Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 17:19     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:On the Saturday evening AmTrak from Williamsburg (1 block from campus) to Alexandria (AKA, the Hogworts Express), the Conductor announced a welcome home the 450 W& M students they were dropping off. Kids also came home Friday evening, Sat am, and there were two trains Sunday. And, of course, some kids drove and some were picked up.

Contrast this with 35 kids a year from MoCo.


Huh?


Multiple points here:

1. How many NOVA kids are attending W&M and contrasting it to how few from MoCo, indicating the OOS state competitiveness
2. Amtrak is an easy connector to travel between the college & NOVA
3. The conductor geeking out on Harry Potter, not a bad comparison in my opinion regarding the train around holidays
4. Poster was humble by not mentioning how the conductor praised the W&M students as the kindest & nicest passengers he's had. Yes, multiple parents verified this on FB as being true and student confirmed.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 17:12     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:On the Saturday evening AmTrak from Williamsburg (1 block from campus) to Alexandria (AKA, the Hogworts Express), the Conductor announced a welcome home the 450 W& M students they were dropping off. Kids also came home Friday evening, Sat am, and there were two trains Sunday. And, of course, some kids drove and some were picked up.

Contrast this with 35 kids a year from MoCo.


Huh?


It is a funny allegory meant to demonstrate the difficulty of applying from Md, I think. I didn’t want to point out those on the train were from any graduating year, grad school, law school etc. I am guessing the 35 is an extrapolated number of enrolled freshmen based on the 66 MD members of last year’s freshmen class. Apples to oranges, but I like hearing about the kids on the train home for the holidays
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 17:05     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:On the Saturday evening AmTrak from Williamsburg (1 block from campus) to Alexandria (AKA, the Hogworts Express), the Conductor announced a welcome home the 450 W& M students they were dropping off. Kids also came home Friday evening, Sat am, and there were two trains Sunday. And, of course, some kids drove and some were picked up.

Contrast this with 35 kids a year from MoCo.


Huh?
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 17:00     Subject: William and Mary
Not one student with similar stats in past five years on Naviance has been rejected from our large MCPS high school with many applicants. I’d still show interest in case they start yield protecting at that level.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 15:25     Subject: Re:William and Mary
It also depends how many they take early. I think Tulane takes so many early that for the RD round admission rate is like 1% or something. What matters here is the RD acceptance rates for in and out of state. But certainly sounds like a VERY strong candidate wherever he applies.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 15:13     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am confused about the data on here. Kid has perfect 4.0 unweighted (so that would mean all A’s) and a ton of AP classes if weighted GPA is a 4.7. From a good Montgomery County school. And test scores are 1570, with good extra curriculars (I am going to take that to mean a leadership position and long term involvement in some activity).

And the OOS and In-state admit rates are about 10% difference (40% and 30% roughly). Wouldn’t this kid have a decent shot? There are posters who said kids got in with a 1360 SAT and another with a C.

I understand ED would be a surer bet, instate is better, and the kid needs to demonstrate interest, but wouldn’t RD at least be considered a match?


Yes, there is a lot of bad advice here. Very good chance of getting in with these scores, even RD OOS.


+1. Try to have him sign up and attend some of their virtual events. I think they have a virtual tour as well.


As in, do the virtual tour even if the kid did the in person tour?


Yes, it cannot hurt. DD toured the campus in person another time after a guided tour. Signed up for multiple online panels, especially in areas of interest.
There might always be one new snipped of info that was not shared in the other version/tour.



Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 15:10     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am confused about the data on here. Kid has perfect 4.0 unweighted (so that would mean all A’s) and a ton of AP classes if weighted GPA is a 4.7. From a good Montgomery County school. And test scores are 1570, with good extra curriculars (I am going to take that to mean a leadership position and long term involvement in some activity).

And the OOS and In-state admit rates are about 10% difference (40% and 30% roughly). Wouldn’t this kid have a decent shot? There are posters who said kids got in with a 1360 SAT and another with a C.

I understand ED would be a surer bet, instate is better, and the kid needs to demonstrate interest, but wouldn’t RD at least be considered a match?


I understood the public schools give a 4 for a B in an advanced class. So not necessarily straight As. I know, those of us with unweighted scores don’t get this. That is not straight a stats, right OP?


I'm OP. Yes, straight As from MCPS school.


This is just personal observation, but it seems like WM takes so many kids from NOVA publics and has so few OOS slots that they have higher standards from DC-MD kids than kids from other areas of the country. It’s like they don’t want to be a DMV majority/ regional school, and the NOVA part of that equation is not negotiable. They want to be a national U, so regional diversity plays a role. So a NY or CA (or Midwest!) kid may be more attractive than a MoCo kid. I don’t have numbers to back that up, but it tracks with what I’ve seen.

