Anonymous
07/13/2019 17:10
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
Anonymous wrote:48- yes. But I want to caveat. My mom was abusive- and the spanking was really hitting.
What I remember is the criticism and verbal/emotional abuse. So much worse than being hit.
A lot of parents wouldn't spank their kids but would tear stripe off of them verbally by criticizing and being generally awful. Those people should not be congratulating themselves. I think kids do forgive spanking because we think that someone lost their cool, or didn't know better. Verbal and emotional abuse is not so easy to let go of.
My mother slapped me across the face a few times, including when I was a teen. She also mentally and verbally abused me, calling me all kinds of names. If she had only just spanked me with an open hand on the bottom, I think it would not have phased me. But the slap across the face, and other stuff that I recall, and the verbal abuse have stayed with me.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 17:05
Subject: Re:Were you spanked as child?
62 and yes, likely until I was about 8 but it was infrequent and pretty normal in my world. I don’t recall ever spanking my kids....even when they deserved it.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 16:58
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
48- yes. But I want to caveat. My mom was abusive- and the spanking was really hitting.
What I remember is the criticism and verbal/emotional abuse. So much worse than being hit.
A lot of parents wouldn't spank their kids but would tear stripe off of them verbally by criticizing and being generally awful. Those people should not be congratulating themselves. I think kids do forgive spanking because we think that someone lost their cool, or didn't know better. Verbal and emotional abuse is not so easy to let go of.
What I remember is the criticism and verbal/emotional abuse. So much worse than being hit.
A lot of parents wouldn't spank their kids but would tear stripe off of them verbally by criticizing and being generally awful. Those people should not be congratulating themselves. I think kids do forgive spanking because we think that someone lost their cool, or didn't know better. Verbal and emotional abuse is not so easy to let go of.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 16:57
Subject: Re:Were you spanked as child?
Yes, by my step-father. It was abuse.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 16:53
Subject: Re:Were you spanked as child?
Yes. Not very often but it happened. All under age 7 or 8. 39 now.
Have great relationships with parents.
Have great relationships with parents.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 14:00
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
Anonymous wrote:I am 50
I was spanked by my mother when I was a tiny child (under 4?) and by my father.
My father continued to hit me - but instead of spanking he hit me across the face with the back of his hand.
or he twisted my arm behind my back or he kicked me in the back of the legs.
Dude, that is not spanking. What you are describing is assault. A lot of what you all are describing is assault. Spanking was for egregious breaking of rules that was made clear to the child and was at the level of their understanding. It was on the bottom and not face or back of legs.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 13:48
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
32, yes, but don’t remember it.
I do remember being asked if I wanted to go to the bathroom (in public) and I knew that meant a spanking and there was no crying when you came out.
I do remember being asked if I wanted to go to the bathroom (in public) and I knew that meant a spanking and there was no crying when you came out.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 13:27
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:33, yes. I was spanked by my dad all the way till I left for college. My mom had to find other alternatives like washing my mouth with soap though because I could physically overpower her by then.
Well this is disturbing. Spanking a 17 or 18 year old is almost certainly illegal. Also it makes your dad sound like a perv.
It is hard to imagine it being "illegal" to spank a 17 or 18 year old but not illegal to spank someone younger.
No need to make it illegal to spank 17 year old boys. When I got to that age, if my mom hit me I'd just laugh at her, or pick her up and say "hey, you're pretty funny!" She stopped when I was younger than that. I think I was taller than her already in 7th grade.
As for my dad hitting me at 17, he didn't do that but if he had I would have socked him back. Game on, mofo.
What I really don't get is how the PP's mom was unable to spank but was somehow able to wash the PP's mouth out with soap. The latter seems like it would be a lot easier to resist if the PP was able to physically overpower mom.
I may be wrong, but I believe spanking is legal until age 12. Illegal under 2 (?) and over 12.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 13:17
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
I am 50
I was spanked by my mother when I was a tiny child (under 4?) and by my father.
My father continued to hit me - but instead of spanking he hit me across the face with the back of his hand.
or he twisted my arm behind my back or he kicked me in the back of the legs.
I was spanked by my mother when I was a tiny child (under 4?) and by my father.
My father continued to hit me - but instead of spanking he hit me across the face with the back of his hand.
or he twisted my arm behind my back or he kicked me in the back of the legs.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 13:15
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
37
Spanked until kindergarten by my parents. Hit on the hand with rulers by public school teachers until fifth grade.
Spanked until kindergarten by my parents. Hit on the hand with rulers by public school teachers until fifth grade.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 13:02
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
37. Regularly beaten. Have never forgotten or forgiven my parents. I don’t spank/abuse my children because I respect them.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 12:54
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
39, yes. I have a wonderful and close relationship with my parents to this day.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 12:07
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:33, yes. I was spanked by my dad all the way till I left for college. My mom had to find other alternatives like washing my mouth with soap though because I could physically overpower her by then.
Well this is disturbing. Spanking a 17 or 18 year old is almost certainly illegal. Also it makes your dad sound like a perv.
It is hard to imagine it being "illegal" to spank a 17 or 18 year old but not illegal to spank someone younger.
No need to make it illegal to spank 17 year old boys. When I got to that age, if my mom hit me I'd just laugh at her, or pick her up and say "hey, you're pretty funny!" She stopped when I was younger than that. I think I was taller than her already in 7th grade.
As for my dad hitting me at 17, he didn't do that but if he had I would have socked him back. Game on, mofo.
What I really don't get is how the PP's mom was unable to spank but was somehow able to wash the PP's mouth out with soap. The latter seems like it would be a lot easier to resist if the PP was able to physically overpower mom.
I don’t know about 17 but 18 is definitely illegal.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 11:54
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:33, yes. I was spanked by my dad all the way till I left for college. My mom had to find other alternatives like washing my mouth with soap though because I could physically overpower her by then.
Well this is disturbing. Spanking a 17 or 18 year old is almost certainly illegal. Also it makes your dad sound like a perv.
It is hard to imagine it being "illegal" to spank a 17 or 18 year old but not illegal to spank someone younger.
No need to make it illegal to spank 17 year old boys. When I got to that age, if my mom hit me I'd just laugh at her, or pick her up and say "hey, you're pretty funny!" She stopped when I was younger than that. I think I was taller than her already in 7th grade.
As for my dad hitting me at 17, he didn't do that but if he had I would have socked him back. Game on, mofo.
What I really don't get is how the PP's mom was unable to spank but was somehow able to wash the PP's mouth out with soap. The latter seems like it would be a lot easier to resist if the PP was able to physically overpower mom.
Anonymous
07/13/2019 11:47
Subject: Were you spanked as child?
Anonymous wrote:33, yes. I was spanked by my dad all the way till I left for college. My mom had to find other alternatives like washing my mouth with soap though because I could physically overpower her by then.
Well this is disturbing. Spanking a 17 or 18 year old is almost certainly illegal. Also it makes your dad sound like a perv.