 KIPP DC - KEY Academy PCS
20.41 Friendship PCS - Blow Pierce Middle
20 Center City PCS - Brightwood
19.51 Dorothy I. Height Elementary School
19.05 Aiton Elementary School
18.64 Bruce-Monroe Elementary School @ Park View
16.9 DC Prep PCS - Edgewood Middle School
16.87 Brightwood Elementary School
16.67 Miner Elementary School
16.07 Truesdell Elementary School
15.79 Smothers Elementary School
15.38 DC Prep PCS - Anacostia Middle School
15.15 Malcolm X Elementary School @ Green
14.71 Friendship PCS - Ideal Middle
14 Lawrence E. Boone Elementary School
13.89 Perry Street Preparatory PCS
13.64 Rocketship PCS - Legacy Prep
13.58 KIPP DC - WILL Academy PCS
13.51 Amidon-Bowen Elementary School
13.51 Simon Elementary School
13.51 DC Prep PCS - Benning Middle School
13.43 Ingenuity Prep PCS
12 Mary McLeod Bethune Day Academy PCS
11.86 KIPP DC - Honor Academy PCS
11.48 Friendship PCS - Online Academy
11.25 KIPP DC - Northeast Academy PCS
11.11 Langley Elementary School
10.81 Patterson Elementary School
10.14 Rocketship PCS - Rise Academy
9.9 KIPP DC - AIM Academy PCS
9.84 Friendship PCS - Southeast Middle
9.52 C.W. Harris Elementary School
9.52 Nalle Elementary School
9.09 Hope Community PCS - Tolson
8.33 Browne Education Campus
8.11 Randle Highlands Elementary School
7.41 Turner Elementary School
7.02 Friendship PCS - Chamberlain Middle
6.98 Excel Academy
6.98 KIPP DC - Valor Academy PCS
6.9 Houston Elementary School
6.06 Moten Elementary School
5.71 Noyes Elementary School

A lot of the Ross 4th grade class leaves for charters such as Basis so this list is misleading. Same is try for Brent, Maury, and other schools either a bad feeder pattern.

I mean... Ross is 2nd on this list, so not *that* misleading Though I think it makes by far the most sense to do it across 3-5 to cancel out as much statistically noise as possible; then the smaller testing grades are also weighted less if you do it per student , which makes sense.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The Grade 5 ELA proficiency run-down...

79.25 Washington Yu Ying PCS
59.70 DC Bilingual PCS
58.59 BASIS DC PCS
57.14 Lee Montessori PCS
54.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
50.00 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
44.68 Washington Latin PCS
37.50 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS
37.31 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS
36.25 District of Columbia Public Schools
34.48 Creative Minds International PCS
30.85 Two Rivers PCS
30.00 Roots PCS
26.92 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
26.53 E.L. Haynes PCS
23.68 Capital City PCS
23.53 Meridian PCS
23.08 Social Justice PCS
22.73 Bridges PCS
19.69 Center City PCS
15.24 DC Prep PCS
13.51 Perry Street Preparatory PCS
13.43 Ingenuity Prep PCS
12.60 KIPP DC PCS
12.54 Friendship PCS
11.54 Mary McLeod Bethune Day Academy PCS
11.50 Rocketship Education DC PCS

And Grade 5 Math proficiency:

61.42 BASIS DC PCS
56.60 Washington Yu Ying PCS
50.75 DC Bilingual PCS
43.18 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
35.71 Lee Montessori PCS
31.91 Washington Latin PCS
31.34 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS
30.85 Two Rivers PCS
30.00 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS
29.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
26.67 Creative Minds International PCS
25.48 District of Columbia Public Schools
20.41 E.L. Haynes PCS
19.05 Bridges PCS
15.73 KIPP DC PCS
14.29 Sela PCS
13.28 Center City PCS
12.38 DC Prep PCS
11.54 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
10.53 Capital City PCS
7.96 Rocketship Education DC PCS
5.71 Friendship PCS

This comparison is a bit off since many of these schools start in 5th grade and the kids are mostly be tested at what they learned at their prior schools.

+1. I would want to look at 4th grade knowing that 5th grade has a lot of attrition and backfilling. 4th is not the first year of testing, but without all of the 5th grade shuffling.

You should actually look at all grades across the school to get a real sense as each individual grade is small enough that there's too much statistical noise... You want the sample as big as possible to actually compare.

So 3rd and 4th?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The Grade 5 ELA proficiency run-down...