Remember, a WM class is 1600-1700 kids. Last year, they took 66 kids from MD. The whole state, not just MoCo.

https://www.wm.edu/admission/undergraduateadmission/facts-figures/class-profile/


This makes sense to me (unforunately, as an MCPS parent). OP's stats seem good enough for OOS RD ... but maybe not from Maryland. Maybe yes from other less represented states. Ugh.


They are certainly good enough, but just like those stats are good enough for Harvard, that doesn't mean that the student will get in. There is just a lot of competition, so there is a certain element of luck involved.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 15:09     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:IF OP has more questions, don't mean to stop conversation, but it feels like we have reached the "agree to disagree" part of the program and are opinions don't really matter (unless there is an AO on here).

I would bet kid will be admitted but I readily admit I am speculating without complete information (full application). Please report back in March! Good luck to your student. Sounds like he worked hard throughout HS and I wish him to the best.


*our (sorry typing too quickly)
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 15:06     Subject: William and Mary
IF OP has more questions, don't mean to stop conversation, but it feels like we have reached the "agree to disagree" part of the program and are opinions don't really matter (unless there is an AO on here).

I would bet kid will be admitted but I readily admit I am speculating without complete information (full application). Please report back in March! Good luck to your student. Sounds like he worked hard throughout HS and I wish him to the best.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 14:57     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am confused about the data on here. Kid has perfect 4.0 unweighted (so that would mean all A’s) and a ton of AP classes if weighted GPA is a 4.7. From a good Montgomery County school. And test scores are 1570, with good extra curriculars (I am going to take that to mean a leadership position and long term involvement in some activity).

And the OOS and In-state admit rates are about 10% difference (40% and 30% roughly). Wouldn’t this kid have a decent shot? There are posters who said kids got in with a 1360 SAT and another with a C.

I understand ED would be a surer bet, instate is better, and the kid needs to demonstrate interest, but wouldn’t RD at least be considered a match?


I understood the public schools give a 4 for a B in an advanced class. So not necessarily straight As. I know, those of us with unweighted scores don’t get this. That is not straight a stats, right OP?


I'm OP. Yes, straight As from MCPS school.


This is just personal observation, but it seems like WM takes so many kids from NOVA publics and has so few OOS slots that they have higher standards from DC-MD kids than kids from other areas of the country. It’s like they don’t want to be a DMV majority/ regional school, and the NOVA part of that equation is not negotiable. They want to be a national U, so regional diversity plays a role. So a NY or CA (or Midwest!) kid may be more attractive than a MoCo kid. I don’t have numbers to back that up, but it tracks with what I’ve seen.

Remember, a WM class is 1600-1700 kids. Last year, they took 66 kids from MD. The whole state, not just MoCo.

https://www.wm.edu/admission/undergraduateadmission/facts-figures/class-profile/


This makes sense to me (unforunately, as an MCPS parent). OP's stats seem good enough for OOS RD ... but maybe not from Maryland. Maybe yes from other less represented states. Ugh.


Those numbers are the kids who attended right? Not those who were accepted.


Yes, but— a decent percent we’re accepted ED, where accepted = attended.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 14:56     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am confused about the data on here. Kid has perfect 4.0 unweighted (so that would mean all A’s) and a ton of AP classes if weighted GPA is a 4.7. From a good Montgomery County school. And test scores are 1570, with good extra curriculars (I am going to take that to mean a leadership position and long term involvement in some activity).

And the OOS and In-state admit rates are about 10% difference (40% and 30% roughly). Wouldn’t this kid have a decent shot? There are posters who said kids got in with a 1360 SAT and another with a C.

I understand ED would be a surer bet, instate is better, and the kid needs to demonstrate interest, but wouldn’t RD at least be considered a match?


I understood the public schools give a 4 for a B in an advanced class. So not necessarily straight As. I know, those of us with unweighted scores don’t get this. That is not straight a stats, right OP?


I'm OP. Yes, straight As from MCPS school.


This is just personal observation, but it seems like WM takes so many kids from NOVA publics and has so few OOS slots that they have higher standards from DC-MD kids than kids from other areas of the country. It’s like they don’t want to be a DMV majority/ regional school, and the NOVA part of that equation is not negotiable. They want to be a national U, so regional diversity plays a role. So a NY or CA (or Midwest!) kid may be more attractive than a MoCo kid. I don’t have numbers to back that up, but it tracks with what I’ve seen.

Remember, a WM class is 1600-1700 kids. Last year, they took 66 kids from MD. The whole state, not just MoCo.

https://www.wm.edu/admission/undergraduateadmission/facts-figures/class-profile/


This makes sense to me (unforunately, as an MCPS parent). OP's stats seem good enough for OOS RD ... but maybe not from Maryland. Maybe yes from other less represented states. Ugh.


