Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Altidore has scored more USMNT goals than:

- Brian McBride
- Roy Wegerle
- Eric Wynalda
- Earnie Stewart

He only scored 4 goals for the USMNT in the last 3 years.

He is the best we have....

That's debatable, but Altidore won't be the best in 2022, when it matters. Shouldn't a meaningless, cupcake CONCACAF tournament be used to test and develop young players? Wouldn't players like Weah, Sargent,Soto, Mendez, Dest, Llanez benefit from going to the tournament even as off the bench players?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Altidore has scored more USMNT goals than:

- Brian McBride
- Roy Wegerle
- Eric Wynalda
- Earnie Stewart

He only scored 4 goals for the USMNT in the last 3 years.

He is the best we have....

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Altidore has scored more USMNT goals than:

- Brian McBride
- Roy Wegerle
- Eric Wynalda
- Earnie Stewart

He only scored 4 goals for the USMNT in the last 3 years.

Anonymous wrote:Altidore has scored more USMNT goals than:

- Brian McBride
- Roy Wegerle
- Eric Wynalda
- Earnie Stewart

Anonymous wrote:Altidore has scored more USMNT goals than:

- Brian McBride
- Roy Wegerle
- Eric Wynalda
- Earnie Stewart

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Meh, Jozy will be 32, not 36. He still has one more WC in him. Let's concentrate on actually qualifying this time, and for that, we need our best players. He's our best striker, no questions asked.

His play also helps develop the other 10 guys on the field with him... Whoever posted the US was better against Venezuela with him on the field was spot on. It was night and day.

If he’s our best striker, then we aren’t qualifying. Lucky for us, he isn’t.

Who then?

Pulisic is an attacking mid
Johansson? I wish...
Bobby Wood looked like the answer at one point, but has knee problems and isn't playing for his club.
Sargent is promising, but it just getting started...
Zardes?

Well, you’re seeing why we struggle. My opinion is out with the old and in with the new. Start by using the only guy to ever play for PSG and have a great soccer parentage. Weah. He is untapped potential with creativity not seen on the USMNT and will strike fear into the opponent even if he is still a bit raw.

Also, yes Pulisic and Sargent. We have enough midfielders to move Pulisic. Use Weah and Pulisic up front with Sargent in the middle. Let the youth reign for the next several years and develop and grow towards the WC. Yes, play a 4-3-3. McKennie and Adams in mid with tbd (best player to emerge). Defense is a problem, so we need to score, hence the 3 young forwards. Let them gel along with the two promising young mids. On D ... I like Miazga but that is about it. Not sure what to do there other than never let John Brooks see the field again. He’s awful.

I'm with you to a degree, but that's an awfully young team. None of the players you mentioned but Pulisic are currently better than Altidore, and we can play him out of position, but why when we have a good alternative (in Altidore). Weah and Sargent certainly have the potential to be better than Jozy, but they aren't there yet. Weah was on the U20 team, otherwise I would have argued for his inclusion on the Gold Cup roster.

Sargent got screwed over, but I would have chosen him over Zardes, not Altidore.

Again, Altidore has had a career derailed by injuries, but he's not dead yet. At 32, he can still play a major role in 2022 (McBride was 34 in 2006), and I think he can still be a star in qualifying. How many "future stars" have not panned out for the US? Why give up on a proven winner just because he's imperfect?

He disappears during big games...he is not a proven winner.

Altidore is "MLS good." People assume he's good because he's good against weak opposition. But he isn't good enough in a world-class setting. We need players who are testing themselves day in and day out against real competition, like Pulisic, Sargent and Weah do in Europe.

Exactly we know what he is and he is not a world class striker. If he were he would have played for a top cub in a major league. As a striker he has aged out and is on the down ward side. Most likely will “retire” in a year or two. I never understood the media hype about him.

I agree that Josy is not a world class striker. He had some promise, but gave up fighting for the playing time in Europe and took a big paycheck from MLS. He and Bradley should not have been allowed to put on the national team jersey after their abysmal performance in Trinidad loss, which stopped USMNT from going to the WC.

No, Altidore isn't a world class striker, but he is a CONCACAF class striker...he's scored tons of goals against our local competition.
And, unfortunately, he's still the best striker we have.

Altidore is terrible on an international level. At one time looked more like a linebacker than a striker.

I can't believe the US doesn't have a single person that can play better than him.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Meh, Jozy will be 32, not 36. He still has one more WC in him. Let's concentrate on actually qualifying this time, and for that, we need our best players. He's our best striker, no questions asked.

His play also helps develop the other 10 guys on the field with him... Whoever posted the US was better against Venezuela with him on the field was spot on. It was night and day.

If he’s our best striker, then we aren’t qualifying. Lucky for us, he isn’t.

Who then?

Pulisic is an attacking mid
Johansson? I wish...
Bobby Wood looked like the answer at one point, but has knee problems and isn't playing for his club.
Sargent is promising, but it just getting started...
Zardes?

Well, you’re seeing why we struggle. My opinion is out with the old and in with the new. Start by using the only guy to ever play for PSG and have a great soccer parentage. Weah. He is untapped potential with creativity not seen on the USMNT and will strike fear into the opponent even if he is still a bit raw.

