Anonymous
Post 05/18/2012 07:43     Subject: AAP - What happen to those who were not accepted?

Introverts and behavior problems do not mean low GBRS. Have you looked at the rating scale? It is on fcps.edu. It looks for specific items based on learning. Things like memory, creativity, etc.

You have provided no evidence that the GBRS does not measure introverted children correctly.

I can make just as strong of a case against the group test scores favoring certain children.

Anonymous
Post 05/18/2012 06:45     Subject: AAP - What happen to those who were not accepted?

Anonymous wrote:Yes, but that is just one small blurb from this article to fit your purposes.

If you read the whole article, you can find statements about how half of gifted kids are seen as behavior problems. (Doesn't sound like introversion) boys are usually seen as immature, second children not being recognized as giften as often as first born children because of behavior (not lack of iq), etc.

Yes, you can probably find evidence to support the view that gifted kids are introverts just as you can find evidence that gifted kids can be behavior problems.

From my personal experience, the profoundly gifted boys and one profoundly gifted girlI know (backed by test scores at or just below the testing ceiling) are slightly immature, fidgity, talkative, outgoing kids and the other profoundly gifted girl I know is an introvert. This is out of a sample of 6 families. Not statistically significant but just an observation.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:All children are curious, creative, and motivated. Most teachers are able to discern when those traits are typical or exceptional. This discernment is reflected in the GBRS.


More than 70% of gifted kids are introverts with deeper thoughts. It won't be easy for teachers without proper and enough training to fairly identify them.


Who says?


Here's one source from quick Google search.
http://www.gifteddevelopment.com/What_is_Gifted/learned.htm

"About 60% of gifted children are introverted compared with 30% of the general population. Approximately 75% of highly gifted children are introverted. Introversion correlates with introspection, reflection, the ability to inhibit aggression, deep sensitivity, moral development, high academic achievement, scholarly contributions, leadership in academic and aesthetic fields in adult life, and smoother passage through midlife; however, it is very likely to be misunderstood and “corrected” in children by well-meaning adults."


You are actually proving my point that thus GBRS can be subjective and inconsistent.
Majority of gifted are introverts and many of them seem to have behavior problem, so... hard for teachers to properly evaluate when they are not experts.
It's not one article. Do your own Google.