Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 16:19     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
How many EDP players just got called up to the U17 camp?
How many D1 college coaches watch EDP showcases?

EDP in NOVA is not the same as EDP in regions were there are no ECNL or GA options for the players.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 16:14     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:just so you know, many D3 college starters at the top 50 D3 schools could have played at D1 but elected not to.


Yup, the old, “She wanted D3”.


Yeah, why on earth would a kid go somewhere like Amherst when they could play soccer for New Mexico State
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 16:13     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:The most important attribute that a girl needs to play ecnl is parents willing to pay for ecnl. The rest is secondary


☝️☝️
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 16:12     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:just so you know, many D3 college starters at the top 50 D3 schools could have played at D1 but elected not to.


Yup, the old, “She wanted D3”.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 16:06     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:just so you know, many D3 college starters at the top 50 D3 schools could have played at D1 but elected not to.


Source, just so I know where you are getting your info?
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 15:54     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
just so you know, many D3 college starters at the top 50 D3 schools could have played at D1 but elected not to.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 15:52     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
go on youtube and look at any ECNL game at any age group.

20% (2 on a team) of the players on a team have GENUINE TALENT. 60%. are alright and can use their athletic ability over skill. 20% of the players (2 on a team) could be interchanged with other good players who are not playing ECNL.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 15:29     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
The most important attribute that a girl needs to play ecnl is parents willing to pay for ecnl. The rest is secondary
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 15:13     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:There are u15 and older players at clubs unaffiliated with ECNL/GA. There players can easily make and contribute to the most competitive ECNL teams in the area.


I don’t think anyone is arguing with that. In no way does ECNL have a monopoly on talented soccers kids. I think the initial questions were asking for broad observations between the level of competitiveness in ECNL vs EDP, which I believe is fair game to state that ECNL players and competition are better. Are there talented EDP girls that could play in ECNL, of course. Likewise, there’s a lot of DIII players who could be successful playing DI soccer but if you asked me if DI soccer players are faster, better than DIII players, the answer is yes.


LOL.

You could have just left it at “are there talented EDP players who could play in ECNL, of course.

The rest was just nonsense.


Just providing the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Happy to be of service


Quite a large percentage of ECNL players play D3.

Truth. Happy to be of service.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 13:02     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:There are u15 and older players at clubs unaffiliated with ECNL/GA. There players can easily make and contribute to the most competitive ECNL teams in the area.


I don’t think anyone is arguing with that. In no way does ECNL have a monopoly on talented soccers kids. I think the initial questions were asking for broad observations between the level of competitiveness in ECNL vs EDP, which I believe is fair game to state that ECNL players and competition are better. Are there talented EDP girls that could play in ECNL, of course. Likewise, there’s a lot of DIII players who could be successful playing DI soccer but if you asked me if DI soccer players are faster, better than DIII players, the answer is yes.


+1. It seems some posters are practically saying ECNL team roosters are all highly skilled, big & faster players. It is as if their teams have little Mia Hamm, Abby Wambach, etc. that can practically start and dominate at any positions on EDP teams.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 13:01     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:There are u15 and older players at clubs unaffiliated with ECNL/GA. There players can easily make and contribute to the most competitive ECNL teams in the area.


I don’t think anyone is arguing with that. In no way does ECNL have a monopoly on talented soccers kids. I think the initial questions were asking for broad observations between the level of competitiveness in ECNL vs EDP, which I believe is fair game to state that ECNL players and competition are better. Are there talented EDP girls that could play in ECNL, of course. Likewise, there’s a lot of DIII players who could be successful playing DI soccer but if you asked me if DI soccer players are faster, better than DIII players, the answer is yes.


LOL.

You could have just left it at “are there talented EDP players who could play in ECNL, of course.

The rest was just nonsense.


Just providing the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Happy to be of service
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 12:58     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:There are u15 and older players at clubs unaffiliated with ECNL/GA. There players can easily make and contribute to the most competitive ECNL teams in the area.


I don’t think anyone is arguing with that. In no way does ECNL have a monopoly on talented soccers kids. I think the initial questions were asking for broad observations between the level of competitiveness in ECNL vs EDP, which I believe is fair game to state that ECNL players and competition are better. Are there talented EDP girls that could play in ECNL, of course. Likewise, there’s a lot of DIII players who could be successful playing DI soccer but if you asked me if DI soccer players are faster, better than DIII players, the answer is yes.


LOL.

You could have just left it at “are there talented EDP players who could play in ECNL, of course.

The rest was just nonsense.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 12:50     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:There are u15 and older players at clubs unaffiliated with ECNL/GA. There players can easily make and contribute to the most competitive ECNL teams in the area.


I don’t think anyone is arguing with that. In no way does ECNL have a monopoly on talented soccers kids. I think the initial questions were asking for broad observations between the level of competitiveness in ECNL vs EDP, which I believe is fair game to state that ECNL players and competition are better. Are there talented EDP girls that could play in ECNL, of course. Likewise, there’s a lot of DIII players who could be successful playing DI soccer but if you asked me if DI soccer players are faster, better than DIII players, the answer is yes.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 12:15     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:God these ECNL threads are exhausting and repetitive, especially with the naysayers.

Here’s the deal OP: have your kid tryout. Have them attend several team’s sessions. She’ll know within one or two sessions if she’s a fit and whether it will be worth the time and money to play ECNL.


The naysayers need to keep up the illusion of unreachable eliteness. To them the thought of a plucky kid from a EDP trying out for their team at 15, making it and contributing would shatter the world they created.


Yep.

It's insanity.
Anonymous
Post 02/05/2021 12:06     Subject: Girls ECNL vs EDP players’ skills, attributes, etc.
There are u15 and older players at clubs unaffiliated with ECNL/GA. There players can easily make and contribute to the most competitive ECNL teams in the area.