Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is OP. Thank you for the suggestions! In law school professors called it “fighting the hypo” (as in hypothetical) when students wouldn’t just answer the question but instead needed to change the question to something else. I’m noticing that now two responders are saying, “don’t give her iron for dinner, do it at other meals!” DCUM can’t resist fighting the hypo. It’s kind of fascinating. I wonder if I do it to other people or if I just don’t answer if I don’t have an answer to OP’s question. I am also going to notice if it happens so much in real life or if this is just a DCUM thing.
Sounds like you have a little research project, OP. Congrats!
After you do that, perhaps you could google "foods rich in iron," and cross reference the responses with "foods your kid likes." When you're finished, please return here and we'll let you know how to use that information.
This x100. I’ve never heard of “fighting the hypo,” but I think this is more of an “ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer” situation.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is OP. Thank you for the suggestions! In law school professors called it “fighting the hypo” (as in hypothetical) when students wouldn’t just answer the question but instead needed to change the question to something else. I’m noticing that now two responders are saying, “don’t give her iron for dinner, do it at other meals!” DCUM can’t resist fighting the hypo. It’s kind of fascinating. I wonder if I do it to other people or if I just don’t answer if I don’t have an answer to OP’s question. I am also going to notice if it happens so much in real life or if this is just a DCUM thing.
It's not that some of us aren't deliberately posting a direct answer to your question, but just giving you another perspective and option that you might not have thought of and could work out well...especially since " give her iron at other meals" (and other similar ideas posted upthread) isn't an unreasonable suggestion....AND it might actually "work" if you are open-minded and give it a try 1x or 2x a week.
There's no harm in this. There's a lot of us who have BTDT when it comes to chronic anemia .
Yes, but DCUM always assumes that people are kind of dumb and haven't thought of the other perspectives themselves. I mean, if OP's child has an iron problem at age 5 and she has even talked to a doctor about it, I'm sure she's considered these other (rather obvious) ideas already and whether they work for her.
Anonymous wrote:OP, has your daughter been tested for celiac disease?
Celiac disease in a young person can cause the anemia.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is OP. Thank you for the suggestions! In law school professors called it “fighting the hypo” (as in hypothetical) when students wouldn’t just answer the question but instead needed to change the question to something else. I’m noticing that now two responders are saying, “don’t give her iron for dinner, do it at other meals!” DCUM can’t resist fighting the hypo. It’s kind of fascinating. I wonder if I do it to other people or if I just don’t answer if I don’t have an answer to OP’s question. I am also going to notice if it happens so much in real life or if this is just a DCUM thing.
Sounds like you have a little research project, OP. Congrats!
After you do that, perhaps you could google "foods rich in iron," and cross reference the responses with "foods your kid likes." When you're finished, please return here and we'll let you know how to use that information.
This x100. I’ve never heard of “fighting the hypo,” but I think this is more of an “ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer” situation.
Anonymous wrote:This is OP. Thank you for the suggestions! In law school professors called it “fighting the hypo” (as in hypothetical) when students wouldn’t just answer the question but instead needed to change the question to something else. I’m noticing that now two responders are saying, “don’t give her iron for dinner, do it at other meals!” DCUM can’t resist fighting the hypo. It’s kind of fascinating. I wonder if I do it to other people or if I just don’t answer if I don’t have an answer to OP’s question. I am also going to notice if it happens so much in real life or if this is just a DCUM thing.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is OP. Thank you for the suggestions! In law school professors called it “fighting the hypo” (as in hypothetical) when students wouldn’t just answer the question but instead needed to change the question to something else. I’m noticing that now two responders are saying, “don’t give her iron for dinner, do it at other meals!” DCUM can’t resist fighting the hypo. It’s kind of fascinating. I wonder if I do it to other people or if I just don’t answer if I don’t have an answer to OP’s question. I am also going to notice if it happens so much in real life or if this is just a DCUM thing.
Sounds like you have a little research project, OP. Congrats!
After you do that, perhaps you could google "foods rich in iron," and cross reference the responses with "foods your kid likes." When you're finished, please return here and we'll let you know how to use that information.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is OP. Thank you for the suggestions! In law school professors called it “fighting the hypo” (as in hypothetical) when students wouldn’t just answer the question but instead needed to change the question to something else. I’m noticing that now two responders are saying, “don’t give her iron for dinner, do it at other meals!” DCUM can’t resist fighting the hypo. It’s kind of fascinating. I wonder if I do it to other people or if I just don’t answer if I don’t have an answer to OP’s question. I am also going to notice if it happens so much in real life or if this is just a DCUM thing.
It's not that some of us aren't deliberately posting a direct answer to your question, but just giving you another perspective and option that you might not have thought of and could work out well...especially since " give her iron at other meals" (and other similar ideas posted upthread) isn't an unreasonable suggestion....AND it might actually "work" if you are open-minded and give it a try 1x or 2x a week.
There's no harm in this. There's a lot of us who have BTDT when it comes to chronic anemia .
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is OP. She’s anemic and a supplement hasn’t raised her iron enough to make her not anemic. So her doctor suggested high iron meals in addition to supplement for the next 3 months and then recheck. I do appreciate the suggestions but every time I ask something on DCUM it drives me nuts that multiple folks won’t just answer the question and instead second guess the premise of the question.
Thanks to folks who offered suggestions!
If my kid had anemia I don’t think I’d be dragging them to the pool to eat their dinner out of a bag. I’d prepare a fresh thoughtful sit down meal that’s will nourish they body and then hit the pool or whatever.
My youngest was anemic and I fed him liver, red meat and plenty of seafood. I also made spinach mufffins with chickpea flour.