Anonymous wrote:The best nurses become NPs and PAs. The worst doctors become PCPs. I’m fine with NPs.

Anonymous wrote:My DS and DIL are physicians. Their time spend in school, residency and board testing cannot be compared to a NP or PA.

Anonymous wrote:My primary doctor is an NP! Never had a more attentive and thoughtful diagnostician — much better than any MD I’ve gone to as an GP. And I’m not alone. She is full and not taking new patients (and a number of her patients are doctors!).

Anonymous wrote:The devolution of the US medical system to increasingly poor quality levels is the fruit of corporatization, abetted by the appalling power insurance companies have been permitted to amass over what constitutes “appropriate” care. Corporate-owned practices (which increasingly are the only thing you can find if you want to use your preposterously overpriced insurance) hire non-physicians to do what properly is physician’s work because the non-physicians are more readily available, are significantly cheaper and allow vastly increased financial leverage and a concomitant increase in profit. People say that their non-physician “provider” is great and will refer them if anything is “serious.” The problem is that few patients have even the slightest ability to determine how “serious” their condition is; regardless of their misplaced self confidence, non-physicians lack the training to avoid mistakes that a physician would catch. Given the rate of physician error, it is terrifying to think how much non-physicians may be missing. I am alive today because a physician noticed a deadly skin cancer when I was in for something else entirely. I have very little confidence that a non-physician would have caught that.

Anonymous wrote:The devolution of the US medical system to increasingly poor quality levels is the fruit of corporatization, abetted by the appalling power insurance companies have been permitted to amass over what constitutes “appropriate” care. Corporate-owned practices (which increasingly are the only thing you can find if you want to use your preposterously overpriced insurance) hire non-physicians to do what properly is physician’s work because the non-physicians are more readily available, are significantly cheaper and allow vastly increased financial leverage and a concomitant increase in profit. People say that their non-physician “provider” is great and will refer them if anything is “serious.” The problem is that few patients have even the slightest ability to determine how “serious” their condition is; regardless of their misplaced self confidence, non-physicians lack the training to avoid mistakes that a physician would catch. Given the rate of physician error, it is terrifying to think how much non-physicians may be missing. I am alive today because a physician noticed a deadly skin cancer when I was in for something else entirely. I have very little confidence that a non-physician would have caught that.

Anonymous wrote:The devolution of the US medical system to increasingly poor quality levels is the fruit of corporatization, abetted by the appalling power insurance companies have been permitted to amass over what constitutes “appropriate” care. Corporate-owned practices (which increasingly are the only thing you can find if you want to use your preposterously overpriced insurance) hire non-physicians to do what properly is physician’s work because the non-physicians are more readily available, are significantly cheaper and allow vastly increased financial leverage and a concomitant increase in profit. People say that their non-physician “provider” is great and will refer them if anything is “serious.” The problem is that few patients have even the slightest ability to determine how “serious” their condition is; regardless of their misplaced self confidence, non-physicians lack the training to avoid mistakes that a physician would catch. Given the rate of physician error, it is terrifying to think how much non-physicians may be missing. I am alive today because a physician noticed a deadly skin cancer when I was in for something else entirely. I have very little confidence that a non-physician would have caught that.

Anonymous wrote:My primary doctor is an NP! Never had a more attentive and thoughtful diagnostician — much better than any MD I’ve gone to as an GP. And I’m not alone. She is full and not taking new patients (and a number of her patients are doctors!).

Anonymous wrote:Why is it so hard to see a doctor? So many practices want to stick you with an NP or some other APP its just ridiculous.
My last visit I specifically asked to see an MD only to be called the day before to be told that I would be seeing the NP.
Nurse Practioners have no where near the training that a physician has, its not the same as seeing an MD or a DO.
Vent over !

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is horrifying to me how many people are unaware of how poorly trained the far majority of NP's are. They can get their degrees from 100% online programs (AKA degree mills). They may be absolutely lovely in person, but the bottom line is that they don't know what they don't know. It is an absolute travesty what they have done to the field of medicine. Primary care is one of the most difficult things because 99% of the time, everything is fine. But you need to see thousands of cases of normal in order to detect the abnormal.

Exactly, I work in medicine. NPs are poorly trained and are not cost effective. The patient is billed at the same rate as an MD but the reimbursement to the provider is lower. So the only person that wins is the insurance company. NPs order more tests and do a lot of unnecessary things because they do not know what they're doing.
I don't want to see an NP because I'm alarmed at the pace at which their scope of practice is increasing. Insurance groups are pushing the NP model because its a huge profit margin for them, but telling people that an NP is the equivalent of seeing an MD/DO trained in family medicine is disingenuous.
NPs misdiagnose all the damn time simply because they do not have the breadth of knowledge to know when something isn't right. I rarely go to the doctor but when I do I want to be seen by a physician.