OP here: still have not decided but all of your suggestions are great! Please keep them coming.

The dinner party isn't until December. DH has a business trip to Paris at the end of the month so i told him to bring back butter so i can use it for the dinner party.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I would love this! I hate going to potlucks and having to pretend to like eating a bunch of cheap store bought stuff. People should put effort and good ingredients into what they bring.

You realize half the suggestions in this thread are frozen burritos and Reese’s peanut butter cups right.

That sounds like a partay!

I want to know what folks brought.

OP, update us?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I would love this! I hate going to potlucks and having to pretend to like eating a bunch of cheap store bought stuff. People should put effort and good ingredients into what they bring.

You realize half the suggestions in this thread are frozen burritos and Reese’s peanut butter cups right.

New idea: frozen burritos stuffed with Reese’s cups. They’ll never see it coming!

I would think nothing store bought as this is a dinner with probably snobby foodies. And things like bananas are not a surprise because when you peel a banana, you find inside...a banana!

Anonymous wrote:I would love this! I hate going to potlucks and having to pretend to like eating a bunch of cheap store bought stuff. People should put effort and good ingredients into what they bring.

You realize half the suggestions in this thread are frozen burritos and Reese’s peanut butter cups right.