Anonymous wrote:Why aren’t there more “traditional” schools to choose from. No nonsense phonics, spelling tests, memorizing math facts, textbooks, workbooks. No Lucy Caulkins.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why is ATS so popular with everyone? Is it that much better than all the neighborhood schools?

ATS gets higher test scores because of the self-selecting nature of the population it serves (children of highly engaged, highly motivated parents).

FALSE

other schools have lower scores for those with learning disabilities and for those w ith lower incomes. Not ATS. It's an excellent school that focuses on literacy. It's that simple.

But ATS also has a lot fewer students with significant learning disabilities who wouldn't have similar outcomes at other schools. In other words, other schools have (a) more special ed needs and (b) a wider range of special ed needs, not to mention the schools with a lot of special ed students AND ELL students. It makes a difference when you have fewer and a smaller range of demands.

ATS and McK have the same percentage of sn kids. Look at the score distribution. ATS tops McK.

Anonymous wrote:I have a kid in 2nd at ATS and another in middle school. My first had SN and ATS did everything to remediate. Mine had complex needs and was not alone at all. It's a very supportive place for SN kids. Not sure why parents think it's not.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My daughter is in ATS in first grade. My second will be in their kindergarten class. We absolutely love it. Speaking of diversity, initially applied because our neighborhood school is all white (though it is such a wonderful school) and a friend suggested that this school would be a good fit for her since it was more diverse. Being not white ourselves, we felt like it would be good for her to go to a school where she didn’t feel different. We also wanted the flexibility of moving without having to have our kids switch schools. However we have come to love the school and appreciate it’s philosophy. First of all it is extremely diverse - with families from all over the world. Unlike our neighborhood school, it has a significant portion of its population that qualify for free and reduced lunch due to its VPE program (I’m assuming that drew is similar in that regard). What is unique about AT though, is the achievement gap is quite low. Everyone does well and it’s because of the resources the school puts into their students and also their teaching methods. Unlike many other Arlington schools for example, they stay away from Lucy Calkins. Their reading program is phonics based and ensures that kids learn how to read no matter what their socio-economic background is. I also love their focus on writing. My daughter was writing full sentences and paragraphs by the end of Kindergarten as were so many others in her class. Most of their work is done by hand and on paper so it really improves their fine motor skills. Yes there is homework which I was initially against but there is such a vast improvement in their writing and reading that I feel it is actually beneficial. I also love their focus on art and music. Don’t worry about it being “too much.” My daughter loves it and made lots of good friends. The teachers are warm and friendly and are a lot of fun. I remember my daughter telling me how funny her kindergarten teacher was. Apparently he would make them laugh a lot! And yes a lot of ATS parents want their kids to go to HB even though they are diametrically opposed philosophically. Many of us aren’t attached to a school philosophy - we just want a school that works and educates our kids. Option schools are generally more diverse because they pull from all over the county so I doubt people are sending their kids to ATS and HB to avoid diversity. Notice the critics of ATS here - the majority don’t have kids at ATS. I strongly believe that you should only talk about what you know. I know nothing about Drew. I’m sure like many Arlington schools it’s great (and I’m also assuming that because of its location, it is more diverse than our neighborhood school). But I can tell you that our experience with ATS has been great and we plan on sticking with it.

I'm not trying to criticize ATS here. But I can speak to people avoiding their neighborhood school. It absolutely happens and for different reasons. People in mostly white schools like the idea of diversity and/or the choice program philosophy. White people in the high FRL districts often avoid their high FRL school and might also be interested in the instructional program as a bonus. Some people just really want the choice program. And a lot of people just think ATS is the end all be all or their kid isn't getting the best education if they don't go there because ATS scores are typically the highest in the district.

the ATS to HBWoodlawn path is absolutely illogical from an instructional philosophy perspective. ATS is very structured and rigid. HBW is the exact opposite.

I do think some of the instructional approaches are better at ATS and the expectations are high for every student. However, historically, the principal has had too much influence on admissions and there hasn't been a lot of patience with students who don't fall in line or perform high enough or need too much in the way of special ed/accommodations. Hopefully that has changed in the last few years??

OP, I'm very confident your child will thrive and be happy in either school. She won't know the difference because whichever you send her to will be all she knows. I don't think it's worth all the angst to make a decision and if you would prefer a little less stress and anxiety and less pressure, Drew is for you. If you're hyper type-A typical Arlington helicopter micromanager parent who thinks nothing but the most elite will do for your child and their future success, go ahead and take the ATS slot.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why is ATS so popular with everyone? Is it that much better than all the neighborhood schools?

ATS gets higher test scores because of the self-selecting nature of the population it serves (children of highly engaged, highly motivated parents).

FALSE

other schools have lower scores for those with learning disabilities and for those w ith lower incomes. Not ATS. It's an excellent school that focuses on literacy. It's that simple.

Congratulations, you completely missed the substance of the post you responded to. Probably for the best your child’s school has a strong literacy curriculum.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why is ATS so popular with everyone? Is it that much better than all the neighborhood schools?

ATS gets higher test scores because of the self-selecting nature of the population it serves (children of highly engaged, highly motivated parents).

FALSE

other schools have lower scores for those with learning disabilities and for those w ith lower incomes. Not ATS. It's an excellent school that focuses on literacy. It's that simple.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why is ATS so popular with everyone? Is it that much better than all the neighborhood schools?

