Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
And how many were admitted to each?
Berkeley lists 0 but we know a student is there - so it's hard to say whether that is a reporting error vs a student getting off WL
UCLA lists 3 (and we know of 3 accepted there)
Did they have any Bs?
You ask this question like Bs are the only thing that matter. Do these students getting denied have strong ECs, do they have strong essays? One B or a few Bs definitely isn’t a disqualification for UCB. Check their common data set. A majority of students accepted don’t have perfect GPAs.
I'm not the PP speaking of B's - but to your point on those being denied..... there are definitely Big 3 students with zero B's, that have very high stats, high rigor, solid ECs, and strong essays who are still getting a WLs/rejections from Cal and UCLA.
I’m still puzzled as to why any Big 3 student would really want to attend Cal and UCLA with their subpar public facilities (especially Cal), impacted classes (both), and high OOS tuition (both).
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
And how many were admitted to each?
Berkeley lists 0 but we know a student is there - so it's hard to say whether that is a reporting error vs a student getting off WL
UCLA lists 3 (and we know of 3 accepted there)
Did they have any Bs?
You ask this question like Bs are the only thing that matter. Do these students getting denied have strong ECs, do they have strong essays? One B or a few Bs definitely isn’t a disqualification for UCB. Check their common data set. A majority of students accepted don’t have perfect GPAs.
I'm not the PP speaking of B's - but to your point on those being denied..... there are definitely Big 3 students with zero B's, that have very high stats, high rigor, solid ECs, and strong essays who are still getting a WLs/rejections from Cal and UCLA.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
And how many were admitted to each?
Berkeley lists 0 but we know a student is there - so it's hard to say whether that is a reporting error vs a student getting off WL
UCLA lists 3 (and we know of 3 accepted there)
Did they have any Bs?
You ask this question like Bs are the only thing that matter. Do these students getting denied have strong ECs, do they have strong essays? One B or a few Bs definitely isn’t a disqualification for UCB. Check their common data set. A majority of students accepted don’t have perfect GPAs.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
And how many were admitted to each?
Berkeley lists 0 but we know a student is there - so it's hard to say whether that is a reporting error vs a student getting off WL
UCLA lists 3 (and we know of 3 accepted there)
Did they have any Bs?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I don’t understand the dmv’s fascination with usc. Growing up in socal it was always kind of a laughingstock. University of spoiled children was for mediocre student rich kids of alumni and football players. It’s in the complete hood as well and had the reputation of being like a prison…you can’t leave campus.
If I had a kid at a “big 3” school and they ended up at usc I’d consider it a fail. Unless they wanted to study film.
Sounds like you are stuck in college landscape of thirty years ago and have no real knowledge on this topic.
I’m not. I still have family and friends in socal. Stanford, Berkeley and ucla are the in state schools Californians aspire too. Davis, uc San Diego, and Santa Barbara are considered better than usc, which is considered Pepperdine with football. USC is where you go cuz you think it’ll help you get a job at your buddy’s dads company.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
And how many were admitted to each?
Berkeley lists 0 but we know a student is there - so it's hard to say whether that is a reporting error vs a student getting off WL
UCLA lists 3 (and we know of 3 accepted there)
Did they have any Bs?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
And how many were admitted to each?
Berkeley lists 0 but we know a student is there - so it's hard to say whether that is a reporting error vs a student getting off WL
UCLA lists 3 (and we know of 3 accepted there)
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
And how many were admitted to each?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
In 2023 - 25 Sidwell students applied to Berkeley and 27 applied to UCLA...... look before you leap.
Anonymous wrote:3.8 big 3. Not in at UCB. WL and UCLA. In at Irvine, SB, SD. Going somewhere else altogether.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:if your kid or any you know were admitted to Cal, UCLA, etc from a Big3, what do you think put them over the edge?
I know these are hard admits under the private school paradigm of few APs, etc,
I don’t know any students at my children’s school (Sidwell) who talk about attending a UC. I’m sure there are some, it just hasn’t reached my ears. Generally speaking, I don’t think state schools are popular among Sidwell kids.
My son applied from Sidwell a couple of cycles ago. Denied. The problem is that a Sidwell GPA will never cut it in a sea of 4.8888888s, and GPA is literally the only thing UCs screen for now. That, and I think poverty.
Michigan, Virginia and Wisconsin "get" the Sidwell situation. UCs and Texas do not. So, Ann Arbor is a more reliable admit than UC Santa Barbara, oddly.
UCs are not highly sought after by Sidwell students. That said, there are 5 c/o ‘24 students going to UCs (1 each to Cal, UCSD, and UCSC). The two students who are going to UCLA are recruited athletes.
Sidwell seems to send a handful of students (including non recruited athletes) to UCs every year. It’s not an impossible admit.
And yet Sidwell seniors send in close to 30 applications per year with only a few acceptances to Berkeley/UCLA.
There are 125 students per grade at Sidwell. Those 30 applications are most likely coming from the same 5-10 students. Are you actually trying to convince us that UCs are some of the most sought after colleges by Sidwell students? Please stop.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I don’t understand the dmv’s fascination with usc. Growing up in socal it was always kind of a laughingstock. University of spoiled children was for mediocre student rich kids of alumni and football players. It’s in the complete hood as well and had the reputation of being like a prison…you can’t leave campus.
If I had a kid at a “big 3” school and they ended up at usc I’d consider it a fail. Unless they wanted to study film.
Sounds like you are stuck in college landscape of thirty years ago and have no real knowledge on this topic.