Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok everyone knows who this is so why not name it. An FVU 2011 was asked to play up with the FVU 2010s because a key goal scorer on the FVU 2010s tore her ACL in a high school game. The 2011 practiced with FVU 2010s for a full week. Scored three goals in a scrimmage with the FVU 2009s in fact. And then parents complained about her. Went to the FVU board. And the FVU board caved to the 2010 parents and told her that she couldn’t go to playoffs. Well done FVU 2010 parents. Hope you enjoyed your two loses in ECNL 2010 without a goal scorer. Great job. Good luck on playoffs.

Again, this seems like a non-issue within a club, and nothing to do with this thread. Of course the 2010 coach wanted her for playoffs, but club decided since she was leaving for another club, they did not want to reward her with that opportunity. Yu can debate pro/con of that decision, but completely within clubs purview and nothing to do with breaking any rules.

Im with the club on this one. You stay you play. You go? Uh.... no.

Anonymous wrote:The spirit of the rules for ECNL don't typically allow players rostered to one ECNL club to play for another and contribute during the post season. I know of many instances where players are coming from a completely different league and being added and travelling for playoffs but that's not the same as switching/transferring from another ECNL club and then contributing during the post season, but the language leaves it up to interpretation specifically with the commissioner deciding what's okay and not okay.

It happens every year all over the country. Teams load up for the playoffs.

Anonymous wrote:Ok everyone knows who this is so why not name it. An FVU 2011 was asked to play up with the FVU 2010s because a key goal scorer on the FVU 2010s tore her ACL in a high school game. The 2011 practiced with FVU 2010s for a full week. Scored three goals in a scrimmage with the FVU 2009s in fact. And then parents complained about her. Went to the FVU board. And the FVU board caved to the 2010 parents and told her that she couldn’t go to playoffs. Well done FVU 2010 parents. Hope you enjoyed your two loses in ECNL 2010 without a goal scorer. Great job. Good luck on playoffs.

Again, this seems like a non-issue within a club, and nothing to do with this thread. Of course the 2010 coach wanted her for playoffs, but club decided since she was leaving for another club, they did not want to reward her with that opportunity. Yu can debate pro/con of that decision, but completely within clubs purview and nothing to do with breaking any rules.

Ok everyone knows who this is so why not name it. An FVU 2011 was asked to play up with the FVU 2010s because a key goal scorer on the FVU 2010s tore her ACL in a high school game. The 2011 practiced with FVU 2010s for a full week. Scored three goals in a scrimmage with the FVU 2009s in fact. And then parents complained about her. Went to the FVU board. And the FVU board caved to the 2010 parents and told her that she couldn’t go to playoffs. Well done FVU 2010 parents. Hope you enjoyed your two loses in ECNL 2010 without a goal scorer. Great job. Good luck on playoffs.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:That just sounds wrong on many levels. Is this player by chance leaving their current team to go to VDA?

What age group is Vda doing this?

Rhymes with 7-11

That team didn't make playoffs.

Exactly which is why they are trying to play up with their current club's 2010s to be able to play in playoffs, and then leave for VDA in August. This is highly unusual and been out in the open for sometime so we'll see what happens I guess. Someone is about to look like a donkey.

This doesn’t make any GD sense. You’re saying that VDA 2011s is making another team take a 2011 to playoffs with that team for playoffs. “Leave for VDA in August” How exactly would VDA manage that?! You’re an idiot.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:MD United 2011 trying to add multiple new players to their sudden playoff squad.

How so?

Ask HC, as he's masterminding his ECNL playoff domination

Anonymous wrote:MD United 2011 trying to add multiple new players to their sudden playoff squad.

How so?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:That just sounds wrong on many levels. Is this player by chance leaving their current team to go to VDA?

What age group is Vda doing this?

Rhymes with 7-11

That team didn't make playoffs.

Exactly which is why they are trying to play up with their current club's 2010s to be able to play in playoffs, and then leave for VDA in August. This is highly unusual and been out in the open for sometime so we'll see what happens I guess. Someone is about to look like a donkey.

