Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I grew up going to ski school and was a pretty good skier and could get up to Black Diamond. HOWEVER, I have since torn an ACL and now I am terrified to get back on skis, even though I love it. I am wondering if I can try cross country skiing as that seems less hard on the knees. Does anyone know?
I’m a lifelong downhill skier and took up nordic skiing 4 years ago at age 40 because long story but we moved next door to a nordic ski center. Unless you are going very slowly on absolutely flat, groomed trails, I think nordic is much scarier as an adult. The skis are narrow and don’t have edges and the boots are much less stable than alpine boots. Although it is gentler on your knees if you are good at it, I’ve found the falls to be much, much worse because your bindings don’t pop off and the boots are soft enough that your legs and skis can go any and all directions. All of my nasty falls in the last 3 years have been nordic related and on stupidly mild slopes and even standing still.
The motion of classic nordic skiing can also be very hard on your achilles and calf muscles for a new skier, and if you’re not careful you might flare old knee injuries when your body tries to compensate.
My neighbor is a downhill and Nordic skier with lots of ACL drama. After surgery last year, he dropped nordic and is happily downhill-only in a brace.
Fascinating! I had planned to switch to Nordic at some point (I'm in my late 40s now).maybe instead I'll switch to snowshoeing?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If you really want to learn to ski, OP, I would not do it on local hills. Or even New England. I know it's expensive, but I would do a trip to a Utah or Colorado resort. Better snow, and the impact of skiing straight for 5 days can't be overestimated.
I learned at 40 - had never been on skis before. I took one group lesson at Wintergreen, and it was a disaster. I then went out west on a group family trip, and took lessons for 5 days in Utah. Mostly group, one or two private, and then skied on my own. At the end of it, I made my way (slowly) down the easiest blue hill at the ski resort. I now am comfortable on basically any blue hill in Utah, and a handful of blacks. We do at least one long trip a year. I am never going to be a great skier, but I have a lot of fun, and can hold my own as long as I stay on the right slopes.
If you can afford it, it's definitely the best way to learn. I would choose either a smaller less crowded resort (such as Solitude, where I learned) or a higher end resort like Deer Valley. I'm sure there are similar places in Colorado that others can recommend. Wait a year or two to ski at Park City, Alta, etc.
New England in late winter is great and snow can be just as good as out West.
Is it possible that the snow is as good? I suppose - anything's possible. But you're far more likely to get crappy, icy snow in NE than out west.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If you really want to learn to ski, OP, I would not do it on local hills. Or even New England. I know it's expensive, but I would do a trip to a Utah or Colorado resort. Better snow, and the impact of skiing straight for 5 days can't be overestimated.
I learned at 40 - had never been on skis before. I took one group lesson at Wintergreen, and it was a disaster. I then went out west on a group family trip, and took lessons for 5 days in Utah. Mostly group, one or two private, and then skied on my own. At the end of it, I made my way (slowly) down the easiest blue hill at the ski resort. I now am comfortable on basically any blue hill in Utah, and a handful of blacks. We do at least one long trip a year. I am never going to be a great skier, but I have a lot of fun, and can hold my own as long as I stay on the right slopes.
If you can afford it, it's definitely the best way to learn. I would choose either a smaller less crowded resort (such as Solitude, where I learned) or a higher end resort like Deer Valley. I'm sure there are similar places in Colorado that others can recommend. Wait a year or two to ski at Park City, Alta, etc.
New England in late winter is great and snow can be just as good as out West.
Anonymous wrote:I tried. I managed to drop the instructor and fall on him. At the beginning of our lesson, he said he could teach anyone to ski. At the end of the lesson he had to admit I was the first one he could not help.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I grew up going to ski school and was a pretty good skier and could get up to Black Diamond. HOWEVER, I have since torn an ACL and now I am terrified to get back on skis, even though I love it. I am wondering if I can try cross country skiing as that seems less hard on the knees. Does anyone know?
If you love(d) it, and were a good skier, fear not. Discuss with your orthopedic surgeon, and get back on the slopes with any prep they recommend. There’s likely no reason you have to abandon your beloved sport! Like you, I skied, then tore my ACL during a different sport, then got back on the slopes a few years after that. If you have residual instability there are things to do to prepare and wear. You can do this, and have no knee pain and no issues at all!
Anonymous wrote:a lot of it is how fearless you are. It’s physically harder to ski very slow than it is faster.
This is why it’s better to learn young.
But that doesn’t mean that learning once old and sticking to easy terrain can’t be awesome.
Anonymous wrote:I grew up going to ski school and was a pretty good skier and could get up to Black Diamond. HOWEVER, I have since torn an ACL and now I am terrified to get back on skis, even though I love it. I am wondering if I can try cross country skiing as that seems less hard on the knees. Does anyone know?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I grew up going to ski school and was a pretty good skier and could get up to Black Diamond. HOWEVER, I have since torn an ACL and now I am terrified to get back on skis, even though I love it. I am wondering if I can try cross country skiing as that seems less hard on the knees. Does anyone know?
I’m a lifelong downhill skier and took up nordic skiing 4 years ago at age 40 because long story but we moved next door to a nordic ski center. Unless you are going very slowly on absolutely flat, groomed trails, I think nordic is much scarier as an adult. The skis are narrow and don’t have edges and the boots are much less stable than alpine boots. Although it is gentler on your knees if you are good at it, I’ve found the falls to be much, much worse because your bindings don’t pop off and the boots are soft enough that your legs and skis can go any and all directions. All of my nasty falls in the last 3 years have been nordic related and on stupidly mild slopes and even standing still.
The motion of classic nordic skiing can also be very hard on your achilles and calf muscles for a new skier, and if you’re not careful you might flare old knee injuries when your body tries to compensate.
My neighbor is a downhill and Nordic skier with lots of ACL drama. After surgery last year, he dropped nordic and is happily downhill-only in a brace.