ATS gets higher test scores because of the self-selecting nature of the population it serves (children of highly engaged, highly motivated parents).

FALSE

other schools have lower scores for those with learning disabilities and for those w ith lower incomes. Not ATS. It's an excellent school that focuses on literacy. It's that simple.

But ATS also has a lot fewer students with significant learning disabilities who wouldn't have similar outcomes at other schools. In other words, other schools have (a) more special ed needs and (b) a wider range of special ed needs, not to mention the schools with a lot of special ed students AND ELL students. It makes a difference when you have fewer and a smaller range of demands.

ATS and McK have the same percentage of sn kids. Look at the score distribution. ATS tops McK.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why is ATS so popular with everyone? Is it that much better than all the neighborhood schools?

ATS gets higher test scores because of the self-selecting nature of the population it serves (children of highly engaged, highly motivated parents).

FALSE

other schools have lower scores for those with learning disabilities and for those w ith lower incomes. Not ATS. It's an excellent school that focuses on literacy. It's that simple.

But ATS also has a lot fewer students with significant learning disabilities who wouldn't have similar outcomes at other schools. In other words, other schools have (a) more special ed needs and (b) a wider range of special ed needs, not to mention the schools with a lot of special ed students AND ELL students. It makes a difference when you have fewer and a smaller range of demands.

Anonymous wrote:My oldest will be going into 3rd grade at ATS and my younger will be starting K there this year (just got the email yesterday he was offered admission- I was a little nervous with all the redshirting this year). One thing to note, this year’s K class is large, 5 instead of 4. This is the 2nd time they’ve had a 5 class K.

I can’t say enough good things about ATS (I’m a non-VPI South Arlington family). It is great for my quiet, inverted rue-following kid, and I’m sure it’ll be great for my boisterous, outgoing, line-stepping kid. All the teachers have been outstanding, and the principal runs a tight ship and I have to assume the teachers like her, given the average tenure. Being at ATS was one reason I decided not to leave Arlington this year during the pandemic.

On Drew, the principal is excellent (feedback from teachers who’ve worked with her), but I’ve heard from friends whose kids go there... it is a much different experience than my kids get are getting at ATS. However, I think Drew will grow to a unique and exceptional school.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My daughter is in ATS in first grade. My second will be in their kindergarten class. We absolutely love it. Speaking of diversity, initially applied because our neighborhood school is all white (though it is such a wonderful school) and a friend suggested that this school would be a good fit for her since it was more diverse. Being not white ourselves, we felt like it would be good for her to go to a school where she didn’t feel different. We also wanted the flexibility of moving without having to have our kids switch schools. However we have come to love the school and appreciate it’s philosophy. First of all it is extremely diverse - with families from all over the world. Unlike our neighborhood school, it has a significant portion of its population that qualify for free and reduced lunch due to its VPE program (I’m assuming that drew is similar in that regard). What is unique about AT though, is the achievement gap is quite low. Everyone does well and it’s because of the resources the school puts into their students and also their teaching methods. Unlike many other Arlington schools for example, they stay away from Lucy Calkins. Their reading program is phonics based and ensures that kids learn how to read no matter what their socio-economic background is. I also love their focus on writing. My daughter was writing full sentences and paragraphs by the end of Kindergarten as were so many others in her class. Most of their work is done by hand and on paper so it really improves their fine motor skills. Yes there is homework which I was initially against but there is such a vast improvement in their writing and reading that I feel it is actually beneficial. I also love their focus on art and music. Don’t worry about it being “too much.” My daughter loves it and made lots of good friends. The teachers are warm and friendly and are a lot of fun. I remember my daughter telling me how funny her kindergarten teacher was. Apparently he would make them laugh a lot! And yes a lot of ATS parents want their kids to go to HB even though they are diametrically opposed philosophically. Many of us aren’t attached to a school philosophy - we just want a school that works and educates our kids. Option schools are generally more diverse because they pull from all over the county so I doubt people are sending their kids to ATS and HB to avoid diversity. Notice the critics of ATS here - the majority don’t have kids at ATS. I strongly believe that you should only talk about what you know. I know nothing about Drew. I’m sure like many Arlington schools it’s great (and I’m also assuming that because of its location, it is more diverse than our neighborhood school). But I can tell you that our experience with ATS has been great and we plan on sticking with it.

Uhh option schools are not generally more diverse. If you’re in south Arlington, ATS probably won’t be more diverse.

Hmm. ATS is definitely more diverse than Randolph and Carlin Springs. And option schools other than HBW are definitely more diverse than those same two schools and all but a few of the schools north of Route 50.

Anonymous wrote:Oh my goodness, PP. "Hyper type A typical Arlington helicopter parents" are the type of parents who will be happiest at ATS? Wow. Do you actually have a child at ATS? I can tell you as a current parent that there is a wide variety of families, parents and backgrounds. You are painting with a very broad stroke and I'm guessing this is based solely on "heard it from a friend of a friend who know someone who had a child at ATS" intel.

Please.

Anyway, the principal is lovely and she has no control over admissions. It is all handled at the central office.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why is ATS so popular with everyone? Is it that much better than all the neighborhood schools?

ATS gets higher test scores because of the self-selecting nature of the population it serves (children of highly engaged, highly motivated parents).

FALSE

other schools have lower scores for those with learning disabilities and for those w ith lower incomes. Not ATS. It's an excellent school that focuses on literacy. It's that simple.