You can get Graeter's at Fresh Markets.
But - I live a short drive from Graeter's and don't bother, because Mitchell's (Cleveland) beats the pants off Graeter's. I love/miss these guys and their goodies so much. They don't franchise yet, and might not because they're very Cleveland-centric, but if they ever do, you should be on that. They make the most fresh, delicious versions of classic flavors. Ever. Whole plump, slightly salty almonds in the Rocky Road. omg.
http://mitchellshomemade.com/
For fancy modern flavors made with pastured cream -
http://www.jenis.com/
A little rich for my blood... $10-12 a pint. But people get irrational over the salty caramel.