Anonymous
09/10/2023 22:05
Subject: How does Catholic school make kids so outgoing and gregarious?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Booze. Big loud families. Lots of fun sports events. And not really caring about academics.
Heck, it sounds amazing!!!
-not kidding. Kind of wished we were Catholic.
Wow -- prejudice is alive and flourishing, isn't it? This poster and several others are saying "those people drink like fish, reproduce like rabbits, and are as stupid as donkeys." If anyone posted stereotypes of other ethnic or racial groups, they'd be banned from this site. And called out in public. But there's an exception in America: apparently it's always okay to demean Irish and Italian Catholics (and Polish too). You'd like to think we got over this in the 20th century, but we definitely didn't!
If you lurk on this forum at all it's ok to demean any type of Christian. Someone asked if it was ok to have a birthday party on Sunday morning and when someone mentioned church there was a response to the effect of "You don't want to socialize with that kind anyway."
Anonymous
09/10/2023 16:42
Subject: How does Catholic school make kids so outgoing and gregarious?
Anonymous wrote:Booze. Big loud families. Lots of fun sports events. And not really caring about academics.
Heck, it sounds amazing!!!
-not kidding. Kind of wished we were Catholic.
Wow -- prejudice is alive and flourishing, isn't it? This poster and several others are saying "those people drink like fish, reproduce like rabbits, and are as stupid as donkeys." If anyone posted stereotypes of other ethnic or racial groups, they'd be banned from this site. And called out in public. But there's an exception in America: apparently it's always okay to demean Irish and Italian Catholics (and Polish too). You'd like to think we got over this in the 20th century, but we definitely didn't!
Anonymous
09/09/2023 22:05
Subject: How does Catholic school make kids so outgoing and gregarious?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I know in my own kid's school there is a lot of emphasis on public speaking and leadership.
This! My kids who did Catholic for at least part of their education are not naturally extroverted, but they had so many oral presentations that they are poised and fluid orators. Even my kid who stuttered had to present orally and was taught to remain calm and keep going.
I think you see this at most private schools. Certainly the Episcopal and Presbyterian ones, anyway.
My kids are at a Catholic school and I was sold on the tour when the impressive 8th grader showed us around. He looked us in the eye, seemed very mature, and was just had a presence about him, and seemed confident and comfortable with other adults. Most of the teens I saw around town were nothing like that. They mumbled when speaking, avoided eye contact and would certainly never call us Mr or Mrs. I'm sure for some manners are old fashioned and unimportant, but it made an impression on us.
Anonymous
09/09/2023 16:24
Subject: How does Catholic school make kids so outgoing and gregarious?
Anonymous wrote:They’re allowed to expel the kids who crush your spirit.
This is true. Zero tolerance for kids who jeopardize the atmosphere. When you get rid of the bad apples, everyone including the introverts becomes more confident and thus more personable and better orators. The *average* public school kid is a bit insecure, always worried what other kids will think or say, and mumbles when they speak.
Anonymous
09/09/2023 16:19
Subject: How does Catholic school make kids so outgoing and gregarious?
Anonymous wrote:Booze. Big loud families. Lots of fun sports events. And not really caring about academics.
Heck, it sounds amazing!!!
-not kidding. Kind of wished we were Catholic.
Not caring about academics? Bulls—. If anything, it’s work hard, play hard at Catholic schools.
Anonymous
09/06/2023 20:29
Subject: How does Catholic school make kids so outgoing and gregarious?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I know in my own kid's school there is a lot of emphasis on public speaking and leadership.
This! My kids who did Catholic for at least part of their education are not naturally extroverted, but they had so many oral presentations that they are poised and fluid orators. Even my kid who stuttered had to present orally and was taught to remain calm and keep going.
My kids are at a Catholic school and I was sold on the tour when the impressive 8th grader showed us around. He looked us in the eye, seemed very mature, and was just had a presence about him, and seemed confident and comfortable with other adults. Most of the teens I saw around town were nothing like that. They mumbled when speaking, avoided eye contact and would certainly never call us Mr or Mrs. I'm sure for some manners are old fashioned and unimportant, but it made an impression on us.
This is a huge selling point. My kids are young at a Catholic school and I volunteered for lunch duty. The middle school kids talked amongst themselves about normal things (clothes, anime, books), threw out all their trash, and THANKED ME for wiping the tables down! Of course it helps that no phones are allowed. If my kids turn out to be nice adolescents like that I'll consider it the best money I ever spent.
Agree, I'm the PP and once we enrolled I did lunch duty and saw the same. So it wasn't just a one off with a friendly 8th grader. They were supposed to be respectful of the volunteers (as well as others) and were reminded to say please and thank you at every turn such that by 8th grade it was ingrained. And as for the community part, when I saw kids from the school around town that I knew, because it was a small community I looked out for them. I once saw a group of older boys try to leave a fast food restaurant without cleaning their tables and asked them to throw their trash out. I vaguely knew them, I definitely knew their families, they recognized me and they promptly cleaned up and said "sorry, we forgot". In a bigger school it's likely I wouldn't have known those boys and certainly wouldn't have approached them. And I didn't get an angry call from an irate parent, the parents would have appreciated me making sure they cleaned up after themselves.
Anonymous
09/06/2023 19:07
Subject: How does Catholic school make kids so outgoing and gregarious?
Anonymous wrote:Booze. Big loud families. Lots of fun sports events. And not really caring about academics.
Heck, it sounds amazing!!!
-not kidding. Kind of wished we were Catholic.
It is amazing 😂. My mom is 100% Irish and my dad is half Italian. Lots of big family get togethers and holidays and weddings are legendary. We have so much fun. Lots of smart, athletic people.