Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 19:32     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Nnat - 130
Cogat - 140

In pool.
In
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 19:30     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:NNAT 133
CogAT 116
GBRS 16

In pool.

In.


the one and only 16 so far


That was my DD. I will say, her teacher put A LOT of effort into that GBRS report. She included very specific examples of behaviors/acts in the classroom and out (like at recess). I knew about some of these things, but not about others. It was an interesting read, and more information about my child than I've gotten (albeit indirectly) from any of my kids' teachers so far. I would recommend to anyone who had a packet prepared to request a copy.


My DD got a 16 last year, too. It contained about 4 pages of singled spaced typed commentary. I was shocked at the details provided. It covered nearly all aspects of her day, things she says, quotes she'd said, how she handled situations, questions she asked, answers she provided, etc. EXTREMELY detailed.


Can you tell us what school your child attends. I'm pretty sure the teachers at our school don't put in nearly that effort. Great teacher whoever she/he is!


Seriously, I want to know, too. My DC's teacher gave one sentence each for his resport. I feel she doesn't care or know so much about my kid.


No, I won't say what school, but she was a very average teacher. Interesting that you would think she is a "great" teacher because of how she filled this report out. Yes, the report was well written and while in no way was I thinking my child would get a 16, if the teacher was hearing and seeing the things she wrote about, it did make sense and she had the complete back up to support her score. That said, she wasn't a "great" teacher; she was just okay.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 19:26     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
NNAT - not taken/submitted
CoGAT - 144
WISC - 151, not submitted (Didn't know it was an option to submit)
GBRS 16

In pool

Found Eligible
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 19:05     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:NNat 142
CoGat composite 138
In pool with Gbrs unknown but did not get in.

Check the GBR. That's unreal.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:57     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Please explain to me why my DS with a CoGat composite of 148 and a NNat of 145 did not get in. I don't know the GBRS but those scores should have been sufficient. We are very unhappy with this and considering our options.


I'm very sorry, PP, I also would not understand. I guess doing WISC and understanding GBRS is the way to go.

A similar situation was posted on a different thread , with strong NNAT, CoGAT , and I think GBRS 9 and got denied the GBRS . From the stat that people reported so far ( and assuming people are truthfully did so)I have to say that GBRS is a very important criteria, if not THE most important when the committee consider the whole package. Unfortunately, GBRS is very subjective in my opinion, and different from school to school, teacher to teacher. It looks like they emphasize the history of gifted behavior in one and a half year (first and second half of second grade) to predict how well the child will do in AAP.


Correction: and got denied to AAP.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:56     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Please explain to me why my DS with a CoGat composite of 148 and a NNat of 145 did not get in. I don't know the GBRS but those scores should have been sufficient. We are very unhappy with this and considering our options.


I'm very sorry, PP, I also would not understand. I guess doing WISC and understanding GBRS is the way to go.

A similar situation was posted on a different thread , with strong NNAT, CoGAT , and I think GBRS 9 and got denied the GBRS . From the stat that people reported so far ( and assuming people are truthfully did so)I have to say that GBRS is a very important criteria, if not THE most important when the committee consider the whole package. Unfortunately, GBRS is very subjective in my opinion, and different from school to school, teacher to teacher. It looks like they emphasize the history of gifted behavior in one and a half year (first and second half of second grade) to predict how well the child will do in AAP.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:55     Subject: AAP admission stats 2015
NNAT 130
Cogat 136
GBRS 12

Accepted
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:53     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:CoGat was 128 and Naglierii from garde one was 140. The Gbrs were 14 but my dad did not get in. I am beside myself and very perplexed...


What does that mean?
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:42     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:Please explain to me why my DS with a CoGat composite of 148 and a NNat of 145 did not get in. I don't know the GBRS but those scores should have been sufficient. We are very unhappy with this and considering our options.


I'd request your child's file from the aart.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:37     Subject: AAP admission stats 2015
In with NNAT 142, Cogat 134, GBRS 13.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:32     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:Please explain to me why my DS with a CoGat composite of 148 and a NNat of 145 did not get in. I don't know the GBRS but those scores should have been sufficient. We are very unhappy with this and considering our options.


I'm very sorry, PP, I also would not understand. I guess doing WISC and understanding GBRS is the way to go.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:18     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Anonymous wrote:Please explain to me why my DS with a CoGat composite of 148 and a NNat of 145 did not get in. I don't know the GBRS but those scores should have been sufficient. We are very unhappy with this and considering our options.


Apparently,your child needs scores in the 110-129 range for admittance. Your child might actually be gifted, so they we're denied.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:04     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
Twins

NNAT 129 (I think)
CogAT Composite - 126 (116, 129, 124)
GBRS - unknown
Parent Referred

NNAT - I can not remember, but was in the 80s percentile
CogAT Composite - 126 (128, 129, 113)
GBRS - unknown
Parent Referred

Both are eligible for full time level IV.
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:02     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
NNAT - he didn't attend FCPS for first grade
Cogat-136
GBRS-13.

In pool
Anonymous
Post 05/01/2015 18:01     Subject: Re:AAP admission stats 2015
NNAT 135
COGAT 123
GBRS no idea

In pool
In

No prepping, we didn't even pay attention to when the tests were. I am guessing had a great GBRS, will have to request it.