Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I've never heard of a junior playing on a JV team in any sport in a public school, I'm in Maryland. I don't know if that kind of thing is governed at the state level, county level, or up to each individual school.

It’s common at our private. But waste of time and boring. You blowout teams all season, no competition and miss so much time traveling to these games, get to school at 8, get home after 10pm. For what? I always thought Jrs on JV was embarrassing.

Maybe its different at private schools where its so easy to make the teams.
At large publics with competitive sports, many juniors play varsity and there's nothing embarrassing about it. Literally, its called "JUNIOR varsity".

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I've never heard of a junior playing on a JV team in any sport in a public school, I'm in Maryland. I don't know if that kind of thing is governed at the state level, county level, or up to each individual school.

It’s common at our private. But waste of time and boring. You blowout teams all season, no competition and miss so much time traveling to these games, get to school at 8, get home after 10pm. For what? I always thought Jrs on JV was embarrassing.

Anonymous wrote:I've never heard of a junior playing on a JV team in any sport in a public school, I'm in Maryland. I don't know if that kind of thing is governed at the state level, county level, or up to each individual school.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why play on the high school team? It doesn't help with recruiting and only increases the risk of injuries. Focus on academics and aim to get on the highest team with his club.

Recruiting? A kid that doesn't make their JV team sophomore year isn't getting recruited to play in college. Not everyone has that goal. Some just like to play soccer.

Playing for a school team can be a huge part of a kids identity, confidence, and social experience in high school. And it can be a lot of fun! Most kids who play HS sports have no plans to play in college.

Based on the comments in this forum, it seems a kid playing in HS is more important to parents identity than the kids.

The training is way too concentrated on running and strength and the games are poor quality.
Can't see why it's so much fun (over club soccer)

Different lanes for different kids. I have a daughter starting HS next year and one who has graduated from HS. The older one chose what she wanted to do in HS for activities. We won't tell our younger one what to do. We let them make their own decisions about activities. Just get good grades. You sound like a parent overly concerned about your kids not playing HS sports.

This is a soccer chat.
One of the most inconsequential HS sports is soccer.

It is a pathway to nowhere. Except the Orthopedic Surgeon's office.

Can we get over this idea that there is nothing worthwhile besides ECNL/MLSNext/D1?

How about the pathway to happy, well-rounded human?

(Because high-level club soccer athletes don't end up injured? In my experience, that happens long before HS.)

HS soccer makes you well-rounded?

I thought it was the sports + academics

Does HS soccer not mean sports at the same place kid does academics?

Anonymous wrote:Playing isn't a right, its earned.

Anonymous wrote:Andres Iniesta, David Silva and Betnardo Silva would not make the local high school team because of their speed. Sad state of affairs...

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why play on the high school team? It doesn't help with recruiting and only increases the risk of injuries. Focus on academics and aim to get on the highest team with his club.

Recruiting? A kid that doesn't make their JV team sophomore year isn't getting recruited to play in college. Not everyone has that goal. Some just like to play soccer.

Playing for a school team can be a huge part of a kids identity, confidence, and social experience in high school. And it can be a lot of fun! Most kids who play HS sports have no plans to play in college.

Based on the comments in this forum, it seems a kid playing in HS is more important to parents identity than the kids.

The training is way too concentrated on running and strength and the games are poor quality.
Can't see why it's so much fun (over club soccer)

Different lanes for different kids. I have a daughter starting HS next year and one who has graduated from HS. The older one chose what she wanted to do in HS for activities. We won't tell our younger one what to do. We let them make their own decisions about activities. Just get good grades. You sound like a parent overly concerned about your kids not playing HS sports.

This is a soccer chat.
One of the most inconsequential HS sports is soccer.

It is a pathway to nowhere. Except the Orthopedic Surgeon's office.

Can we get over this idea that there is nothing worthwhile besides ECNL/MLSNext/D1?

How about the pathway to happy, well-rounded human?

(Because high-level club soccer athletes don't end up injured? In my experience, that happens long before HS.)

HS soccer makes you well-rounded?

I thought it was the sports + academics

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why play on the high school team? It doesn't help with recruiting and only increases the risk of injuries. Focus on academics and aim to get on the highest team with his club.

