Anonymous
11/29/2021 08:33
Subject: Basketball Roster Size - Rec
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How do they balance the teams without having a draft?
They don't. You end up with a ton of blowouts and a miserable experience for the kids on the noncompetitive teams. The kids on the good teams learn the mercy rules quickly; DD's team has a special defense they play once they reach the point that they can't defend past the foul line.
Why on earth would anyone sign their kid up to play in a league like this?
Seriously! I have never heard of a basketball rec league that didn’t care about balanced teams. That’s not fun for any of the kids.
And yes, a kid who can barely dribble should get a turn once or twice a game playing point guard. It’s REC.
Coaches like you are the reason DD plays county now. The tall kid who can dribble better than the coaches kid may want to play the point on occasion or take an outside jumper instead of constantly having to stand in the post. Thankfully, her travel coach plays kids based on where they are capable of playing rather than where the coach prefers them.
Never heard of standing in the post being a bad thing. Isn’t that where the tall players who are good at shooting go?
It means they never learn how to do anything else in a game and the tall kids don't necessarily stay the tall kids.
Anonymous
11/29/2021 08:05
Subject: Basketball Roster Size - Rec
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How do they balance the teams without having a draft?
They don't. You end up with a ton of blowouts and a miserable experience for the kids on the noncompetitive teams. The kids on the good teams learn the mercy rules quickly; DD's team has a special defense they play once they reach the point that they can't defend past the foul line.
Why on earth would anyone sign their kid up to play in a league like this?
Seriously! I have never heard of a basketball rec league that didn’t care about balanced teams. That’s not fun for any of the kids.
And yes, a kid who can barely dribble should get a turn once or twice a game playing point guard. It’s REC.
Coaches like you are the reason DD plays county now. The tall kid who can dribble better than the coaches kid may want to play the point on occasion or take an outside jumper instead of constantly having to stand in the post. Thankfully, her travel coach plays kids based on where they are capable of playing rather than where the coach prefers them.
Never heard of standing in the post being a bad thing. Isn’t that where the tall players who are good at shooting go?
Anonymous
11/29/2021 08:00
Subject: Basketball Roster Size - Rec
Anonymous wrote:I don't know of any leagues in DC, Moco, or Fairfax that have drafts for rec basketball. That is just not a thing here.
What are you talking about? Every community rec league we know does drafts after 4th grade or so. Gainesville, Loudoun, SYA, CYA, Burke, BRYC, Vienna...should I go on? There is NO way to run a fair league without drafting teams for basketball.
Anonymous
11/28/2021 23:27
Subject: Basketball Roster Size - Rec
surprised to find this thread is still going, but DD got in the team so all is good now.
-OP
-OP
Anonymous
11/28/2021 20:19
Subject: Basketball Roster Size - Rec
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:How do they balance the teams without having a draft?
They don't. You end up with a ton of blowouts and a miserable experience for the kids on the noncompetitive teams. The kids on the good teams learn the mercy rules quickly; DD's team has a special defense they play once they reach the point that they can't defend past the foul line.
Why on earth would anyone sign their kid up to play in a league like this?
Seriously! I have never heard of a basketball rec league that didn’t care about balanced teams. That’s not fun for any of the kids.
And yes, a kid who can barely dribble should get a turn once or twice a game playing point guard. It’s REC.
Coaches like you are the reason DD plays county now. The tall kid who can dribble better than the coaches kid may want to play the point on occasion or take an outside jumper instead of constantly having to stand in the post. Thankfully, her travel coach plays kids based on where they are capable of playing rather than where the coach prefers them.