Anonymous
Post 12/13/2017 07:57     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:You're asking for way too much info, in a specific area, during early admissions. Way too easy to dox a family.


And the problem is????
Who cares if you know where the guy next door S/D applied to? BIg deal!
Most school will advertise to the which universities the kid are going...
GO to Prep, Visi, Sydwell etc and you'll see that info.
Anonymous
Post 12/13/2017 05:10     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:If a kid is both a legacy and a URM, that's a golden ticket.


I heard legacy doesn't count for much anymore if you haven't donated big $$.
My kids are legacy and URM, we are preparing for state school.


Treatment of legacy candidates is very school-specific.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 23:00     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:VA Tech ED is released this evening...


Nephew got in. Langley HS, B+ student weighted to around a 3.8, 1400 SAT

Deferred. 3.94 gpa w/ tough courseload, 1360 SATs. Good, well rounded but not outstanding ECs.


Were these two students applying to engineering?
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 21:27     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:If a kid is both a legacy and a URM, that's a golden ticket.


I heard legacy doesn't count for much anymore if you haven't donated big $$.
My kids are legacy and URM, we are preparing for state school.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 21:08     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
If a kid is both a legacy and a URM, that's a golden ticket.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 18:59     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:VA Tech ED is released this evening...


Nephew got in. Langley HS, B+ student weighted to around a 3.8, 1400 SAT

Deferred. 3.94 gpa w/ tough courseload, 1360 SATs. Good, well rounded but not outstanding ECs.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 17:26     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
for Engineering though?
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 16:54     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:VA Tech ED is released this evening...


Nephew got in. Langley HS, B+ student weighted to around a 3.8, 1400 SAT
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 16:13     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:College Applied to: Pomona College
Result: Deferred
SAT/ACT: 1540 SAT (770 Math, 770 Reading), 750 Literature Subject Test, 790 Chemistry Subject Test, 800 Math II Subject Test
Class rank: Salutatorian
Legacy: None
URM: No
Aid: Full Pay
Why: Her top choice
Next steps: Apply EDII at either UChicago or Swarthmore, apply RD to Amherst, Carleton, Colby, Bowdoin, Barnard, Wellesley, Columbia, Yale, Tufts. Already admitted to a match and safety school.


no athletics? No ECs?
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 15:52     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:College Applied to: Pomona College
Result: Deferred
SAT/ACT: 1540 SAT (770 Math, 770 Reading), 750 Literature Subject Test, 790 Chemistry Subject Test, 800 Math II Subject Test
Class rank: Salutatorian
Legacy: None
URM: No
Aid: Full Pay
Why: Her top choice
Next steps: Apply EDII at either UChicago or Swarthmore, apply RD to Amherst, Carleton, Colby, Bowdoin, Barnard, Wellesley, Columbia, Yale, Tufts. Already admitted to a match and safety school.

DC has similar stats and was deferred at Swarthmore. Can I ask which school you've identified as a match? That's been a difficult process for DC given DC's stats are average at the most selective schools.


Yes- my daughter's match is University of Pittsburgh Honors College. Her safety is a National Merit full tuition school. She also applied EA to Colorado College so she'll hear back from them soon.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 15:19     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
VA Tech ED is released this evening...
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 13:49     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:College Applied to: Pomona College
Result: Deferred
SAT/ACT: 1540 SAT (770 Math, 770 Reading), 750 Literature Subject Test, 790 Chemistry Subject Test, 800 Math II Subject Test
Class rank: Salutatorian
Legacy: None
URM: No
Aid: Full Pay
Why: Her top choice
Next steps: Apply EDII at either UChicago or Swarthmore, apply RD to Amherst, Carleton, Colby, Bowdoin, Barnard, Wellesley, Columbia, Yale, Tufts. Already admitted to a match and safety school.

DC has similar stats and was deferred at Swarthmore. Can I ask which school you've identified as a match? That's been a difficult process for DC given DC's stats are average at the most selective schools.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 12:29     Subject: Re:College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
I think it is o.k. if the student or parent wants to give the info about themselves, but not for someone else to give it about a person they know.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 12:22     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
You're asking for way too much info, in a specific area, during early admissions. Way too easy to dox a family.
Anonymous
Post 12/12/2017 12:21     Subject: College ED -- Just the Facts (Results Thread)
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:This is OP back. I had no idea that this would be so controversial. Welcome to the College Board, I guess. I thought this info would be helpful to other newbies who are 1+ year out.

I did not mean to out anyone nor even the name of the high school, simply "Public" or "Private" and, if possible, MCPS, FCPS, APS, DCPS, Etc.

Happy to redevelop the survey and ask Jeff to delete and replace this thread.

College:
Result:
SAT/ACT Percentile or Score:
Legacy (Y/N):
URM (Y/N):
Aid or Full Pay:
Who guided you to this ED selection (I'm looking to see where the advice came from -- a HS guidance counselor, parent influence, senior's top choice, outside college counselor who had some strategy, etc):

Critique away and let's get it right and start a new thread.



It shouldn't be controversial--there are thousands of kids in this area applying to many of the same schools. People here are paranoid and are clearly not familiar with CC. On your survey, I'd note that you haven't included recruited athletes in the hooks section, and you'd need GPA for context.


Nonsense. There are not "thousands" of kids from around here who applied to a certain SLAC that announced last week. And if I were to mention the URM status - the parents of the kid might well know who posted.the info, which is why I'm not going to do it.


No one is going to make you post, and you certainly shouldn't do so if you don't want to for any reason. That doesn't mean that others feel the same way, so there is no need to clamor for the thread to be deleted. Even if only white and Asian people with no hooks post, it's useful to others in the same boat.

With respect to the total numbers, there may not be thousands applying ED to a top SLAC, but there will be hundreds. Naviance indicates that 8-12 kids apply to Pomona each year from my kid's high school alone.