Anonymous
Post 09/17/2018 07:59     Subject: Re:Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:Ok guys, do you tho knits her dad in this commercial?
https://youtu.be/hiI0fL3hN4E


If so, I might start buying the oils myself


No, that’s not her dad. Her dad is older.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2018 21:36     Subject: Re:Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Ok guys, do you tho knits her dad in this commercial?
https://youtu.be/hiI0fL3hN4E


If so, I might start buying the oils myself
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2018 16:42     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I have now found her sister and more recent photos of her dad (2017). He does not have any visible scars from what I can tell. I'm really surprised her family didn't lock down their accounts and photos.


What photos? How do you know you have the right person?


Facebook photos. It was pretty easy. She mentions her mom’s oil business in the book. I looked it up, found her mom. I immediately found her brothers who used their actual names in the book. I found “Shawn” by looking at pictures. I found her sister through the business web page. Her sisters name is Tara’s Dad and mom’s name combined. Her sister posted pictures of her dad. It was super easy to find and connect.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2018 13:02     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:I have now found her sister and more recent photos of her dad (2017). He does not have any visible scars from what I can tell. I'm really surprised her family didn't lock down their accounts and photos.


What photos? How do you know you have the right person?
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2018 12:42     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I picked it up but thought it sounded too similar to The Glass Castle. I loved that book, but didn't feel like I needed another read so much like it. For those who have read both, is this one worth it to read too?


I've read both, and they are different. While both deal with non-traditional, neglectful parenting, in the Glass Castle there is still a feeling of love, and the Walls' suffered through poverty. The Westovers had two sets of involved grandparents. The parents while crazy and neglectful, always had ways to make money, and a roof over their head.

I preferred The Glass Castle, but Educated still ends up being an interesting read. Also, the events in Educated are relatively recent. I'd say more, but it may spoil the book for you.


Also, Walls is a better writer. Her story flows easier and doesn't feel over embellished. In an effort to give her siblings credit for their versions of the story, Westover loses a bit of credibility.


I did not enjoy The Glass Castle at all. i read it three years ago, and I don't have notes as to why, but I do remember just not liking it and not getting the praise for it. I disagree entirely that Walls is a better writer. I really enjoyed Educated, on the other hand.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2018 12:25     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I was shocked by the health issues they left untreated and the casual cruelty of her father at the junk yard. Throwing things like sheet metal and injuring others daily? Also the moms oils are such a hoax!

Did anyone think her brother sexually abused her? The way she wrote about the physical abuse from him made me think it was really sexual abuse and she didn't want to put that in a memoir. She has a lock on her door for instance.


Yeah, I got that vibe.


I did too. I wonder if her journals reflect it.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2018 08:07     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:I was shocked by the health issues they left untreated and the casual cruelty of her father at the junk yard. Throwing things like sheet metal and injuring others daily? Also the moms oils are such a hoax!

Did anyone think her brother sexually abused her? The way she wrote about the physical abuse from him made me think it was really sexual abuse and she didn't want to put that in a memoir. She has a lock on her door for instance.


Yeah, I got that vibe.
Anonymous
Post 09/15/2018 01:38     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:I have now found her sister and more recent photos of her dad (2017). He does not have any visible scars from what I can tell. I'm really surprised her family didn't lock down their accounts and photos.


It's weird that he doesn't have any visible scars. His lips were mentioned multiple times. Now I am really wondering about her account.
Anonymous
Post 09/14/2018 11:03     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
I have now found her sister and more recent photos of her dad (2017). He does not have any visible scars from what I can tell. I'm really surprised her family didn't lock down their accounts and photos.
Anonymous
Post 09/14/2018 01:05     Subject: Re:Educated memoir- Tara Westover
You can see the house and the junkyard on Google Earth and Streetview, and it wasn't what I imagined. I thought of them living up on a hill with a view down over town, but the road seems relatively flat (though there are rolling hills in the background), and isn't as far from town as I'd imagined, either.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2018 12:37     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I picked it up but thought it sounded too similar to The Glass Castle. I loved that book, but didn't feel like I needed another read so much like it. For those who have read both, is this one worth it to read too?


I've read both, and they are different. While both deal with non-traditional, neglectful parenting, in the Glass Castle there is still a feeling of love, and the Walls' suffered through poverty. The Westovers had two sets of involved grandparents. The parents while crazy and neglectful, always had ways to make money, and a roof over their head.

I preferred The Glass Castle, but Educated still ends up being an interesting read. Also, the events in Educated are relatively recent. I'd say more, but it may spoil the book for you.


Also, Walls is a better writer. Her story flows easier and doesn't feel over embellished. In an effort to give her siblings credit for their versions of the story, Westover loses a bit of credibility.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2018 11:14     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:I was shocked by the health issues they left untreated and the casual cruelty of her father at the junk yard. Throwing things like sheet metal and injuring others daily? Also the moms oils are such a hoax!

Did anyone think her brother sexually abused her? The way she wrote about the physical abuse from him made me think it was really sexual abuse and she didn't want to put that in a memoir. She has a lock on her door for instance.


I don't know about sexual abuse. The physical abuse and especially the emotional manipulation rang so true to me. My BF had a manipulative and abusive brother and it is so unsettling. It's hard to know whether the image or the reality is the real one -- Tara Westover certainly showed that confusion in her book.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2018 11:10     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:I picked it up but thought it sounded too similar to The Glass Castle. I loved that book, but didn't feel like I needed another read so much like it. For those who have read both, is this one worth it to read too?


I've read both, and they are different. While both deal with non-traditional, neglectful parenting, in the Glass Castle there is still a feeling of love, and the Walls' suffered through poverty. The Westovers had two sets of involved grandparents. The parents while crazy and neglectful, always had ways to make money, and a roof over their head.

I preferred The Glass Castle, but Educated still ends up being an interesting read. Also, the events in Educated are relatively recent. I'd say more, but it may spoil the book for you.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2018 11:05     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
Anonymous wrote:I was shocked by the health issues they left untreated and the casual cruelty of her father at the junk yard. Throwing things like sheet metal and injuring others daily? Also the moms oils are such a hoax!

Did anyone think her brother sexually abused her? The way she wrote about the physical abuse from him made me think it was really sexual abuse and she didn't want to put that in a memoir. She has a lock on her door for instance.


Yes, I totally felt there was a sexual abuse vibe.

Her mom's oils maybe a hoax, but she really is making millions, and started her business long before the oil craze.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2018 08:00     Subject: Educated memoir- Tara Westover
I was shocked by the health issues they left untreated and the casual cruelty of her father at the junk yard. Throwing things like sheet metal and injuring others daily? Also the moms oils are such a hoax!

Did anyone think her brother sexually abused her? The way she wrote about the physical abuse from him made me think it was really sexual abuse and she didn't want to put that in a memoir. She has a lock on her door for instance.