79.25 Washington Yu Ying PCS
59.70 DC Bilingual PCS
58.59 BASIS DC PCS
57.14 Lee Montessori PCS
54.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
50.00 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
44.68 Washington Latin PCS
37.50 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS
37.31 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS
36.25 District of Columbia Public Schools
34.48 Creative Minds International PCS
30.85 Two Rivers PCS
30.00 Roots PCS
26.92 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
26.53 E.L. Haynes PCS
23.68 Capital City PCS
23.53 Meridian PCS
23.08 Social Justice PCS
22.73 Bridges PCS
19.69 Center City PCS
15.24 DC Prep PCS
13.51 Perry Street Preparatory PCS
13.43 Ingenuity Prep PCS
12.60 KIPP DC PCS
12.54 Friendship PCS
11.54 Mary McLeod Bethune Day Academy PCS
11.50 Rocketship Education DC PCS

And Grade 5 Math proficiency:

61.42 BASIS DC PCS
56.60 Washington Yu Ying PCS
50.75 DC Bilingual PCS
43.18 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
35.71 Lee Montessori PCS
31.91 Washington Latin PCS
31.34 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS
30.85 Two Rivers PCS
30.00 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS
29.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
26.67 Creative Minds International PCS
25.48 District of Columbia Public Schools
20.41 E.L. Haynes PCS
19.05 Bridges PCS
15.73 KIPP DC PCS
14.29 Sela PCS
13.28 Center City PCS
12.38 DC Prep PCS
11.54 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
10.53 Capital City PCS
7.96 Rocketship Education DC PCS
5.71 Friendship PCS

This comparison is a bit off since many of these schools start in 5th grade and the kids are mostly be tested at what they learned at their prior schools.

+1. I would want to look at 4th grade knowing that 5th grade has a lot of attrition and backfilling. 4th is not the first year of testing, but without all of the 5th grade shuffling.

You should actually look at all grades across the school to get a real sense as each individual grade is small enough that there's too much statistical noise... You want the sample as big as possible to actually compare.

Anonymous wrote:87.06 Murch Elementary School
85.87 Janney Elementary School
84.62 Ross Elementary School
81.82 Hearst Elementary School
81.82 Key Elementary School
79.25 Washington Yu Ying PCS
78.76 Lafayette Elementary School
73.68 Stoddert Elementary School
72.34 Mann Elementary School
69.7 Eaton Elementary School
69.57 Ludlow-Taylor Elementary School
69.23 Maury Elementary School
69.01 Oyster-Adams Bilingual School
68.75 Hyde-Addison Elementary School
67.69 Shepherd Elementary School
66.67 School-Within-School @ Goding
61.11 School Without Walls @ Francis-Stevens
59.7 DC Bilingual PCS
58.59 BASIS DC PCS
57.14 Lee Montessori PCS - Brookland
55.56 Capitol Hill Montessori School @ Logan
54.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
52.94 Langdon Elementary School
51.16 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
48.65 Bancroft Elementary School
46.67 Brent Elementary School