Isn't this really at discretion of current club? They are on current club roster through July. So if club wants to play them up an age group even though they are leaving for a new club next season that is current club's choice.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:That just sounds wrong on many levels. Is this player by chance leaving their current team to go to VDA?

What age group is Vda doing this?

Rhymes with 7-11

That team didn't make playoffs.

Exactly which is why they are trying to play up with their current club's 2010s to be able to play in playoffs, and then leave for VDA in August. This is highly unusual and been out in the open for sometime so we'll see what happens I guess. Someone is about to look like a donkey.

2.11.1 The ECNL is intended to be a development platform for players and teams, requiring a connection between the regular team training environment and the competition environment. As such, Rule 2.11.1 applies to all ECNL Registered Players except for the enumerated exceptions provided in Rule 2.11.3 and Rule 2.11.4, and as provided below in Rule 2.12 regarding Discovery Players. Once registered, an ECNL Registered Player may only participate in 11v11 outdoor competitions with his/her ECNL Member Club for the duration of the ECNL Season (unless released pursuant to the ECNL transfer/release rules herein or otherwise as provided below in this section 2.11). (For purposes of clarification, the ECNL Registered Player may appear in any 11v11 outdoor competition in which the ECNL Club participates during the ECNL Season. This requirement only applies to US Soccer member-sanctioned competitions and does not apply to informal, unsanctioned 11v11 outdoor competitions.) <B>Except as provided below, if an ECNL Registered Player plays in a US Soccer member sanctioned 11v11 outdoor competition for a different club besides the ECNL Club to which he/she is registered as an ECNL Registered Player after the date he/she became rostered as an ECNL Registered Player (“Multiple Club Rostering”), the eligibility of the ECNL Registered Player will be reviewed by the ECNL Commissioner. <B> If it is determined by the ECNL Commissioner that the ECNL Club to which the ECNL Registered Player is registered was aware of the Multiple Club Rostering, the ECNL Commissioner may take any or all of the following actions, without limitation: (i) declare the ECNL Registered Player ineligible for the remainder of that ECNL Season; (ii) declare all games in which the ECNL Registered Player appeared on the ECNL Roster as forfeits by the ECNL Team on which such player was rostered; and / or (iii) recommend revocation of the ECNL Member Club’s membership in the ECNL.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:That just sounds wrong on many levels. Is this player by chance leaving their current team to go to VDA?

What age group is Vda doing this?

Rhymes with 7-11

That team didn't make playoffs.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The spirit of the rules for ECNL don't typically allow players rostered to one ECNL club to play for another and contribute during the post season. I know of many instances where players are coming from a completely different league and being added and travelling for playoffs but that's not the same as switching/transferring from another ECNL club and then contributing during the post season, but the language leaves it up to interpretation specifically with the commissioner deciding what's okay and not okay.

The rules definitely allow for it, but like 3 or 4 checkpoints must be met in order for it to happen.

They definitely do and that's my point, the spirit of the rules make it seem like they discourage this practice but the language is up for interpretation and certain clubs just have a different pull within the league.

Anonymous wrote:The spirit of the rules for ECNL don't typically allow players rostered to one ECNL club to play for another and contribute during the post season. I know of many instances where players are coming from a completely different league and being added and travelling for playoffs but that's not the same as switching/transferring from another ECNL club and then contributing during the post season, but the language leaves it up to interpretation specifically with the commissioner deciding what's okay and not okay.

The rules definitely allow for it, but like 3 or 4 checkpoints must be met in order for it to happen.

The spirit of the rules for ECNL don't typically allow players rostered to one ECNL club to play for another and contribute during the post season. I know of many instances where players are coming from a completely different league and being added and travelling for playoffs but that's not the same as switching/transferring from another ECNL club and then contributing during the post season, but the language leaves it up to interpretation specifically with the commissioner deciding what's okay and not okay.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:That just sounds wrong on many levels. Is this player by chance leaving their current team to go to VDA?

What age group is Vda doing this?

Rhymes with 7-11