Recruiting? A kid that doesn't make their JV team sophomore year isn't getting recruited to play in college. Not everyone has that goal. Some just like to play soccer.

Playing for a school team can be a huge part of a kids identity, confidence, and social experience in high school. And it can be a lot of fun! Most kids who play HS sports have no plans to play in college.

Based on the comments in this forum, it seems a kid playing in HS is more important to parents identity than the kids.

The training is way too concentrated on running and strength and the games are poor quality.
Can't see why it's so much fun (over club soccer)

Different lanes for different kids. I have a daughter starting HS next year and one who has graduated from HS. The older one chose what she wanted to do in HS for activities. We won't tell our younger one what to do. We let them make their own decisions about activities. Just get good grades. You sound like a parent overly concerned about your kids not playing HS sports.

This is a soccer chat.
One of the most inconsequential HS sports is soccer.

It is a pathway to nowhere. Except the Orthopedic Surgeon's office.

Can we get over this idea that there is nothing worthwhile besides ECNL/MLSNext/D1?

How about the pathway to happy, well-rounded human?

(Because high-level club soccer athletes don't end up injured? In my experience, that happens long before HS.)

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why play on the high school team? It doesn't help with recruiting and only increases the risk of injuries. Focus on academics and aim to get on the highest team with his club.

Recruiting? A kid that doesn't make their JV team sophomore year isn't getting recruited to play in college. Not everyone has that goal. Some just like to play soccer.

Playing for a school team can be a huge part of a kids identity, confidence, and social experience in high school. And it can be a lot of fun! Most kids who play HS sports have no plans to play in college.

Based on the comments in this forum, it seems a kid playing in HS is more important to parents identity than the kids.

The training is way too concentrated on running and strength and the games are poor quality.
Can't see why it's so much fun (over club soccer)

Different lanes for different kids. I have a daughter starting HS next year and one who has graduated from HS. The older one chose what she wanted to do in HS for activities. We won't tell our younger one what to do. We let them make their own decisions about activities. Just get good grades. You sound like a parent overly concerned about your kids not playing HS sports.

This is a soccer chat.
One of the most inconsequential HS sports is soccer.

It is a pathway to nowhere. Except the Orthopedic Surgeon's office.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why play on the high school team? It doesn't help with recruiting and only increases the risk of injuries. Focus on academics and aim to get on the highest team with his club.

Recruiting? A kid that doesn't make their JV team sophomore year isn't getting recruited to play in college. Not everyone has that goal. Some just like to play soccer.

Playing for a school team can be a huge part of a kids identity, confidence, and social experience in high school. And it can be a lot of fun! Most kids who play HS sports have no plans to play in college.

Based on the comments in this forum, it seems a kid playing in HS is more important to parents identity than the kids.

The training is way too concentrated on running and strength and the games are poor quality.
Can't see why it's so much fun (over club soccer)

Different lanes for different kids. I have a daughter starting HS next year and one who has graduated from HS. The older one chose what she wanted to do in HS for activities. We won't tell our younger one what to do. We let them make their own decisions about activities. Just get good grades. You sound like a parent overly concerned about your kids not playing HS sports.

Anonymous wrote:Other problem at some schools, the Club coach coaching high school favors kid from club team and known at his club.

Anonymous wrote:you just had to add the jab that your son did not get cut. listen, the good and talented kids are all playing MLS Next.

Anonymous wrote:Our large public HS had over 100 kids tryout for about 48 spots (half JV half V). We do not have a Freshman team.

My understanding is that kids can only be on JV twice. Don't know if this is our school or county rule. So lots of Juniors and some Seniors were cut from Varsity (in some cases in favor of Sophomores) and were not offered a spot on JV because they had already done it twice. I think there may be 1 or 2 Juniors who didn't play JV Freshman year who are on JV. Also lots of new Sophomores on JV who didn't make it Freshman year, which is nice to see.

So yes, sometimes Juniors are on JV but due to rules, cuts, and sometimes their pride (they decline) it is not all that common. Also important to note that LOTS of good kids were cut, and cut for different reasons. From what I see my kid respects the hell out of a lot of boys who were cut (he was not) which is good to see.