Anonymous
Post 04/23/2024 14:54     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
I wandered over here to get ASA boys info (and that's how the conversation started, with discussion of MLSN). Girls parents managed to take it over!
Anonymous
Post 04/03/2024 16:01     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:The one where the child likes the team and coach best.


Agreed. These parents are the ones that want the ECNL. Most girls at 12u could care less. They would rather be with friends. These leagues dont matter until they turn 15 to 16 years old. But we got parents living they there kids putting them thru stress and will burn them out before it counts
Anonymous
Post 04/02/2024 23:05     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
The one where the child likes the team and coach best.
Anonymous
Post 04/02/2024 11:18     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
2011 ASA second team has a few good players and then some rec level player and since they couldn't fill the roster they are having 2012 play up.




Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


The Alex that you are referring too are you looking at the right ASA. The second team is playing up anger 11 v 11. So in reality you are comparing the third team. SYC does not play up in 2012. They're top team is just starting. So of your saying SYC 2nd team is better than ASA second team make sure you are comparing apples to apples. The 2nd SYC team is better than the 3rd Alex team.
So reality of the story is. You want to go to the second team that is giving best chance for developement and get the experience needed to make top team. If you look at Alexandria the top and second team is being heavily recruited for ECNL and GA because of the developement.
Anonymous
Post 04/02/2024 11:16     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
2011 National League Standing


Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


At least for the 2012s
ASA 2 plays up a year in NCSL D3 they lost 4W 1D 4L
SYC 2 plays EDP D1 their record is 5W 1D 3L
Where are you getting your data from?
Anonymous
Post 04/02/2024 11:12     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


The Alex that you are referring too are you looking at the right ASA. The second team is playing up anger 11 v 11. So in reality you are comparing the third team. SYC does not play up in 2012. They're top team is just starting. So of your saying SYC 2nd team is better than ASA second team make sure you are comparing apples to apples. The 2nd SYC team is better than the 3rd Alex team.
So reality of the story is. You want to go to the second team that is giving best chance for developement and get the experience needed to make top team. If you look at Alexandria the top and second team is being heavily recruited for ECNL and GA because of the developement.


At least for the 2012s
ASA 2 (red) plays up a year in NCSL D3. Record 4W 1D 4L
SYC 2 (pre-MSL II) plays EDP D1. Record 5W 1D 3L
FVU can’t be any worse, given that they are a three club combine.
Anonymous
Post 04/02/2024 10:14     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


The Alex that you are referring too are you looking at the right ASA. The second team is playing up anger 11 v 11. So in reality you are comparing the third team. SYC does not play up in 2012. They're top team is just starting. So of your saying SYC 2nd team is better than ASA second team make sure you are comparing apples to apples. The 2nd SYC team is better than the 3rd Alex team.
So reality of the story is. You want to go to the second team that is giving best chance for developement and get the experience needed to make top team. If you look at Alexandria the top and second team is being heavily recruited for ECNL and GA because of the developement.
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 23:15     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


At least for the 2012s
ASA 2 plays up a year in NCSL D3 they lost 4W 1D 4L
SYC 2 plays EDP D1 their record is 5W 1D 3L
Where are you getting your data from?
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 22:30     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Top team is not always the best. You have to see if your player fits in with the group and the coaching style.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You should be looking at which second team has the best coach so your kid can make the top team. All second teams are what they are. Second teams. It comes down to which second team has the best coach


Sounds like most comments are suggesting to go with 2nd team ASA or SYC?
In my experience it’s always better to be in the 1st team. You get the most experienced coaches and the more priority within the club.

Not going to say it's not better being on the first team but to be real majority of the kids on second teams are not ready to be on top team. Very few if any will get moved up to top team and when they do they will have very limited playing time.
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 21:55     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You should be looking at which second team has the best coach so your kid can make the top team. All second teams are what they are. Second teams. It comes down to which second team has the best coach


Sounds like most comments are suggesting to go with 2nd team ASA or SYC?
In my experience it’s always better to be in the 1st team. You get the most experienced coaches and the more priority within the club.

Not going to say it's not better being on the first team but to be real majority of the kids on second teams are not ready to be on top team. Very few if any will get moved up to top team and when they do they will have very limited playing time.
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 19:42     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


What age group are you assuming half will leave?


I see the OP mentioned 2012. Syc 2012 1st team is very strong and hard to move up unless a player moves or get picked up by an academy.


Where would those half go? R they hoping to get on MLSNext or ECNL teams?
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 19:42     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
I would go with FVU because it is the top team
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 19:22     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


What age group are you assuming half will leave?


I see the OP mentioned 2012. Syc 2012 1st team is very strong and hard to move up unless a player moves or get picked up by an academy.
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 18:49     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Anonymous wrote:Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.


What age group are you assuming half will leave?
Anonymous
Post 04/01/2024 18:42     Subject: FVU vs SYC-2 or ASA 2
Take a look at the current standing for SYC 2 and ASA 2.

SYC 2 is currently first in the league with 8 W and 1 L
ASA 2 is 2nd to last in the league with 2 W and 7 L

Fall will be different. Half the players on SYC 2 will be leaving.