Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I didn’t like big parts of it. She was so prim and proper and dressed well and it didn’t jive with her upbringing. By the time she was adopted, she would have already formed how she crossed her legs, how she sat upright, etc.
I didn’t like how the camera cuts away and ends an episode where she’s od’ed in the ground as a young girl and we learn nothing about what happened.
I don’t think you’ve watched every episode? Some scenes were flashbacks to earlier episodes.
Anonymous wrote:I didn’t like big parts of it. She was so prim and proper and dressed well and it didn’t jive with her upbringing. By the time she was adopted, she would have already formed how she crossed her legs, how she sat upright, etc.
I didn’t like how the camera cuts away and ends an episode where she’s od’ed in the ground as a young girl and we learn nothing about what happened.
Anonymous wrote:[SPOILER sort of]
So do we think she stayed in Russia? Or was that last scene meant to just hearken back to her games with the janitor in the basement?
Anonymous wrote:I have mixed feelings about this show. I hate to be the lone dissenter, but the worst part of it was the main character - Beth. She was the flattest, least sympathetic character I’ve seen in a long time. She never took the time to return to the orphanage and thank Mr. Shaibel. She used all her friends who had spent so much time helping her. She never once looked up her old friend, Jolene, after being adopted. Not even one letter. Jolene had nothing and Beth had everything - yet it was Jolene who came and found Beth.
I thought Anya Taylor-Joy was fantastic in “The Witch,” but this role did nothing for me.
Anonymous wrote:I loved it, but thought there were some details that were especially unrealistic. Like, I don't think an orphanage in Kentucky in the 40s would be integrated. Also, the idea that massive doses of tranquilizers would activate her chess prodigy seemed very far fetched. I could believe lsd or some hallucinogenic did that more than tranquilizers.
Anonymous wrote:I loved it, but thought there were some details that were especially unrealistic. Like, I don't think an orphanage in Kentucky in the 40s would be integrated. Also, the idea that massive doses of tranquilizers would activate her chess prodigy seemed very far fetched. I could believe lsd or some hallucinogenic did that more than tranquilizers.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:SPOILER DO NOT READ if you haven't seen the show! - how did her mom die? was it hepatitis? Is it related to her alcoholism?
She said she was in love with Townes? Is that the reporter? Why didn't she pursue that?
Who was the man her real mom Alice was talking to before she died? What were they saying?
That was Beth's dad and his new family/wife. She asks for help with taking care of Beth.
I wasn't sure about this scene. I thought it might be that she had an affair with a married man because he kept telling her she had to get out of there. If it was just a previous wife or relationship why all the secrecy? I feel like there were some unanswered questions with Beth's mom and why she felt she had to do what she did.
I thought her mother was a brilliant math ph.d who was perhaps bipolar or similar and was losing her mind. She was trying to drop off Beth with her real father to keep Beth safe, but when he refused she saw no alternative but to kill both herself and Beth in a car crash. But Beth survived.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:SPOILER DO NOT READ if you haven't seen the show! - how did her mom die? was it hepatitis? Is it related to her alcoholism?
She said she was in love with Townes? Is that the reporter? Why didn't she pursue that?
Who was the man her real mom Alice was talking to before she died? What were they saying?
That was Beth's dad and his new family/wife. She asks for help with taking care of Beth.
I wasn't sure about this scene. I thought it might be that she had an affair with a married man because he kept telling her she had to get out of there. If it was just a previous wife or relationship why all the secrecy? I feel like there were some unanswered questions with Beth's mom and why she felt she had to do what she did.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:SPOILER DO NOT READ if you haven't seen the show! - how did her mom die? was it hepatitis? Is it related to her alcoholism?
She said she was in love with Townes? Is that the reporter? Why didn't she pursue that?
Who was the man her real mom Alice was talking to before she died? What were they saying?
I thought her mom died in the car wreck? Wasn't exactly an accident, looked more like suicide to me. Her mom's last words to her were "Close your eyes."