Anonymous
Post 05/13/2012 18:35     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
It does sound fair. And I have heard there is an oversight committee that looks at the files another time. With the initial process plus the appeals process, I will never understand how so many think that their child wasn't given fair consideration.
Anonymous
Post 05/13/2012 17:17     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
sounds fair
Anonymous
Post 05/13/2012 14:48     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
There is no big secret about the committee. It is made up of principals, vice principals, AARTs, etc. They sit in a big room with tables of 6. The file is passed around the table and reviewed by each person. After someone reviews the file, they decide whether the child is eligible or ineligible and indicate that decision on an individual piece of paper that is put in the back of the file. After the last person at the table makes their decision, all of the decisions are reviewed. If there are more eligible, the student is eligible. If there are more ineligible, the student is ineligible. If there is a tie, the file is passed on to another table of 6 (and even another if necessary) until the tie is broken. The committee members do not know the decisions that the other people at their table made, so that they can make their own determination without influence.
Anonymous
Post 05/13/2012 14:06     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:no you can't speak to them. the committee is made up of principals, and asst. principals from around the county. they are used to seeing hundreds of kids, report cards, test scores all year long. last year our principal was on the committee - she had 30+ years in education.


FCPS needs a major dose of transparency. Secret committees are never good...


I would hardly call it a secret. Have you read these boards?


Yeah, nobody knows the official rules. Guessing what the standards and metrics are....

Anonymous
Post 05/13/2012 00:11     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:no you can't speak to them. the committee is made up of principals, and asst. principals from around the county. they are used to seeing hundreds of kids, report cards, test scores all year long. last year our principal was on the committee - she had 30+ years in education.


FCPS needs a major dose of transparency. Secret committees are never good...


I would hardly call it a secret. Have you read these boards?
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2012 23:42     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Anonymous wrote:no you can't speak to them. the committee is made up of principals, and asst. principals from around the county. they are used to seeing hundreds of kids, report cards, test scores all year long. last year our principal was on the committee - she had 30+ years in education.


FCPS needs a major dose of transparency. Secret committees are never good...
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2012 23:41     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Anonymous wrote:no you can't speak to them. the committee is made up of principals, and asst. principals from around the county. they are used to seeing hundreds of kids, report cards, test scores all year long. last year our principal was on the committee - she had 30+ years in education.
Anonymous
Post 05/12/2012 23:07     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
I wonder why they don't have GT experts on the committee.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2012 16:39     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
And does this same committee meet for appeals or a different one? Just curious about the inner workings. I certainly feel they are well qualified, but wondered how it was all put together.
Thanks for previous answer.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2012 15:02     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
no you can't speak to them. the committee is made up of principals, and asst. principals from around the county. they are used to seeing hundreds of kids, report cards, test scores all year long. last year our principal was on the committee - she had 30+ years in education.
Anonymous
Post 05/10/2012 14:36     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Who or whom is on this central selection committee? Is it the same one? Do they do this year round? Can we speak to them?
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2012 09:54     Subject: Re:Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Cogat 132
GPRS 15
Still found in eligible due to wrong scores sent by school , should I still appeal with all new information or just send the scores?

-Frustrated mom


How do you know that the committee received the wrong scores?


How do you know wrong scores were sent? That sounds very weird. Did the teacher send wrong scores?
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2012 08:33     Subject: Re:Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Anonymous wrote:Cogat 132
GPRS 15
Still found in eligible due to wrong scores sent by school , should I still appeal with all new information or just send the scores?

-Frustrated mom


How do you know that the committee received the wrong scores?
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2012 07:45     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
*find*
Anonymous
Post 05/04/2012 07:45     Subject: Not eligible aap? Do you plan to appeal?
Frustrated mom - what scores were sent? How did you fund out?