Anonymous wrote:While it seems like there are more and more non-believers, it also seems, to me, at least, that people are hesitant to acknowledge it IRL, while religious people frequently telegraph their religious status, e.g., by wearing a Cross necklace or casually mentioning their participation in religious services.
What do you think that’s about?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I mean I also don't walk around with shirts saying "I don't watch football". Generally you don't advertise a negative.
Sounds like you see not believing in God as a negative. I don't.
No, a negative as in "proving a negative." An absence.
People don't wear T shirts announcing the things they don't believe, or don't care about, or don't feel are worth mentioning.
In which planet do you live?! Here on Earth, I see antiracism shirts, anti bigotry shirts, etc, etc. People announce what they don't believe all the time.
Those are things they believe. I believe in anti racism, that's not the same as disbelieving racism or not being invested one way or the other in racism. An equivalent would I guess be anti-theism, which I suppose some atheists are. But most non-believers just don't care. They are not anti-religion, they are a-religious.
Anonymous wrote:While it seems like there are more and more non-believers, it also seems, to me, at least, that people are hesitant to acknowledge it IRL, while religious people frequently telegraph their religious status, e.g., by wearing a Cross necklace or casually mentioning their participation in religious services.
What do you think that’s about?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I mean I also don't walk around with shirts saying "I don't watch football". Generally you don't advertise a negative.
Sounds like you see not believing in God as a negative. I don't.
No, a negative as in "proving a negative." An absence.
People don't wear T shirts announcing the things they don't believe, or don't care about, or don't feel are worth mentioning.
In which planet do you live?! Here on Earth, I see antiracism shirts, anti bigotry shirts, etc, etc. People announce what they don't believe all the time.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I understand, but really think it's too bad, particularly because it's an opportunity to normalize atheism.
Coming from Europe, the US does seem weirdly religious, but still, I haven't been in a situation where I'd been uncomfortable to reveal my atheism. I'd say atheism is already accepted.
Saying you don't believe in God in some parts of 'Merica is like telling the Taliban you don't believe in Allah. And they will treat you just as harshly.
Anonymous wrote:I understand, but really think it's too bad, particularly because it's an opportunity to normalize atheism.
Coming from Europe, the US does seem weirdly religious, but still, I haven't been in a situation where I'd been uncomfortable to reveal my atheism. I'd say atheism is already accepted.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If it comes up I will say I'm an atheist- I don't advertise it. Not for any reason, it would just be weird to say "BTW, I don't believe in god" out of nowhere.
Would you wear some kind of an atheist emblem (like Christians wear a cross) if they existed?
DP, but I would not. My identity isn't tied up in not believing.
Similarly, I think a lot of believers' identities are not tied up in believing, but the society encourages the wearing of religious symbols and mentioning church the way people would mention any other place.
Also, society discourages mentioning lack of belief. Maybe that should change
I just disagree that people wearing crosses or religious garb, or talking about religion, do not have religion as a strong part of their identity.
And I disagree that the default position is religious. I think if you're silent about religion and not wearing symbols, people assume you're not religious. They may be wrong in their assumption, but that's the assumption precisely because so many religious people broadcast it.
I'm an atheist that broadcasts Christianity because it's my culture. Go figure. It's like an American abroad joining an Independence Day celebration in London. It happens. I've done that too.
But I bet you believe in Independence, right?
How do you "broadcast" Christianity? Do you wear a cross?
Yep, I wear a cross. People can wear whatever they want. And, yes, I believe in independence from the monarchy. As I said, it's my culture.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If it comes up I will say I'm an atheist- I don't advertise it. Not for any reason, it would just be weird to say "BTW, I don't believe in god" out of nowhere.
Would you wear some kind of an atheist emblem (like Christians wear a cross) if they existed?
DP, but I would not. My identity isn't tied up in not believing.
Similarly, I think a lot of believers' identities are not tied up in believing, but the society encourages the wearing of religious symbols and mentioning church the way people would mention any other place.
