Anonymous wrote:The difference between diagnosing a young child with a lifelong condition, and providing early assistance to a child who may be at risk of developing a condition isn’t semantics. CALT’s can’t diagnose. It is unethical for them to imply that what they can do is substantially the same.
You are absolutely right, CALTs do not diagnose and I hope I didn’t imply that we can or do. Families come to us after they have been identified or diagnosed either through school or a psychologist. We provide therapy-level instruction in reading, writing, and spelling.
And I agree that the difference between identification and diagnosis is more than semantics and I’m sorry I used that term.
What I was trying to get at, and I think the psychologist and I clarified, is that early identification should be followed by intervention. My own child was known to have poor phonological skills at 5 but not diagnosed until 7. He didn’t receive services until 7 because of that. This was years ago, I didn’t yet know what the assessment results meant, and school didn’t flag it. I’m hopeful things have changed.