46.3 Marie Reed Elementary School
44.68 Washington Latin PCS - Middle School
43.24 Tyler Elementary School
41.89 Watkins Elementary School (Capitol Hill Cluster)
41.3 Van Ness Elementary School
39.39 Burrville Elementary School
37.68 Barnard Elementary School
37.5 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS - Brookland
37.31 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS - J.F. Cook
36.36 Payne Elementary School
36.36 Center City PCS - Congress Heights
36.17 Two Rivers PCS - 4th Street
35.71 Creative Minds International PCS
35.29 Raymond Elementary School
34.29 Thomson Elementary School
33.33 Burroughs Elementary School
32.56 John Lewis Elementary School
32 Powell Elementary School
31.25 Plummer Elementary School
30.77 Beers Elementary School
30.77 Seaton Elementary School
30 Roots PCS
28.57 Cleveland Elementary School
28.57 Whittier Elementary School
27.27 Thomas Elementary School
27.03 Takoma Elementary School
26.92 LaSalle-Backus Elementary School
26.92 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
26.67 Two Rivers PCS - Young Elementary School
26.53 E.L. Haynes PCS - Middle School
26.47 Tubman Elementary School
25 J.O. Wilson Elementary School
25 Friendship PCS - Woodridge International Middle
24.14 Garrison Elementary School
24 Savoy Elementary School
24 Center City PCS - Capitol Hill
23.68 Capital City PCS - Middle School
23.53 Meridian PCS
23.08 Social Justice PCS
22.73 Bridges PCS
22.73 Center City PCS - Trinidad
22.45 Kimball Elementary School
22.22 Garfield Elementary School
21.74 H.D. Cooke Elementary School
21.43 Ketcham Elementary School
20.75 KIPP DC - KEY Academy PCS
20.41 Friendship PCS - Blow Pierce Middle
20 Center City PCS - Brightwood
19.51 Dorothy I. Height Elementary School
19.05 Aiton Elementary School
18.64 Bruce-Monroe Elementary School @ Park View
16.9 DC Prep PCS - Edgewood Middle School
16.87 Brightwood Elementary School
16.67 Miner Elementary School
16.07 Truesdell Elementary School
15.79 Smothers Elementary School
15.38 DC Prep PCS - Anacostia Middle School
15.15 Malcolm X Elementary School @ Green
14.71 Friendship PCS - Ideal Middle
14 Lawrence E. Boone Elementary School
13.89 Perry Street Preparatory PCS
13.64 Rocketship PCS - Legacy Prep
13.58 KIPP DC - WILL Academy PCS
13.51 Amidon-Bowen Elementary School
13.51 Simon Elementary School
13.51 DC Prep PCS - Benning Middle School
13.43 Ingenuity Prep PCS
12 Mary McLeod Bethune Day Academy PCS
11.86 KIPP DC - Honor Academy PCS
11.48 Friendship PCS - Online Academy
11.25 KIPP DC - Northeast Academy PCS
11.11 Langley Elementary School
10.81 Patterson Elementary School
10.14 Rocketship PCS - Rise Academy
9.9 KIPP DC - AIM Academy PCS
9.84 Friendship PCS - Southeast Middle
9.52 C.W. Harris Elementary School
9.52 Nalle Elementary School
9.09 Hope Community PCS - Tolson
8.33 Browne Education Campus
8.11 Randle Highlands Elementary School
7.41 Turner Elementary School
7.02 Friendship PCS - Chamberlain Middle
6.98 Excel Academy
6.98 KIPP DC - Valor Academy PCS
6.9 Houston Elementary School
6.06 Moten Elementary School
5.71 Noyes Elementary School

