Anonymous wrote:This is a super interesting thread. In some ways, I can see how the validation of feelings is important in the moment because they are emotional and all they want to do is vent and feel and be heard rather than corrected. So the poster who mentioned timing is important. But I also think we don't actually have to say that much. Just listen. And maybe ask open-ended questions that lead them to come to revelation on their own. After listening and validating, maybe say: 'why do you think it made you so upset and embarrassed', in the case of the homework, for example. They might recognize that they were embarrassed because they made they forgot their homework. And then ask, "what do you think you can do differently so you don't forget your homework again?" The bigger message I struggle to impart with my own daughter is correcting the 'its not my fault' mentality. I know its a defense mechanism but part of maturing is accepting responsibility for mistakes and thinking about what you could do differently. So it definitely resonates with me that validation alone is problematic because it also validates that mentality and lack of ownership over mistakes.
Anonymous wrote:Larlat's grandmother here.
I am glad you found this helpful. Enough years have passed that I can reveal that Larlat's actual name was Satan. Another pet was called Beelzebub. Just to give you an idea of the darkish place my DD was in.
She was a DCUM nightmare; she didn't even graduate from high school, a fact I see I didn't include earlier. Twice I had to get a lawyer for brushes with the law, thankfully expunged. Also something I didn't include.
Validation helped enormously to get her through the darkness, as well as what turned out to be two pretty serious illnesses. Once those were stable enough she got her GED and enrolled in college.
She is doing pre-med and has a very high GPA; she will be doing her MCATs soon. Her hope is to be a forensic pathologist, which I see as a positive way of channeling the remnants of darkness.
Anonymous wrote:Word of caution op- my sister has done this for years with her now 20 year old. My niece was completely unprepared to hear any sort of constructive criticism from her college professors and employers. She always says they are unfair because she is used to the BT style you use.
Anonymous wrote:Bless you for coming up with Larlat. May that be the DCUM generic name for pet rats forever more.
Anonymous wrote:Bless you for coming up with Larlat. May that be the DCUM generic name for pet rats forever more.
Anonymous wrote:Larlat's grandmother here.
I am glad you found this helpful. Enough years have passed that I can reveal that Larlat's actual name was Satan. Another pet was called Beelzebub. Just to give you an idea of the darkish place my DD was in.
She was a DCUM nightmare; she didn't even graduate from high school, a fact I see I didn't include earlier. Twice I had to get a lawyer for brushes with the law, thankfully expunged. Also something I didn't include.
Validation helped enormously to get her through the darkness, as well as what turned out to be two pretty serious illnesses. Once those were stable enough she got her GED and enrolled in college.
She is doing pre-med and has a very high GPA; she will be doing her MCATs soon. Her hope is to be a forensic pathologist, which I see as a positive way of channeling the remnants of darkness.