Also, society discourages mentioning lack of belief. Maybe that should change
I just disagree that people wearing crosses or religious garb, or talking about religion, do not have religion as a strong part of their identity.
And I disagree that the default position is religious. I think if you're silent about religion and not wearing symbols, people assume you're not religious. They may be wrong in their assumption, but that's the assumption precisely because so many religious people broadcast it.
I'm an atheist that broadcasts Christianity because it's my culture. Go figure. It's like an American abroad joining an Independence Day celebration in London. It happens. I've done that too.
But I bet you believe in Independence, right?
How do you "broadcast" Christianity? Do you wear a cross?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If it comes up I will say I'm an atheist- I don't advertise it. Not for any reason, it would just be weird to say "BTW, I don't believe in god" out of nowhere.
Would you wear some kind of an atheist emblem (like Christians wear a cross) if they existed?
DP, but I would not. My identity isn't tied up in not believing.
Similarly, I think a lot of believers' identities are not tied up in believing, but the society encourages the wearing of religious symbols and mentioning church the way people would mention any other place.
Also, society discourages mentioning lack of belief. Maybe that should change
I just disagree that people wearing crosses or religious garb, or talking about religion, do not have religion as a strong part of their identity.
And I disagree that the default position is religious. I think if you're silent about religion and not wearing symbols, people assume you're not religious. They may be wrong in their assumption, but that's the assumption precisely because so many religious people broadcast it.
I'm an atheist that broadcasts Christianity because it's my culture. Go figure. It's like an American abroad joining an Independence Day celebration in London. It happens. I've done that too.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If it comes up I will say I'm an atheist- I don't advertise it. Not for any reason, it would just be weird to say "BTW, I don't believe in god" out of nowhere.
Would you wear some kind of an atheist emblem (like Christians wear a cross) if they existed?
DP, but I would not. My identity isn't tied up in not believing.
Similarly, I think a lot of believers' identities are not tied up in believing, but the society encourages the wearing of religious symbols and mentioning church the way people would mention any other place.
Also, society discourages mentioning lack of belief. Maybe that should change
I just disagree that people wearing crosses or religious garb, or talking about religion, do not have religion as a strong part of their identity.
And I disagree that the default position is religious. I think if you're silent about religion and not wearing symbols, people assume you're not religious. They may be wrong in their assumption, but that's the assumption precisely because so many religious people broadcast it.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I mean I also don't walk around with shirts saying "I don't watch football". Generally you don't advertise a negative.
Sounds like you see not believing in God as a negative. I don't.
No, a negative as in "proving a negative." An absence.
People don't wear T shirts announcing the things they don't believe, or don't care about, or don't feel are worth mentioning.
In which planet do you live?! Here on Earth, I see antiracism shirts, anti bigotry shirts, etc, etc. People announce what they don't believe all the time.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If it comes up I will say I'm an atheist- I don't advertise it. Not for any reason, it would just be weird to say "BTW, I don't believe in god" out of nowhere.
Would you wear some kind of an atheist emblem (like Christians wear a cross) if they existed?
DP, but I would not. My identity isn't tied up in not believing.
Similarly, I think a lot of believers' identities are not tied up in believing, but the society encourages the wearing of religious symbols and mentioning church the way people would mention any other place.
Also, society discourages mentioning lack of belief. Maybe that should change
I just disagree that people wearing crosses or religious garb, or talking about religion, do not have religion as a strong part of their identity.
And I disagree that the default position is religious. I think if you're silent about religion and not wearing symbols, people assume you're not religious. They may be wrong in their assumption, but that's the assumption precisely because so many religious people broadcast it.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I mean I also don't walk around with shirts saying "I don't watch football". Generally you don't advertise a negative.
Sounds like you see not believing in God as a negative. I don't.
No, a negative as in "proving a negative." An absence.
People don't wear T shirts announcing the things they don't believe, or don't care about, or don't feel are worth mentioning.