A lot of the Ross 4th grade class leaves for charters such as Basis so this list is misleading. Same is try for Brent, Maury, and other schools either a bad feeder pattern.

We're in first grade at a DCPS Title 1 and while this data is alarming (though not unexpectedly), what I really want to watch is which school bounce back the most and the fastest. My hope is that the systems they're putting in place for remediation will allow schools to show some real progress over the next few years, without taking away from the kids that are on grade level. Time will tell.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All public and charter schools in DC with a 5th grade, is what it looks like to me.

You can't compare fifth grade classes across schools though since so many kids shuffle to middle schools and better feeder patterns in fifth.

What is the best comparison?

Probably 3rd grade for how well the school did distance learning (since those kids did K and 1st remote) or 4th for the school overall. There's attrition in 4th at many schools, but the biggest loss happens all at once in 5th.

+1. Fifth grade classrooms look markedly different from every other elementary grade in schools that don't have middle school pathways. Just look at the threads on MacFarland right now. Aside from a few pioneers, everyone that can get out does get out. That leaves a much more disadvantaged population remaining in fifth. Test scores would reflect that.

3rd grade ELA proficiency (look at Burroughs!)

85.19 Ross Elementary School
84.54 Janney Elementary School
82 Key Elementary School
75.93 Ludlow-Taylor Elementary School
70.49 Stoddert Elementary School
68 Mann Elementary School
67.16 Eaton Elementary School
66.92 Lafayette Elementary School
65.91 Hearst Elementary School
60.98 Shepherd Elementary School
60.34 Brent Elementary School
57.32 Maury Elementary School
54.76 Murch Elementary School
54.69 Hyde-Addison Elementary School
54.17 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
50.54 Bancroft Elementary School
50 Oyster-Adams Bilingual School
46.43 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
46.15 Burroughs Elementary School
44.19 School-Within-School @ Goding
43.66 Washington Yu Ying PCS
42.31 Center City PCS - Brightwood
37.78 Two Rivers PCS - 4th Street
37.68 DC Bilingual PCS
37.25 Marie Reed Elementary School
36.96 Two Rivers PCS - Young Elementary School
36.11 Payne Elementary School
35.29 School Without Walls @ Francis-Stevens
35.14 Lee Montessori PCS - Brookland
34.48 Garrison Elementary School
33.33 Seaton Elementary School
33.33 Van Ness Elementary School
33.33 Center City PCS - Congress Heights
33.33 Sela PCS
31.82 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS - Brookland
31.71 Amidon-Bowen Elementary School
29.87 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS - J.F. Cook
29.49 Watkins Elementary School (Capitol Hill Cluster)
28.3 Dorothy I. Height Elementary School
27.45 J.O. Wilson Elementary School
27.27 Thomson Elementary School
26.67 Capitol Hill Montessori School @ Logan
26.47 John Lewis Elementary School
26.09 Center City PCS - Petworth
25.35 DC Prep PCS - Edgewood Elementary School
25 Center City PCS - Capitol Hill
23.91 Friendship PCS - Woodridge International Elementary
23.81 Center City PCS - Shaw
23.53 Cleveland Elementary School
22.22 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
21.74 Bruce-Monroe Elementary School @ Park View
21.62 Langdon Elementary School
21.43 Barnard Elementary School
21.21 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS - East End
20.63 Friendship PCS - Southeast Elementary
20 Tyler Elementary School
20 Breakthrough Montessori PCS
19.35 Perry Street Preparatory PCS
19.3 Raymond Elementary School
18.87 Kimball Elementary School
18.18 Bunker Hill Elementary School
17.65 Bridges PCS
17.24 King Elementary School
17.02 Leckie Education Campus
17.02 Truesdell Elementary School
16.87 Rocketship PCS - Legacy Prep
16.39 Creative Minds International PCS
16.07 Brightwood Elementary School
15.69 E.L. Haynes PCS - Elementary School
15.38 Burrville Elementary School
15.38 LaSalle-Backus Elementary School
15.38 Center City PCS - Trinidad
14.71 Patterson Elementary School
14.52 Powell Elementary School
14.29 Plummer Elementary School
13.89 Takoma Elementary School
12.99 Tubman Elementary School
12.9 Whittier Elementary School
12.64 KIPP DC - Lead Academy PCS
12.2 Beers Elementary School
11.88 KIPP DC - Promise Academy PCS
11.11 Hendley Elementary School
11.11 DC Prep PCS - Anacostia Elementary School
11.11 Friendship PCS - Ideal Elementary
11.11 Friendship PCS - Armstrong Elementary
10.71 Browne Education Campus
10.53 Ingenuity Prep PCS
10.2 H.D. Cooke Elementary School
10 Simon Elementary School
9.76 Friendship PCS - Online Academy
9.38 KIPP DC - Inspire Academy PCS
8.93 Friendship PCS - Blow Pierce Elementary
8.57 Excel Academy
8.47 Meridian PCS
8.11 Early Childhood Academy PCS
8.00 DC Scholars PCS
8.00 Rocketship PCS - Infinity Community Prep
7.69 Aiton Elementary School
7.69 Garfield Elementary School
7.69 Miner Elementary School
7.50 Walker-Jones Education Campus
7.41 Houston Elementary School
6.06 Randle Highlands Elementary School
5.88 KIPP DC - Quest Academy PCS
5.63 DC Prep PCS - Benning Elementary School
5.43 KIPP DC - Spring Academy PCS
4.81 KIPP DC - Heights Academy PCS

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All public and charter schools in DC with a 5th grade, is what it looks like to me.

You can't compare fifth grade classes across schools though since so many kids shuffle to middle schools and better feeder patterns in fifth.

What is the best comparison?

