Anonymous wrote:Impossible for anyone to say what git them in. Eagle scout is part of a picture. Why wouldn't a long term commitment to an activity involving lots of leadership help?

...in a discriminatory organization that banned gay people. Impressive.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No one gets into college because they're an Eagle Scout.

My son got into William and Mary because he was an Eagle Scout.

LOL. My DS got into W&M and wasn't an Eagle Scout.! As for Penn State, it is a NUMBERS game. A GPA and SAT matrix.

You didn’t learn critical thinking at NVCC Loudoun

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No one gets into college because they're an Eagle Scout.

My son got into William and Mary because he was an Eagle Scout.

LOL. My DS got into W&M and wasn't an Eagle Scout.! As for Penn State, it is a NUMBERS game. A GPA and SAT matrix.

Impossible for anyone to say what git them in. Eagle scout is part of a picture. Why wouldn't a long term commitment to an activity involving lots of leadership help?

@Pedo State U. You get a tour of the you know what...

Yes, it will help. If not, apply to Hampton-Sydney and get a $20K scholarship. https://blog.scoutingmagazine.org/2017/12/28/eagle-scouts-at-this-college-get-an-automatic-5000-a-year-scholarship-and-heres-why/

Haha ha

this is cute.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No one gets into college because they're an Eagle Scout.

Yeah. That's not true. Clearly you don't know much about Eagle Scout. Not only did it get one of my kids into a great college, but it was what got him a fantastic job after graduation. The hiring manager was also Eagle. He flat out told my son his Eagle Scout was the tie breaker. I wish my other boys had stayed with it.

B.S. -- name the "great college" being an Eagle Scout got your kid into or it didn't happen.

URM status, grades, SAT all vastly more important.

VMI

NP: DS, Eagle got into UVA, three Ivies, and three top tech schools. His Eagle friends also similarly placed.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No one gets into college because they're an Eagle Scout.

Yeah. That's not true. Clearly you don't know much about Eagle Scout. Not only did it get one of my kids into a great college, but it was what got him a fantastic job after graduation. The hiring manager was also Eagle. He flat out told my son his Eagle Scout was the tie breaker. I wish my other boys had stayed with it.

B.S. -- name the "great college" being an Eagle Scout got your kid into or it didn't happen.

URM status, grades, SAT all vastly more important.

VMI

Anonymous wrote:No one gets into college because they're an Eagle Scout.

My son got into William and Mary because he was an Eagle Scout.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:HYPS alum here. I don't know how it factors into admissions, but I know I am still always impressed by people who made Eagle Scout or Gold Star. If I found that out about someone who was a recent grad who was applying for a job with me, I would consider that as a "pro" to hiring them.

We're talking about college admissions, not applying for jobs. Maybe a different thread?

Yes, & PP being an HYSP alum was irrelevant to his or her post (which concerned his/her role in hiring not his or her education) but we all know how DCUMers like to throw out information like that at every opportunity

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No one gets into college because they're an Eagle Scout.

Yeah. That's not true. Clearly you don't know much about Eagle Scout. Not only did it get one of my kids into a great college, but it was what got him a fantastic job after graduation. The hiring manager was also Eagle. He flat out told my son his Eagle Scout was the tie breaker. I wish my other boys had stayed with it.

B.S. -- name the "great college" being an Eagle Scout got your kid into or it didn't happen.

URM status, grades, SAT all vastly more important.

That's a total straw man argument -- no one said those things were less important. There are plenty of schools that can fill their classes with very well qualified applicants from the standpoint of grades and test scores many times over. Clearly being an URM is a "hook." The question is, all other things being equal, is being an Eagle Scout an advantage over other similarly situated people. The answer is yes. Obtaining the rank of Eagle Scout takes long-term commitment that is not required for the vast majority of extracurricular activities. It shows the ability to stick with something and follow through.

It may be viewed favorably, but all things are never equal. Selective schools don't really care. Maybe Penn State, but that's not hard to get into anyway.

Anonymous wrote:HYPS alum here. I don't know how it factors into admissions, but I know I am still always impressed by people who made Eagle Scout or Gold Star. If I found that out about someone who was a recent grad who was applying for a job with me, I would consider that as a "pro" to hiring them.

We're talking about college admissions, not applying for jobs. Maybe a different thread?

HYPS alum here. I don't know how it factors into admissions, but I know I am still always impressed by people who made Eagle Scout or Gold Star. If I found that out about someone who was a recent grad who was applying for a job with me, I would consider that as a "pro" to hiring them.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No one gets into college because they're an Eagle Scout.

Yeah. That's not true. Clearly you don't know much about Eagle Scout. Not only did it get one of my kids into a great college, but it was what got him a fantastic job after graduation. The hiring manager was also Eagle. He flat out told my son his Eagle Scout was the tie breaker. I wish my other boys had stayed with it.

B.S. -- name the "great college" being an Eagle Scout got your kid into or it didn't happen.

URM status, grades, SAT all vastly more important.

That's a total straw man argument -- no one said those things were less important. There are plenty of schools that can fill their classes with very well qualified applicants from the standpoint of grades and test scores many times over. Clearly being an URM is a "hook." The question is, all other things being equal, is being an Eagle Scout an advantage over other similarly situated people. The answer is yes. Obtaining the rank of Eagle Scout takes long-term commitment that is not required for the vast majority of extracurricular activities. It shows the ability to stick with something and follow through.