NYC would be great - but my sister lives there, and I'm already planning to visit her (with or withou DH) before baby arrives so I can go eat my face off at Smorgasburg
We've decided on Bedford Springs (thanks for the rec, PP!). It's less expensive than Perry Cabin, so we can go for a day longer and I'll feel less uncomfortable about the cost (I'm a very frugal person, so spending that much on a couple of days freaks me out!).
We're planning on July or early August. The spa looks great, so I'm excited to splurge on that. There's also more activities such as cooking classes, guided hikes, and large grounds to explore. Or just sleep. Whichever!