Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Is this the counselor rating?

No, the peer reputation score is made by surveying university presidents and deans, whose opinions are manifold more credible than the anonymous posters with big opinions on DCUM.

It’s the Berkeley booster cherry-picking data again.

We’re talking about the overall US News ranking, not those of “anonymous posters with big opinions.” People keep explaining to you that validity of the peer reputation data is low, which is why US News doesn’t put more weight on it.

-NP

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Is this the counselor rating?

No, the peer reputation score is made by surveying university presidents and deans, whose opinions are manifold more credible than the anonymous posters with big opinions on DCUM.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Is this the counselor rating?

I think so, the peer Reputation ranking are different numbers. Harvard is a 4.9

No, you’re thinking of a prior year’s scores. These are the updated peer reputation scores, from the survey that university presidents fill out.

No it's this year's scores, I just looked, I have a subscription. And Harvards reputation would never change from year to year. It's 4.9 .

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Is this the counselor rating?

I think so, the peer Reputation ranking are different numbers. Harvard is a 4.9

No, you’re thinking of a prior year’s scores. These are the updated peer reputation scores, from the survey that university presidents fill out.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Is this the counselor rating?

I think so, the peer Reputation ranking are different numbers. Harvard is a 4.9

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Is this the counselor rating?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Is this the counselor rating?

Anonymous wrote:
Not many, but a few, surprises here … Go Blue!

https://www.newsweek.com/colleges-most-famous-alumni-1605419

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:tiers based on cross admit preferences, September 2021 edition:

Harvard (55% picks over Stanford, 69% over Yale, 58% over MIT, and 77% over Princeton, 85% over Columbia)

Stanford (loses to Harvard, but 66% over MIT, 61% over Yale, 71% over Princeton, 83% over Columbia)

------------------------------

MIT (loses to H and S, 67% over Yale, 55% over Princeton, 76% over Columbia, 81% over Caltech)

Yale (loses to H, S, and M, but wins 61% over Princeton, 70% over Columbia, 50%-50% tied with Caltech)

------------------------------

Princeton (loses to all of the above, 65% over Columbia, 56% over Caltech, 76% over Penn, 80% over Duke, 62% over Chicago)

Columbia (loses to HYPSM but wins 58% over Caltech, 63% over Penn/Duke, 73% over Brown/Dartmouth, 65% over Chicago)

Caltech (loses to HYPSM, Columbia, but edges out Penn with 56%, Duke with 75%, Brown with 57%, Dartmouth with 60%, loses to Chicago with 47%, tied with Yale 50%-50%) - really an outlier here

------------------------------

Penn (loses to Columbia, Caltech and HYPSM, 51% over Duke, wins 63% over Brown, 60% over Dartmouth, and 60% over Chicago)

Duke (loses to HYPSM, Columbia, Caltech, and marginally loses to Penn by only 2%, 59% over Brown, 63% over Dartmouth, and 57% over Chicago)

------------------------------

Brown (loses to all of the above, tied 50%-50% with Chicago, but 65% over Dartmouth, 76% over Cornell, 86% over JHU, 64% over Northwestern, 67% over Rice)

Chicago (loses to all of the above except Caltech, tied 50%-50% with Brown, 54% over Dartmouth, 69% over Northwestern, 69% over JHU, 66% over Rice)

Dartmouth (loses to all of the above, 68% over Cornell, 59% over JHU, 61% over Northwestern, 71% over Rice)

------------------------------

Cornell (loses to all of the above, 55% over Northwestern, 54% over JHU/Notre Dame, roughly tied with WashU, loses 47% to Rice)

Northwestern (loses to all of the above, 65% over JHU, 66% over Vanderbilt, 51% over WashU, 58% over Rice, but loses 44% to Notre Dame)

Rice (loses to all of the above, 55% over JHU, 57% over WashU, 53% over Cornell, 54% over Notre Dame)

JHU (loses to all of the above, 50-50% tied with Notre Dame, 57% over Vanderbilt, 53% over WashU)

Notre Dame (loses to all above, 50-50% tied with JHU, 74% over WashU, 70% over Vanderbilt)

WashU (roughly tied or loses to all of the above, 56% over Vanderbilt)

Vanderbilt (loses to all of the above, 50-50% tied with Rice)

------------------------------

UCLA and other USNWR 20+ schools (loses to all of the above)

Parchment also says,

60% Wake Forest vs 40% Princeton
57% Virginia Tech vs 43% Princeton
68% Virginia Tech vs 33% Yale
57% James Madison U vs 43% Harvard
60% James Madison vs 40% Yale

Parchment says so - with 95% confidence interval - so it must be so.

Anonymous wrote:Top 10 universities based on peer reputation (2022)

1 -MIT
1 -Stanford
1 -Columbia
4 - Princeton
4 - Yale
6 - Harvard
6 - Northwestern
6 - UC - Berkeley
9 - Chicago
9 - Penn
9 - Caltech
9 - Rice

Significant movers - Peer ranking vs. overall ranking:

Top 20 Peer ranked, up 5 or more spots from National rank - Stanford, Berkley, Rice, Michigan

Top 20, down 5 or more spots - Duke, Vanderbilt
20-50, up 10 or more spots - Georgia Tech, UT-Austin, Wisconsin, UIUC, Ohio State, Washington, Purdue, Virginia Tech
20-50, down 10 or more spots - WashStL, Cornell, Florida, Tufts, Wake Forest, UC_Santa Barbara

50-100, up 25 or more - Colorado, Iowa, Arizona, Oregon, UC-Santa Cruz

50-100, down 25 or more - Rochester, Lehigh, Santa Clara, WPI, Yeshiva

Anonymous wrote:How many times do we have to say... Parchment is not accurate.