I married a cross of Steve and Aidan. But if I had only one night with one of the SATC guys, Jack Berger all the way.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Steve is disgusting.

A gross bartender.
Smith was a waiter / model wanna b.

Aiden is the real catch. Down to earth, nice AND successful.

Big is all success but no substance. Ew.

By the end of the series, Smith was a well-known model. By the time of the movies, he was a television star.

Aidan (the proper spelling) was okay, and Carrie was an idiot, but Smith was still the better catch.

http://www.cosmopolitan.com/sex-love/news/a37631/the-case-against-aidan-shaw/

I'd love to marry a Trey McDougal. Alas he doesn't want children!

Anonymous wrote:Steve is disgusting.

A gross bartender.
Smith was a waiter / model wanna b.

Aiden is the real catch. Down to earth, nice AND successful.

Big is all success but no substance. Ew.

Anonymous wrote:When I first binged on SaTC, I was intangled with a Big of my own. In every way - the big and tall, handsome, mysterious, wealthy (compared to my grad school income that barely covered rent), and somewhat brooding. He was my first bf, so I totally get the infatuation. But then I grew up

My DH is more of Steve I guess (minus the dorkiness)? Love him to pieces and wouldn't trade him for anything.

You ladies have to remember that Samantha MADE Smith into the successful model that he was. If you met a hot, kinda dim, model with no money would you really consider him a catch? He had a good heart, but most DCUM types would not settle for an empty wallet.

Absolute FALSE. I would absolutely be willing to shell out money for him. In fact, BTDT, and it worked out. I didn't pay for him often but he was 18 (I was 24) and I paid for small stuff for him when he couldn't afford it. He was hot and great in bed and it was fab (I still think about him). I'll take that any day over some wrinkly oldie with a fat wallet.

Steve is disgusting.

When I first binged on SaTC, I was intangled with a Big of my own. In every way - the big and tall, handsome, mysterious, wealthy (compared to my grad school income that barely covered rent), and somewhat brooding. He was my first bf, so I totally get the infatuation. But then I grew up

My DH is more of Steve I guess (minus the dorkiness)? Love him to pieces and wouldn't trade him for anything.

You ladies have to remember that Samantha MADE Smith into the successful model that he was. If you met a hot, kinda dim, model with no money would you really consider him a catch? He had a good heart, but most DCUM types would not settle for an empty wallet.

My list:


1) Smith

2) Dr. Robert

3) Trey

4) Aiden

5) Big

Anonymous wrote:1) Steve
2) Aiden
3) Harry
4) Smith

The rest I didn't like (although I'm sure I'm forgetting some one night stands)

Just remembered Dr. Robert. I think he actually is first for me.

I like to think I am mature and smart so Harry would be the true catch. But in reality, Big is my jam. My DH has some Big qualities.

1) Steve
2) Aiden
3) Harry
4) Smith

The rest I didn't like (although I'm sure I'm forgetting some one night stands)

Also, let's not forget that hot doctor that (inexplicably) was so infatuated with Miranda, of all people.

Behind the obvious winner of Smith Jerrod, he definitely takes the number 2 spot of best pick.

Anonymous wrote:I loved Steve!!!!

Ew.

Anonymous wrote:Absofuckinglutely.

And to add, I don't think Carrie solely loved him for the drama. Don't forget, they got along very well and had fun and were happy when they were together. And they both liked to live BIG and had similiar tastes and enjoyments. Their love for NYC. They had a lot more in common than any of her other boyfriends.

Carrie did date mentally stable men but was never impressed by them because they were usually not as wealthy as big. The two guys she took the biggest chance with were Big and the Russian artist. She loooooves a rich man and will forgive a lot of personality flaws in order to date one.

I loved Steve!!!!