Those numbers are the kids who attended right? Not those who were accepted.


Correct 66 that is number attending, and yield rate for OOS is 18% per the SCHEV link posted earlier, so presumably many more MD kids were admitted - probably double or triple.

Nobody is saying an acceptance is a done deal but stats look good to me - certainly worth pursuing if kid likes W&M.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 14:53     Subject: William and Mary
On the Saturday evening AmTrak from Williamsburg (1 block from campus) to Alexandria (AKA, the Hogworts Express), the Conductor announced a welcome home the 450 W& M students they were dropping off. Kids also came home Friday evening, Sat am, and there were two trains Sunday. And, of course, some kids drove and some were picked up.

Contrast this with 35 kids a year from MoCo.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 14:48     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am confused about the data on here. Kid has perfect 4.0 unweighted (so that would mean all A’s) and a ton of AP classes if weighted GPA is a 4.7. From a good Montgomery County school. And test scores are 1570, with good extra curriculars (I am going to take that to mean a leadership position and long term involvement in some activity).

And the OOS and In-state admit rates are about 10% difference (40% and 30% roughly). Wouldn’t this kid have a decent shot? There are posters who said kids got in with a 1360 SAT and another with a C.

I understand ED would be a surer bet, instate is better, and the kid needs to demonstrate interest, but wouldn’t RD at least be considered a match?


I understood the public schools give a 4 for a B in an advanced class. So not necessarily straight As. I know, those of us with unweighted scores don’t get this. That is not straight a stats, right OP?


I'm OP. Yes, straight As from MCPS school.


This is just personal observation, but it seems like WM takes so many kids from NOVA publics and has so few OOS slots that they have higher standards from DC-MD kids than kids from other areas of the country. It’s like they don’t want to be a DMV majority/ regional school, and the NOVA part of that equation is not negotiable. They want to be a national U, so regional diversity plays a role. So a NY or CA (or Midwest!) kid may be more attractive than a MoCo kid. I don’t have numbers to back that up, but it tracks with what I’ve seen.

Remember, a WM class is 1600-1700 kids. Last year, they took 66 kids from MD. The whole state, not just MoCo.

https://www.wm.edu/admission/undergraduateadmission/facts-figures/class-profile/


This makes sense to me (unforunately, as an MCPS parent). OP's stats seem good enough for OOS RD ... but maybe not from Maryland. Maybe yes from other less represented states. Ugh.


Those numbers are the kids who attended right? Not those who were accepted.
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 14:47     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am confused about the data on here. Kid has perfect 4.0 unweighted (so that would mean all A’s) and a ton of AP classes if weighted GPA is a 4.7. From a good Montgomery County school. And test scores are 1570, with good extra curriculars (I am going to take that to mean a leadership position and long term involvement in some activity).

And the OOS and In-state admit rates are about 10% difference (40% and 30% roughly). Wouldn’t this kid have a decent shot? There are posters who said kids got in with a 1360 SAT and another with a C.

I understand ED would be a surer bet, instate is better, and the kid needs to demonstrate interest, but wouldn’t RD at least be considered a match?


I understood the public schools give a 4 for a B in an advanced class. So not necessarily straight As. I know, those of us with unweighted scores don’t get this. That is not straight a stats, right OP?


I'm OP. Yes, straight As from MCPS school.


Congrats to your kid, OP! And I am guessing he has significant rigor if weighted is 4.7 at a MoCo public. My hunch is he has BC Calc and a foreign language to boot.


OP’s son may have that, so no knock on him, but plenty of 4.0 students have the 4.0 precisely because they did not take BC calculus and AP world language. AP stat and honors Spanish give one’s gpa the same boost in MCPS as do BC calculus and Ap spanish!


He has AP World Lang and AP Calc AB, not BC...
Anonymous
Post 11/30/2022 14:46     Subject: William and Mary
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am confused about the data on here. Kid has perfect 4.0 unweighted (so that would mean all A’s) and a ton of AP classes if weighted GPA is a 4.7. From a good Montgomery County school. And test scores are 1570, with good extra curriculars (I am going to take that to mean a leadership position and long term involvement in some activity).

And the OOS and In-state admit rates are about 10% difference (40% and 30% roughly). Wouldn’t this kid have a decent shot? There are posters who said kids got in with a 1360 SAT and another with a C.

I understand ED would be a surer bet, instate is better, and the kid needs to demonstrate interest, but wouldn’t RD at least be considered a match?


Yes, there is a lot of bad advice here. Very good chance of getting in with these scores, even RD OOS.


+1. Try to have him sign up and attend some of their virtual events. I think they have a virtual tour as well.


As in, do the virtual tour even if the kid did the in person tour?