Anonymous wrote:Ha, I was watching with close captions on because everyone was asleep at home. I turned the volume low and CC on.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This is a really stupid question: we did not hear the final interviews of the women involved in the death scene, just the clicking of the detective's lighter. I assumed this was intentional, but we weren't 100% sure that maybe our sound just didn't go out. Without hearing those interviews, just not sure what "lying" everyone is talking about. I have to assume they lied in the interviews and in fact, our sound went out for 1 minute. I read the book, so I knew what was going on and thought maybe this was some strange plot device so that we, as viewers, wouldn't know exactly what they said. I hope HBO is replaying this so I can re-record with sound.

It wasn't your tv. There was no audio when they showed the various women being interviewed at the end.

Thank you for clarifying that. Then how does everybody here know what stories they gave? Because of the book? As I said, I figured it was just David Kelley's way of handling it (though I really don't get why), and the cop said enough to imply that their stories matched too precisely which let us know they were covering. But a PP said that their stories were that he tripped, but we never heard that, right?

You can read everyone's lips saying "he tripped and fell backward down the stairs" and then the sounds comes back on Celeste says the same thing.

They were really emphasizing their mouths making a hard "f" in "fell." That was one word a viewer could tell they all agreed on. I thought it was incredibly well done. And good point PP about how not having sound makes the viewer pay more attention to how distraught they all looked.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This is a really stupid question: we did not hear the final interviews of the women involved in the death scene, just the clicking of the detective's lighter. I assumed this was intentional, but we weren't 100% sure that maybe our sound just didn't go out. Without hearing those interviews, just not sure what "lying" everyone is talking about. I have to assume they lied in the interviews and in fact, our sound went out for 1 minute. I read the book, so I knew what was going on and thought maybe this was some strange plot device so that we, as viewers, wouldn't know exactly what they said. I hope HBO is replaying this so I can re-record with sound.

It wasn't your tv. There was no audio when they showed the various women being interviewed at the end.

Thank you for clarifying that. Then how does everybody here know what stories they gave? Because of the book? As I said, I figured it was just David Kelley's way of handling it (though I really don't get why), and the cop said enough to imply that their stories matched too precisely which let us know they were covering. But a PP said that their stories were that he tripped, but we never heard that, right?

You can read everyone's lips saying "he tripped and fell backward down the stairs" and then the sounds comes back on Celeste says the same thing.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why didn't they keep the part where "Larry" donates to Abby to shut down her auction?!? SO GOOD!

I agree- wish this would have been included. I thought the show was really good!

Anonymous wrote:Why didn't they keep the part where "Larry" donates to Abby to shut down her auction?!? SO GOOD!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Did anyone notice Nicole Kidman's Australian accent creeping in during the argument in the car?

It didn't bother me, she was so excellent all the way through. The scene where they're walking out of the house after Perry returned her phone was so chilling.

I also like the way they showed the abuse in flashbacks. In the book, Celeste is a distracted and forgetful person and the reasons were portrayed well here.

Yes, I noticed that too, and it was somewhat distracting in the moment, but like you said, she was so excellent overall.

I couldn't figure out if Bonnie stabbed Perry with something or if he landed on something, and in either case, what was it? Wasn't there something sticking out of his throat?

I think the clicking and binoculars at the end mean that the female detective is still on the case.

I do love how they all came together at the end. I really liked Renata at the end!

Anonymous wrote:Did anyone notice Nicole Kidman's Australian accent creeping in during the argument in the car?

It didn't bother me, she was so excellent all the way through. The scene where they're walking out of the house after Perry returned her phone was so chilling.

I also like the way they showed the abuse in flashbacks. In the book, Celeste is a distracted and forgetful person and the reasons were portrayed well here.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok now I can finally say;
The madeleine affair was not in the book and I'm super annoyed they added it

0f all the changes from the book, the affair was one big change I don't think was worth it. It raised conflict that wasn't really resolved except for Madeline saying Ed's the best guy she knows (after he killed Elvis's Wonder of You).

The awesome music was at its finest tonight. But how was Perry's push/fall of a dozen streps enough for all that blood and his death?

Loved the women and Judd on the beach ending.

Anonymous wrote:The female detective says to "turn it off" or similar words regarding the sound to the interrogation room as she watches the women trough the window as they're being interrogated. She doesn't want to hear any more because she says they're all lying. She "knows" they're lying because their stories are all "too similar". But doesn't the male detective respond something like "may be they're not lying. Let it go."