Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 11:18     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:Mine applied to 11 EA’s, 1 ED1, 1 rolling and had 4 RD’s ready to go. Got in to rolling with merit and ED1. The rest now feels like a waste of time but we weren’t sure what would happen in this highly unpredictable college admit round to an UMC white male with great stats. The colleges are responsible for this madness with TO and their other vague criteria for entry with emphasis on other things besides meritocracy that only they know!!!


Did you at least withdraw those other 16 apps ?
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 11:02     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:My kid applied to 12 by Nov 1; deferred to ED school.

Submitted 8 more apps by Dec 31 (whew)…..

Spent 1-2 days on each of the 8 apps; one at a time; tailoring EVERYTHING - and I reviewed each of these apps (was hands off in fall….)


20 apps??!??


Imagine if they'd have spent all that time studying, they'd have had better choices.



This is the dumbest comment ever. I’m certain 20 colleges included great choices.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:55     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The privates limit apps in order to try and get a good outcome for all of their students in any given class. Not good for one superstar to suck up all of the spots at Ivys, etc


How very Socialist of them. And very ironic.


Exactly. And I don’t think that the poster was saying schools don’t do this- they were saying why would you send your child to a school that does this? The schools do it to protect themselves and to help their reputations to the detriment of the children.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:55     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:What bugs me is the kids who apply to Harvard, Yale or Stanford SCEA and then proceed to apply to additional Ivys after getting accepted “just to see” after winning one lottery ticket.


Why not
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:54     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
What bugs me is the kids who apply to Harvard, Yale or Stanford SCEA and then proceed to apply to additional Ivys after getting accepted “just to see” after winning one lottery ticket.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:53     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:Mine applied to 11 EA’s, 1 ED1, 1 rolling and had 4 RD’s ready to go. Got in to rolling with merit and ED1. The rest now feels like a waste of time but we weren’t sure what would happen in this highly unpredictable college admit round to an UMC white male with great stats. The colleges are responsible for this madness with TO and their other vague criteria for entry with emphasis on other things besides meritocracy that only they know!!!


Merit is not limited to GPAs and test scores. When will people figure that out? And, there are a lot of kids out there with great stats.

Mine applied to 7 EA, 1 rolling and 1 ED reach. So grateful she got in to ED school that is much harder admit for females. It was nice to have some early/rolling admits as well, now that it is over so fast. So, not a waste. She did an excellent job communicating on the supplements, which is an important part of the equation.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:49     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:All these kids I know who applied to 10-20 schools start listing all of their acceptances to colleges they have no real interest in attending.


This isn't true for my son. He's applying to 20. He's high stats but didn't get in ED . He has a couple safeties and targets but most of the list are reach schools. It has been a crazy amount of work for him but I think it makes sense to apply to a lot if you are hoping to get into one of single digit acceptance rate schools.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:44     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:The privates limit apps in order to try and get a good outcome for all of their students in any given class. Not good for one superstar to suck up all of the spots at Ivys, etc


How very Socialist of them. And very ironic.


People who choose these schools should do their homework and know the system going into it. If you don’t like it, attend elsewhere. They want positive outcomes for as many of their students as possible (who are being compared against each other as an applicant pool). This approach has benefits for the students and school as a whole. 12 is still plenty of college applications and most kids will end up at the right place with multiple offers of admission.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:28     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
^^^It’s all about the DEI in DMV privates don’t you know!
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 10:19     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:The privates limit apps in order to try and get a good outcome for all of their students in any given class. Not good for one superstar to suck up all of the spots at Ivys, etc


How very Socialist of them. And very ironic.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 09:56     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
The privates limit apps in order to try and get a good outcome for all of their students in any given class. Not good for one superstar to suck up all of the spots at Ivys, etc
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 09:46     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
GDS does limit. I have a senior (who was admitted in the ED round). It was 12 school limit this year which was an increase from 10. The increase from 10 to 12 schools had the requirement that 5 schools be "foundational" as that's where there's been the most variability in admit rates.
And, GDS is very good about ensuring all applications are withdrawn if you are accepted ED.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 09:26     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Our school doesn’t limit. Honestly how could they? Why would any parent allow that? Common app allows 20 and you can always apply directly with the school.


They can and do impose limits. These are private schools. They enforce it by not releasing transcripts to additional schools beyond the limit they set. Parents who don’t like it can choose to enroll their kids elsewhere, nobody is forcing them to attend these private schools. The limits can be beneficial, as the college counseling is very individualized and they take time to curate a realistic application list for each student. Students don’t need to apply to 20 schools just because that’s what fits in the Common App.


Well I guess it’s great your kid attends a school that only “allows” them to choose from 10 schools for their future.


Where did I state my kid attends one of those schools? They don’t but I’m stating facts that there are other private schools that impose limits on number of college applications.


NP
Great that you clarified. Now you should have no issue naming the schools that impose limits. I am aware of none. And I’m assuming someone lied to you if you were told that


NP here. Why are you so heated about this? I know for a fact that Landon does this.


Georgetown Day School does as well. I don’t know why this person is so spun up about it and intent on dismissing the fact that this does happen at some private schools.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 09:14     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Our school doesn’t limit. Honestly how could they? Why would any parent allow that? Common app allows 20 and you can always apply directly with the school.


They can and do impose limits. These are private schools. They enforce it by not releasing transcripts to additional schools beyond the limit they set. Parents who don’t like it can choose to enroll their kids elsewhere, nobody is forcing them to attend these private schools. The limits can be beneficial, as the college counseling is very individualized and they take time to curate a realistic application list for each student. Students don’t need to apply to 20 schools just because that’s what fits in the Common App.


Well I guess it’s great your kid attends a school that only “allows” them to choose from 10 schools for their future.


I'm sure the quality of the counseling is high at some of these private schools, but I would be absolutely livid if my kid's school refused to release a transcript at our request. That level of control is about the school, not the student. There are legitimate reasons to apply to more than 10 schools. I can't believe that after spending all that money, parents are putting up with that.
Anonymous
Post 01/03/2024 09:12     Subject: How many apps is your child submitting today?
Mine applied to 11 EA’s, 1 ED1, 1 rolling and had 4 RD’s ready to go. Got in to rolling with merit and ED1. The rest now feels like a waste of time but we weren’t sure what would happen in this highly unpredictable college admit round to an UMC white male with great stats. The colleges are responsible for this madness with TO and their other vague criteria for entry with emphasis on other things besides meritocracy that only they know!!!