I've got to say our new supermarket favorite is Trader Joe's Organic Vanilla Chocolate Chip. It's simple, rich and really delicious. I'd actually choose it over Haagen Dazs.

Turkey Hill.

The key to any ice cream is to make sure it's called "ice cream" and not "frozen dairy dessert". Breyers and Edy's is now "frozen dairy dessert" and it sucks.

My favorite supermarket varieties are B&J phish food, and Haagen Dazs chocolate peanut butter.
My favorite place to go for ice cream is Eataly. I get pistachio and stracciatella.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Three Twins cardamom. Whole Foods doesn’t carry regular Three Twins pints any more. Very sad. Only the large sizes and diet ice creams.

Also to the Princeton poster - Halo Pub /Halo Fram is really good, but Bent Spoon is fantastic!

You can order Three Twins pints/quarts etc and have it delivered from the Amazon Prime Now/ Whole Foods delivery service.

Never mind - you can order it directly to be delivered to your door! I’ve done this before with McConnells - it comes frozen solid in a cooler packed in dry ice . It stays frozen in that cooler for a long time so there’s no worry about quality or melting.

http://shop.threetwinsicecream.com


I wish that they would snazzy up the art work on their ice cream to better reflect the ice cream product instead of the ‘3 sisters’. It would probably increase sales by a lot.

Anonymous wrote:I’m not sure it exists anymore: Friendly’s Peppermint Stick.

It exsists still!!! I bought it at Giant in early December. Definitely seasonal, but must sell out quickly. I went to get more a week later and couldn't find any...checked many Giants . I love it with my homemade hot fudge sauce.

I also live Friendly's Coconut. It is so creamy and subtle. It pairs well with chocolate cake or raspberry crisp. Yum!

Breyer's Mint Chip will forever be my favorite

Baskin Robbins World Class Chocolate

Edy's Chocolate Cherry Chip. It's like chocolate covered cherries in ice cream form.

Anonymous wrote:Three Twins cardamom. Whole Foods doesn’t carry regular Three Twins pints any more. Very sad. Only the large sizes and diet ice creams.

Also to the Princeton poster - Halo Pub /Halo Fram is really good, but Bent Spoon is fantastic!

You can order Three Twins pints/quarts etc and have it delivered from the Amazon Prime Now/ Whole Foods delivery service.

I guess I'm in the minority here because I don't like Ben &Jerrys. The texture is terrible with the hard frozen bits of chocolate pieces in every bite... like in Phish Food, Jerry Garcia. I only like just the ice cream part.

Breyers chocolate and peanut butter

Three Twins cardamom. Whole Foods doesn’t carry regular Three Twins pints any more. Very sad. Only the large sizes and diet ice creams.

Also to the Princeton poster - Halo Pub /Halo Fram is really good, but Bent Spoon is fantastic!

Haagan Dazs White Chocolate Raspberry- it has these big pieces of the most delicious chocolate in it and the tart raspberry swirl with the creamy white chocolate ice cream.

Baskin Robbins mint chocolate chip.

Anonymous wrote:Three Twins chocolate orange. MOMs used to carry it, but no longer. Does anyone know where I can find it??

Three Twins has yummy ice cream sandwiches too.