Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Taking Algebra in 8th via the traditional math route is still considered advanced in other regions. Unless your child knows for sure that he wants to be a STEM major that heavily leans into math, then he will be fine. My DD got into compacted math, and while she’s not struggling, I want to pull back because she’s not at all interested in STEM. But I feel like now we’re stuck because she will have to repeat a year in math. She is going to take algebra in 7th next year so either we repeat pre algebra or algebra next year.

How are you stuck? If your didn't take prealgebra in 6th then you would have repeated the material anyway, just stretched across 2 years instead of 1. If the math is getting too hard, repeating is exactly what you should want to do.

She took pre algebra in 6th but if I don’t send her to algebra next year, she will have to repeat prealgebra. She did fine in it and had As and a high Map but she doesn’t want a career in STEM. Now she will have to repeat pre algebra or continue the accelerated path so hence we feel stuck. To OP, acceleration is not all that it’s cracked up to be and you might end up counting your blessings staying in the traditional math program down the road.

You are not stuck. She can take Alg1 >Geo>2yr Alg 2> Precal> Financial Math

Or some other combination. If she’s truly doing fine then it’s just a natural progression. If not, slow down. Repeat pre-Alg may give her the foundation she needs.

The problem with that is the way that slowdown looks to colleges, along with the boredom/cohort of 2yr Alg 2. Better to go Alg 2>Precalc>AP Calc AB>AP Calc BC or, if trying to show rigor while avoiding the second-level college courses like MVC, DiffEq & LA, Alg 2>Precalc>AP Calc BC>AP Stats. That can be tough in the Junior/Calc year, though, for a student who is not mathy. On the other hand, Stats is really valuable in many, many careers (not just STEM), and in life, in general.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I've seen several kids taking Algebra 1 and Geometry concurrently in 8th.

Why? Because they didn't get into Algebra 1 in 7th and they're trying to catch up to be on the top accelerated track by 9th?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What percent of kids are in accelerated math in grade 3?

That’s easy. 0%.

PP was probably asking about what share of kids are placed into accelerated math from grade 3.

+1 Are there data published about what % of kids are in Compact Math 4/5, Grade 7 Algebra etc (ideally by school)?

And don't forget the very important data: algebra in 6th grade!!!!!!!!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What percent of kids are in accelerated math in grade 3?

That’s easy. 0%.

PP was probably asking about what share of kids are placed into accelerated math from grade 3.

+1 Are there data published about what % of kids are in Compact Math 4/5, Grade 7 Algebra etc (ideally by school)?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Do Khan or Beast Academy at home at a comfortable pace to reach their potential. You can adjust placement every year and sometimes midyear.

Do everything at home.
Only send your kids to school for free/reduced lunch if you need and to hang out friends.

Anonymous wrote:Do Khan or Beast Academy at home at a comfortable pace to reach their potential. You can adjust placement every year and sometimes midyear.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What percent of kids are in accelerated math in grade 3?

That’s easy. 0%.

PP was probably asking about what share of kids are placed into accelerated math from grade 3.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What percent of kids are in accelerated math in grade 3?

That’s easy. 0%.

Anonymous wrote:What percent of kids are in accelerated math in grade 3?

Anonymous wrote:I've seen several kids taking Algebra 1 and Geometry concurrently in 8th.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Taking Algebra in 8th via the traditional math route is still considered advanced in other regions. Unless your child knows for sure that he wants to be a STEM major that heavily leans into math, then he will be fine. My DD got into compacted math, and while she’s not struggling, I want to pull back because she’s not at all interested in STEM. But I feel like now we’re stuck because she will have to repeat a year in math. She is going to take algebra in 7th next year so either we repeat pre algebra or algebra next year.

How are you stuck? If your didn't take prealgebra in 6th then you would have repeated the material anyway, just stretched across 2 years instead of 1. If the math is getting too hard, repeating is exactly what you should want to do.

She took pre algebra in 6th but if I don’t send her to algebra next year, she will have to repeat prealgebra. She did fine in it and had As and a high Map but she doesn’t want a career in STEM. Now she will have to repeat pre algebra or continue the accelerated path so hence we feel stuck. To OP, acceleration is not all that it’s cracked up to be and you might end up counting your blessings staying in the traditional math program down the road.

You are not stuck. She can take Alg1 >Geo>2yr Alg 2> Precal> Financial Math

Or some other combination. If she’s truly doing fine then it’s just a natural progression. If not, slow down. Repeat pre-Alg may give her the foundation she needs.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Taking Algebra in 8th via the traditional math route is still considered advanced in other regions. Unless your child knows for sure that he wants to be a STEM major that heavily leans into math, then he will be fine. My DD got into compacted math, and while she’s not struggling, I want to pull back because she’s not at all interested in STEM. But I feel like now we’re stuck because she will have to repeat a year in math. She is going to take algebra in 7th next year so either we repeat pre algebra or algebra next year.

How are you stuck? If your didn't take prealgebra in 6th then you would have repeated the material anyway, just stretched across 2 years instead of 1. If the math is getting too hard, repeating is exactly what you should want to do.

She took pre algebra in 6th but if I don’t send her to algebra next year, she will have to repeat prealgebra. She did fine in it and had As and a high Map but she doesn’t want a career in STEM. Now she will have to repeat pre algebra or continue the accelerated path so hence we feel stuck. To OP, acceleration is not all that it’s cracked up to be and you might end up counting your blessings staying in the traditional math program down the road.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Taking Algebra in 8th via the traditional math route is still considered advanced in other regions. Unless your child knows for sure that he wants to be a STEM major that heavily leans into math, then he will be fine. My DD got into compacted math, and while she’s not struggling, I want to pull back because she’s not at all interested in STEM. But I feel like now we’re stuck because she will have to repeat a year in math. She is going to take algebra in 7th next year so either we repeat pre algebra or algebra next year.

How are you stuck? If your didn't take prealgebra in 6th then you would have repeated the material anyway, just stretched across 2 years instead of 1. If the math is getting too hard, repeating is exactly what you should want to do.

She took pre algebra in 6th but if I don’t send her to algebra next year, she will have to repeat prealgebra. She did fine in it and had As and a high Map but she doesn’t want a career in STEM. Now she will have to repeat pre algebra or continue the accelerated path so hence we feel stuck. To OP, acceleration is not all that it’s cracked up to be and you might end up counting your blessings staying in the traditional math program down the road.