Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 17:40     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:Where does the cross admit data come from? If it's Parchment then it's unreliable data...


What do you base that on? I've heard that the cross admit data is very accurate for schools with large applicant figures, but less so for smaller schools.
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 17:22     Subject: Re:Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:UVA, Michigan, and UCLA as high as they are because of in-state students. I mean, of course you're going to pick UVA if your other choices are William and Mary and JMU. And Michigan? I mean, there really is no other option for paying in-state. You can't compare those to privates. What an illogical way to "rank" colleges.


+1

The inclusion of state schools makes this list meaningless.


Stanford is 40% instate
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 17:17     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Sounds like the Crimson marketing machine at its full gear. A smart strategy to get their name out in hopes of attracting future customers. Hook, line, sinker?....maybe, maybe not
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 15:20     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:Data is biased since only a small segment of the overall population would pay for their services.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Where does the cross admit data come from? If it's Parchment then it's unreliable data...


Crimson sourced their own cross admit data from their students and other counselors


They’ve gone beyond to source from other areas as well. For the most part the ranking aligns with what we expect, maybe except the 11 - 15 ranks that speak to value of top public’s and schools w particularly strong alumni base
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 14:45     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Data is biased since only a small segment of the overall population would pay for their services.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Where does the cross admit data come from? If it's Parchment then it's unreliable data...


Crimson sourced their own cross admit data from their students and other counselors
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 13:02     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:But I dont really care about Yale vs Princeton.

I would be more interested in kids who pick UT Austin over Rice. Or Rice over Northwestern. Or Northwestern over Notre Dame. Or Notre Dame over Dartmouth.


The ranking takes into account all the cross admit yields between ranked schools
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 13:02     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:Where does the cross admit data come from? If it's Parchment then it's unreliable data...


Crimson sourced their own cross admit data from their students and other counselors
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 11:03     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
But I dont really care about Yale vs Princeton.

I would be more interested in kids who pick UT Austin over Rice. Or Rice over Northwestern. Or Northwestern over Notre Dame. Or Notre Dame over Dartmouth.
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 11:00     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
I'm a little interested in this, only because it takes away the yield rates etc that highly depend on ED or SCEA tips.
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 09:48     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
This reflects the preponderance of interest in majoring in STEM.
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 09:10     Subject: Re:Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:UVA, Michigan, and UCLA as high as they are because of in-state students. I mean, of course you're going to pick UVA if your other choices are William and Mary and JMU. And Michigan? I mean, there really is no other option for paying in-state. You can't compare those to privates. What an illogical way to "rank" colleges.


+1

The inclusion of state schools makes this list meaningless.
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 08:55     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Where does the cross admit data come from? If it's Parchment then it's unreliable data...
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 08:38     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:Schools I would totally avoid now given the blatant anti-semitic nonsense at
Harvard, Yale, Stanford, Columbia, Brown, Penn, Princeton, Dartmouth, Northwestern, UT Austin, UCLA, MIT, Emory, USC. Wow!!
I'm sure more colleges will join this list soon.


There's always an idiot in the crowd.

To whomever posted the above absurdity--nobody believes you.
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 08:36     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:This tracks with our experience getting to know actual Vanderbilt students (DC is enrolled now) -- the student really, really do want to be there. They are not sad that they're not at USC, or Brown, or Chicago. Vanderbilt was their target all along ... regardless of where it falls on this year's USNWR list.

They know it ranks lower than Brown, and the current students we know don't seem to care because they're completely different products. That's why they (and so many other enrolled students) do ED, even before test optional came onto the scene.

I would guess the situation is the same at some of the other very distinctive schools, like Dartmouth and Columbia.

vs., I could personally see the same individual being agnostic between, say, Duke and Northwestern.



What does the last sentence mean ?

If I understand, then this poster doesn't have a clue.
Anonymous
Post 05/05/2024 02:06     Subject: Crimson - college ranking based on cross admit yield data
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Always question the data. There is no way they could’ve gotten statistically significant data on cross yields. Therefore, this list is useless.


Agreed. Source of data questionable.


Which school is the OP promoting?



Duke