Also, yes Pulisic and Sargent. We have enough midfielders to move Pulisic. Use Weah and Pulisic up front with Sargent in the middle. Let the youth reign for the next several years and develop and grow towards the WC. Yes, play a 4-3-3. McKennie and Adams in mid with tbd (best player to emerge). Defense is a problem, so we need to score, hence the 3 young forwards. Let them gel along with the two promising young mids. On D ... I like Miazga but that is about it. Not sure what to do there other than never let John Brooks see the field again. He’s awful.

I'm with you to a degree, but that's an awfully young team. None of the players you mentioned but Pulisic are currently better than Altidore, and we can play him out of position, but why when we have a good alternative (in Altidore). Weah and Sargent certainly have the potential to be better than Jozy, but they aren't there yet. Weah was on the U20 team, otherwise I would have argued for his inclusion on the Gold Cup roster.

Sargent got screwed over, but I would have chosen him over Zardes, not Altidore.

Again, Altidore has had a career derailed by injuries, but he's not dead yet. At 32, he can still play a major role in 2022 (McBride was 34 in 2006), and I think he can still be a star in qualifying. How many "future stars" have not panned out for the US? Why give up on a proven winner just because he's imperfect?

He disappears during big games...he is not a proven winner.

Altidore is "MLS good." People assume he's good because he's good against weak opposition. But he isn't good enough in a world-class setting. We need players who are testing themselves day in and day out against real competition, like Pulisic, Sargent and Weah do in Europe.

Exactly we know what he is and he is not a world class striker. If he were he would have played for a top cub in a major league. As a striker he has aged out and is on the down ward side. Most likely will “retire” in a year or two. I never understood the media hype about him.

I agree that Josy is not a world class striker. He had some promise, but gave up fighting for the playing time in Europe and took a big paycheck from MLS. He and Bradley should not have been allowed to put on the national team jersey after their abysmal performance in Trinidad loss, which stopped USMNT from going to the WC.

No, Altidore isn't a world class striker, but he is a CONCACAF class striker...he's scored tons of goals against our local competition.
And, unfortunately, he's still the best striker we have.

Anonymous wrote:people watch this shit show?

Anonymous wrote:My god. Are we sure Zardes isn’t actually one of the Guyana forwards guest playing on the USMNT?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Meh, Jozy will be 32, not 36. He still has one more WC in him. Let's concentrate on actually qualifying this time, and for that, we need our best players. He's our best striker, no questions asked.

His play also helps develop the other 10 guys on the field with him... Whoever posted the US was better against Venezuela with him on the field was spot on. It was night and day.

If he’s our best striker, then we aren’t qualifying. Lucky for us, he isn’t.

Who then?

Pulisic is an attacking mid
Johansson? I wish...
Bobby Wood looked like the answer at one point, but has knee problems and isn't playing for his club.
Sargent is promising, but it just getting started...
Zardes?

Well, you’re seeing why we struggle. My opinion is out with the old and in with the new. Start by using the only guy to ever play for PSG and have a great soccer parentage. Weah. He is untapped potential with creativity not seen on the USMNT and will strike fear into the opponent even if he is still a bit raw.

Also, yes Pulisic and Sargent. We have enough midfielders to move Pulisic. Use Weah and Pulisic up front with Sargent in the middle. Let the youth reign for the next several years and develop and grow towards the WC. Yes, play a 4-3-3. McKennie and Adams in mid with tbd (best player to emerge). Defense is a problem, so we need to score, hence the 3 young forwards. Let them gel along with the two promising young mids. On D ... I like Miazga but that is about it. Not sure what to do there other than never let John Brooks see the field again. He’s awful.

I'm with you to a degree, but that's an awfully young team. None of the players you mentioned but Pulisic are currently better than Altidore, and we can play him out of position, but why when we have a good alternative (in Altidore). Weah and Sargent certainly have the potential to be better than Jozy, but they aren't there yet. Weah was on the U20 team, otherwise I would have argued for his inclusion on the Gold Cup roster.

Sargent got screwed over, but I would have chosen him over Zardes, not Altidore.

Again, Altidore has had a career derailed by injuries, but he's not dead yet. At 32, he can still play a major role in 2022 (McBride was 34 in 2006), and I think he can still be a star in qualifying. How many "future stars" have not panned out for the US? Why give up on a proven winner just because he's imperfect?

He disappears during big games...he is not a proven winner.

Altidore is "MLS good." People assume he's good because he's good against weak opposition. But he isn't good enough in a world-class setting. We need players who are testing themselves day in and day out against real competition, like Pulisic, Sargent and Weah do in Europe.

Exactly we know what he is and he is not a world class striker. If he were he would have played for a top cub in a major league. As a striker he has aged out and is on the down ward side. Most likely will “retire” in a year or two. I never understood the media hype about him.

I agree that Josy is not a world class striker. He had some promise, but gave up fighting for the playing time in Europe and took a big paycheck from MLS. He and Bradley should not have been allowed to put on the national team jersey after their abysmal performance in Trinidad loss, which stopped USMNT from going to the WC.