House #1: My House: 5 bedrooms, 3.5 bedrooms, 3K sq ft including basement. One Car Carport, 4 bedrooms upstairs, 1 bedroom in basement with full bathroom, small but useable play space in basement, all bathrooms are very small (our biggest issue, as well as not garage), small bedrooms as well, and yard is small-ish and not flat. Good main level floor plan. When i originally bought the house the appraisal came in as 5 bedrooms and at my purchase price. Depending on the appraiser some might consider it a 4 bedroom since the window on in the bedroom in the basement is higher than a certain amount of feet. It was appraised as a 5 bedroom when I purchased it but then a 4 bedroom when I tried to refinance (and the appraisal came in at $25K under the purchase price).
You didn’t overpay for your house, you just bought a shitty house. A 5-bed in 3000 sq ft? A one-car carport? Why??