Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If you don't have a child with a sleep disorder, you have no clue.
Exactly, most of the people giving their kids melatonin have no clue. Most people aren’t giving it under advice from a doctor, they are giving it because they want their kids knocked out at 7pm or earlier.
Says who? Is there a study that shows who uses melatonin and for what? My kid has a developmental diagnosis and has taken melatonin for many years. I don’t know anyone who uses it with their child regularly without physician guidance.
I mean, most parents I know are using it without physician guidance. I'm one of them, sort of. One of my kids takes it per her doctor to help her after ADHD meds. The other two take it because it makes bedtime easier, and with three kids, I'm pushing that button. The doctor is aware, but hasn't technically blessed it, or told us to stop. Compared to the crap our parents used to give us (soda, candy, chips, artificial dyes, etc.) this just isn't that bad. And if it is, fine, it'll be one of the many many things I've failed at as a parent.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If you don't have a child with a sleep disorder, you have no clue.
Exactly, most of the people giving their kids melatonin have no clue. Most people aren’t giving it under advice from a doctor, they are giving it because they want their kids knocked out at 7pm or earlier.
Says who? Is there a study that shows who uses melatonin and for what? My kid has a developmental diagnosis and has taken melatonin for many years. I don’t know anyone who uses it with their child regularly without physician guidance.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:If you don't have a child with a sleep disorder, you have no clue.
Exactly, most of the people giving their kids melatonin have no clue. Most people aren’t giving it under advice from a doctor, they are giving it because they want their kids knocked out at 7pm or earlier.
Anonymous wrote:If you don't have a child with a sleep disorder, you have no clue.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:this link is about accidental overdoses because it got left out. Not saying it’s not effectiveAnonymous wrote:https://www.npr.org/2022/06/03/1102933012/melatonin-poisoning-kids-sleep-aid-overdose
It is also highly ineffective and not studied to be safe for children in the long-term. stop using it. use things like magnesium or tart cherry juice.
There are no long-term studies about safety or correct dosage. https://www.childrens.com/health-wellness/is-melatonin-safe-for-kids https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/18/parenting/melatonin-sleep-kids.html
It should not be used for anything other than irregular sleep disruptions and only in the short-term, if at all, for neurotypical children. If your child is having that many issues falling asleep you need to get a sleep study, a neuropsych exam, limit TV or use blue light blockers, try a bedtime snack (one with protein, some carbs, and foods with natural melatonin like cherries or bananas) and manage expectations around sleep. The worst thing to happen to kids sleep are the mommy bloggers and sleep trainers who make it seem like every kid must be in bed by 7pm and/or sleep 12 hours overnight.
They arent even regulated so you have no idea what dose is being provided. Its ridiculous to give a child some OTC product and not be willing to do anything else. There is no way 15-30% of kids need melatonin to fall asleep- its not the kids who are the problem.
Agree. 100%.
Anonymous wrote:I read that most people use way too much melatonin -- and the more you take the less effective it becomes.