Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 17:04     Subject: Re:Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:Did she actually verbally disparage your kid?

No? Then your tender child can handle not knowung that not everyone agrees with them.


Would you say the same re: a kid who wrote an essay on transgenderism? Could the teacher confront them with opposing views?

It should be the same answer.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 17:02     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Of course it’s unprofessional and unethical. How is that even a question?


How is it either of those things?

They are a TEACHER. They are SUPPOSED to teach children these things.



Reading, writing, math, social studies, yes. Their political views, no.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 16:49     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
I don't think it's unprofessional at all if the teacher is making an argument or talking about a fact. Sure, they shouldn't say "he's an idiot" even though that is a fact, but I have no problem with this. I'd also have no problem if they made intelligent criticisms of any dem president too. Stop being so sensitive.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 16:44     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:Is it unprofessional for a teacher to let students know her political views? Particularly, is it unethical for a teacher to criticize Trump when a student in the class is open about admiring Trump?


That teacher needs to be fired and escorted off school grounds.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:28     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:OP here. The teacher only gave rebuttals to the student whose speech was about admiring Donald Trump and the student whose speech was about admiring Andrew Tate. The boys are friends. There is a perception that the teacher does not like these boys and targets them because their political opinions are different from hers and the boys feel uncomfortable in her class now.


You are missing the forest.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:27     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP here.

It is 9th grade English class, not social studies. The kids were doing some kind of exercise where they had to explain why they admired somebody. The student in question chose Trump. The teacher started questioning him after he delivered his speech, asking how he could admire a person who XYZ and 123.


If XYZ and 123 were facts that is fine.

It's like writing a persuasive speech to get rid of public schools and the teacher states well what about XYZ?

If you can't see that you are tribal.


Only if she gives similar rebuttals to other students, and isn't selectively targeting certain people.

Einstein abused his wife.


So did Trump
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:22     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:OP here. The teacher only gave rebuttals to the student whose speech was about admiring Donald Trump and the student whose speech was about admiring Andrew Tate. The boys are friends. There is a perception that the teacher does not like these boys and targets them because their political opinions are different from hers and the boys feel uncomfortable in her class now.


Poor little snowflakes.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:22     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:If this story is true, despite having all the signs of a detailed drip-dripping troll, this isn't the first time these two kids have pulled a stunt like this in class. Teacher should stop enabling them.


Yeah my friend's daughter had some boys yell "Your body my choice" at her at school. These Tate boys need to learn that their views will keep them single and lonely.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:19     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP here.

It is 9th grade English class, not social studies. The kids were doing some kind of exercise where they had to explain why they admired somebody. The student in question chose Trump. The teacher started questioning him after he delivered his speech, asking how he could admire a person who XYZ and 123.


What were XYZ and 123?

Facts matter.


Sounds like a pointed question, not an opinion.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:15     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
If this story is true, despite having all the signs of a detailed drip-dripping troll, this isn't the first time these two kids have pulled a stunt like this in class. Teacher should stop enabling them.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:13     Subject: Re:Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:I think it would be unethical to tell a lie or an opinion like "I think Trump is a Muslim who was born in Ukraine" even if that is your opinion.

I think is it ethical to state facts like Trump is a rapist, or Trump is a felon, or Trump sexually assaults women, or Trump created a fake university and has to pay millions in fines, or Trump has declared bankruptcy many times, or Trump incited a riot on 1/6 that cause injury and death to many people.


No, because that's giving the troll what he wants. What teacher should do is read the papers and not share toxic ones with the class, and refer the trolls to the principal to decide what to do with them.

And the teacher should stop making an assignment to glorify celebrities. People should not be worshipped. People are complicated and do good things and bad things.

Focus on the class, not the disruptors.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:11     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:OP here. The teacher only gave rebuttals to the student whose speech was about admiring Donald Trump and the student whose speech was about admiring Andrew Tate. The boys are friends. There is a perception that the teacher does not like these boys and targets them because their political opinions are different from hers and the boys feel uncomfortable in her class now.


It is an excellent opportunity for your DC to support their case persuasively and politely. It's no different than a debate. If he can't do that then he wasn't prepared. It's high school, they should be challenged.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:08     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Andrew Tate is a sex trafficker who said that a man who has with with his own wife is gay.
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:08     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:OP here. The teacher only gave rebuttals to the student whose speech was about admiring Donald Trump and the student whose speech was about admiring Andrew Tate. The boys are friends. There is a perception that the teacher does not like these boys and targets them because their political opinions are different from hers and the boys feel uncomfortable in her class now.


If she is giving rebuttals that are fact-based I think it's fine. It sounds like the boys are like "I admire Hitler and my friend admires Stalin!" and then saying "I don't understand why I'm being questioned about who I like."
Anonymous
Post 01/10/2025 14:06     Subject: Teacher criticizes Trump
Anonymous wrote:OP here. The teacher only gave rebuttals to the student whose speech was about admiring Donald Trump and the student whose speech was about admiring Andrew Tate. The boys are friends. There is a perception that the teacher does not like these boys and targets them because their political opinions are different from hers and the boys feel uncomfortable in her class now.


Yeah, those boys do sound like dolts and should be uncomfortable, that's the point. Maybe they will adjust and realize that misogynistic fools like Tate are not to be admired. Yikes!