9th grade for charters starting in 5th.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:87.06 Murch Elementary School
85.87 Janney Elementary School
84.62 Ross Elementary School
81.82 Hearst Elementary School
81.82 Key Elementary School
79.25 Washington Yu Ying PCS
78.76 Lafayette Elementary School
73.68 Stoddert Elementary School
72.34 Mann Elementary School
69.7 Eaton Elementary School
69.57 Ludlow-Taylor Elementary School
69.23 Maury Elementary School
69.01 Oyster-Adams Bilingual School
68.75 Hyde-Addison Elementary School
67.69 Shepherd Elementary School
66.67 School-Within-School @ Goding
61.11 School Without Walls @ Francis-Stevens
59.7 DC Bilingual PCS
58.59 BASIS DC PCS
57.14 Lee Montessori PCS - Brookland
55.56 Capitol Hill Montessori School @ Logan
54.17 Latin American Montessori Bilingual PCS
52.94 Langdon Elementary School
51.16 Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS
48.65 Bancroft Elementary School
46.67 Brent Elementary School
46.3 Marie Reed Elementary School
44.68 Washington Latin PCS - Middle School
43.24 Tyler Elementary School
41.89 Watkins Elementary School (Capitol Hill Cluster)
41.3 Van Ness Elementary School
39.39 Burrville Elementary School
37.68 Barnard Elementary School
37.5 Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS - Brookland
37.31 Mundo Verde Bilingual PCS - J.F. Cook
36.36 Payne Elementary School
36.36 Center City PCS - Congress Heights
36.17 Two Rivers PCS - 4th Street
35.71 Creative Minds International PCS
35.29 Raymond Elementary School
34.29 Thomson Elementary School
33.33 Burroughs Elementary School
32.56 John Lewis Elementary School
32 Powell Elementary School
31.25 Plummer Elementary School
30.77 Beers Elementary School
30.77 Seaton Elementary School
30 Roots PCS
28.57 Cleveland Elementary School
28.57 Whittier Elementary School
27.27 Thomas Elementary School
27.03 Takoma Elementary School
26.92 LaSalle-Backus Elementary School
26.92 Shining Stars Montessori Academy PCS
26.67 Two Rivers PCS - Young Elementary School
26.53 E.L. Haynes PCS - Middle School
26.47 Tubman Elementary School
25 J.O. Wilson Elementary School
25 Friendship PCS - Woodridge International Middle
24.14 Garrison Elementary School
24 Savoy Elementary School
24 Center City PCS - Capitol Hill
23.68 Capital City PCS - Middle School
23.53 Meridian PCS
23.08 Social Justice PCS
22.73 Bridges PCS
22.73 Center City PCS - Trinidad
22.45 Kimball Elementary School
22.22 Garfield Elementary School
21.74 H.D. Cooke Elementary School
21.43 Ketcham Elementary School
20.75 KIPP DC - KEY Academy PCS
20.41 Friendship PCS - Blow Pierce Middle
20 Center City PCS - Brightwood
19.51 Dorothy I. Height Elementary School
19.05 Aiton Elementary School
18.64 Bruce-Monroe Elementary School @ Park View
16.9 DC Prep PCS - Edgewood Middle School
16.87 Brightwood Elementary School
16.67 Miner Elementary School
16.07 Truesdell Elementary School
15.79 Smothers Elementary School
15.38 DC Prep PCS - Anacostia Middle School
15.15 Malcolm X Elementary School @ Green
14.71 Friendship PCS - Ideal Middle
14 Lawrence E. Boone Elementary School
13.89 Perry Street Preparatory PCS
13.64 Rocketship PCS - Legacy Prep
13.58 KIPP DC - WILL Academy PCS
13.51 Amidon-Bowen Elementary School
13.51 Simon Elementary School
13.51 DC Prep PCS - Benning Middle School
13.43 Ingenuity Prep PCS
12 Mary McLeod Bethune Day Academy PCS
11.86 KIPP DC - Honor Academy PCS
11.48 Friendship PCS - Online Academy
11.25 KIPP DC - Northeast Academy PCS
11.11 Langley Elementary School
10.81 Patterson Elementary School
10.14 Rocketship PCS - Rise Academy
9.9 KIPP DC - AIM Academy PCS
9.84 Friendship PCS - Southeast Middle
9.52 C.W. Harris Elementary School
9.52 Nalle Elementary School
9.09 Hope Community PCS - Tolson
8.33 Browne Education Campus
8.11 Randle Highlands Elementary School
7.41 Turner Elementary School
7.02 Friendship PCS - Chamberlain Middle
6.98 Excel Academy
6.98 KIPP DC - Valor Academy PCS
6.9 Houston Elementary School
6.06 Moten Elementary School
5.71 Noyes Elementary School

What is this list?

5th grade ELA proficiency

Can you post math?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All public and charter schools in DC with a 5th grade, is what it looks like to me.

You can't compare fifth grade classes across schools though since so many kids shuffle to middle schools and better feeder patterns in fifth.

What is the best comparison?

Probably 3rd grade for how well the school did distance learning (since those kids did K and 1st remote) or 4th for the school overall. There's attrition in 4th at many schools, but the biggest loss happens all at once in 5th.

+1. Fifth grade classrooms look markedly different from every other elementary grade in schools that don't have middle school pathways. Just look at the threads on MacFarland right now. Aside from a few pioneers, everyone that can get out does get out. That leaves a much more disadvantaged population remaining in fifth. Test scores would reflect that.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All public and charter schools in DC with a 5th grade, is what it looks like to me.

You can't compare fifth grade classes across schools though since so many kids shuffle to middle schools and better feeder patterns in fifth.

What is the best comparison?

Probably 3rd grade for how well the school did distance learning (since those kids did K and 1st remote) or 4th for the school overall. There's attrition in 4th at many schools, but the biggest loss happens all at once in 5th.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All public and charter schools in DC with a 5th grade, is what it looks like to me.

You can't compare fifth grade classes across schools though since so many kids shuffle to middle schools and better feeder patterns in fifth.

What is the best comparison?